4 ms·
I've long wondered if the best ad blocker would be a client that simply randomly clicks ads instead of blocking them. If you send fake clicks and spoof looking
by echelon 10y ago
I've long wondered if the best ad blocker would be a client that simply randomly clicks ads instead of blocking them. If you send fake clicks and spoof looking like real activity, that will pressure both advertisers and the websites that display ads. If millions of people do this...
- riprowan 10y agoThe problem is that while this might work great on a large scale, it breaks down at the individual level: why would I want all that ad-clicking activity associated with my account / cookie / IP?
- throwaway13337 10y agoBecause you don't want the trackers to know your real activity? It's pretty common now to do things like intentionally tagging the wrong friends in facebook because people are paranoid that facebook knows too much. Even with non-techie people. They're creeped out. Throwing off retargeting is something a lot of people might want to do.
- supernumerary 10y agoThe supposed value of the ad-clicking activity profile is that it pertains to you, if a bot is making your ad-click decisions your profile gets scrambled, ostensibly making you harder to target when ad-tech reaches new heights of persuasiveness...
- anexprogrammer 10y agoIf you're interested in everything, you may as well have clicked nothing. Your ad profile becomes meaningless. It certainly isn't representative any more as you're lost in noise.
- elcct 10y agoOnce your client "clicks" all the ads suddenly all meta data about you becomes useless. That is much better than simply not showing ads.
- rb808 10y agoI get a cheap thrill out of clicking ads to make people pay. Trump ad ... click Comcast ... click Ambulance chasing lawyer ... click click click So that would be better than random - a plugin that clicks the ads for things you don't like or aren't interested in.
- ssharp 10y agoIf you really want to put a dent in things, search for medical issues and click the law firm ads. I've seen clicks costing in the high hundreds.
- Bombthecat 10y agoFor real? I also think that prices are extremely inflated. Even stuff which shows like hundred people a day costs you 8 dollar per click. No amount of selling will you get back the money. Imho something is wrong there...
- nemild 10y agoYou'd be surprised - it often implies the lifetime value of the potential customer is exceptionally high, despite low conversion rates (a medical lawyer is a good example, as are insurance products with high stickiness).
- ssharp 10y agoI've never done work for a law firm but have talked to some and the small shops specializing in easy cases like DUI's and personal bankruptcies can pretty easily fill up their billable hours by turning an AdSense campaign on and not coming close to eating away their margin. I'd guess on the keywords where law firms are spending hundreds per click, you're dealing with malpractice and personal injury cases. Those cases are likely to be done on contingent and can have pretty huge upsides. I'd think a well-run firm would have some idea of the expected value of those types of cases and can spend accordingly to acquire clients. Considering how targeted search ads are compared to how these firms normally advertise -- local TV, radio, billboards, busses, etc. the costs probably aren't radically different than they're used to spending on advertising.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoWell there's https://adnauseam.io/ https://adnauseam.io/ Sends a click to everything blocked in uBlock Origin.
- c0nducktr 10y agoThis actually exists. I tried it out in a separate browser profile for a while, seems to work well, but I've since gone back to ublock origin. https://adnauseam.io/ https://adnauseam.io/
- UweSchmidt 10y agoIn a brazen attack on privacy, intrusive javascript tracks mouse movement, behaviour etc. and can detect if it's a human that does the clicking or your ad blocker/clicker. Next up might be eye tracking through the webcam, do you want an BS-armsrace with the ad industry or can we just block all that nonsense? If you sell shoes, put up some shoe ads with an affiliate link, shouldn't that work good enough? You'd save millions by not being susceptible to attacks like the one in the article.
- rbanffy 10y agoA VM running the an OS, a browser with some software identifying the interesting banners and clicking on the while they move the mouse and scroll the window in human-like ways. Imagine now a beefy box with a couple hundred VMs running on it. Now imagine fake cameras catching a rendered environment and tracking virtual eyes that move according to what the camera would expect. If you want ad networks that rely on cameras to detect your presence capturing your image, imagine installing a fake camera driver on your PC that shows a rendered person in a rendered environment doing random browsing. edit: last part was unclear
- finid 10y agoYour imagination, my friend, scares me.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoYes, I'm thrilled about running all that compute on my hardware. Contrary to what many people in adtech and web development seem to believe, electricity isn't free. Not to mention such silly concerns as worldwide resource usage and climate change. Basically, that's why advertising needs to be reigned in hard, squeezed with regulations until it starts to behave. Because it's a zero-sum game on enough fronts to make everyones' lives worse if it's not fought against hard.
- ma2rten 10y agoI don't think it would work. Let's say out of every click 20% come from your fake clicker. Advertisers would simply charge 20% less, the net effect would be the same for both advertisers and publishers. Especially on mobile there are already accidental clicks that have that effect.
- hoprocker 10y agoThis isn't for ads, but if you want to obfuscate Google's profile of you in the background, you can check out NYU's TrackMeNot: https://cs.nyu.edu/trackmenot/ https://cs.nyu.edu/trackmenot/