4 ms·
My take is that it's still early days, but: Over the next decade more and more companies will be building out their own SoC-type solutions, either as FPGA or A
by cmrdporcupine 10y ago
My take is that it's still early days, but:
Over the next decade more and more companies will be building out their own SoC-type solutions, either as FPGA or ASIC.
The cost of developing custom SoCs is going to drop.
In this context licensing an ARM core every time you approach this problem is going to end up being a major part of the cost and hassle.
Having a quality open ISA that can be adapted by anybody will be extremely useful.
I don't work in the processor industry, but that's how I see it from the outside. And the work on RISC-V so far is very impressive.
- StringyBob 10y agoThe cost per transistor is going down every generation, but the NRE cost of developing a SoC is going up and up. Pretty much doubling every manufacturing generation (e.g. 40nm -> 28nm -> 16nm). The cpu is actually a relatively small chunk of that cost these days, but once in volume production even this is dwarfed by software development costs...
- valarauca1 10y agobut once in volume production even this is dwarfed by software development costs... This is one of the strongest arguments for RISC-V Not only do you avoid licensing costs, but the ELF files you have from the 2-3year old model will still execute on your new model chip. All one needs to do is dynamically link against their new special instructions.
- petra 10y agoWhy doesn't software reuse between generations work?
- gchadwick 10y agoOne of the major costs in IP development is verification, when someone buys an ARM core they're not buying it purely because of the ecosystem or the performance/power etc. It's also because they know the core is verified. They also know they can receive support when things go wrong. You may be able to get a RISC-V core for free, but will you get a fully verified RISC-V core including support for free? Should RISC-V become a success then I imagine you'll see ARM dropping prices and perhaps core licensing will be a major cost in producing an SoC (as I understand it it's rather cheap right now, relative to full development cost) however you're still going to see people buying cores off established IP companies to get that verification and support. Now linux gets plenty of free bug-hunting and fixing, most people in need of a linux kernel will be off to kernel.org rather than paying a company to supply a custom one. I'm not sure you'd see the same thing for a processor core. Verification requirements are a whole lot higher than they are for linux.