6 ms·
The per-watt numbers may sound great, but these are still apples and oranges energy sources. While there are some area where one can certainly replace the othe
by sandworm101 10y ago
The per-watt numbers may sound great, but these are still apples and oranges energy sources. While there are some area where one can certainly replace the other (electrical grids etc) there are others (shipping) where the gap remains monumental. In terms of energy density (35ish MJ/L) and storage (a box) diesel fuels look to remain king for a while.
One downside of cheap solar might be a drop in crude prices, resulting in its more frivolous use. I'd hate to see improvements in shipping meant to conserve fuel, and thereby lower carbon emissions, be set aside once fuel becomes cheap again. We need to watch for this and, perhaps, get regs in place to ensure it is burnt as sparingly as possible.
- ryao 10y agoThey are not apples and oranges from the perspective of investors. Those people want to invest their money for the highest return. If solar gives a higher return than oil, then their money will go there.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoSolar doesn't compete with oil. It competes with natural gas, nuclear, and coal (any fuel with a marginal cost really, except oil, unless you're somewhere remote). And it is winning. [1] [2] As more light vehicles move over to electric vehicles, we're going to need more clean energy. We should build every kWh of solar and wind generation we can. > One downside of cheap solar might be a drop in crude prices, resulting in its more frivolous use. I'd hate to see improvements in shipping meant to conserve fuel, and thereby lower carbon emissions, be set aside once fuel become cheap again. We need to watch for this and, perhaps, get regs in place to ensure it is burnt as sparingly as possible. Well, I mean, that's kinda the whole point of Tesla Motors, you see? Its an electric car, for sure. But its not a Leaf, its not a Bolt, its not an EV1. Its the best damn car you can get. Someone called Katy Perry's stage "The Tesla of tour stages" [3]. That's how you win against oil. We didn't run out of rocks when we left the stone age behind. We found something better. [1] http://ilsr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Screenshot-2014-03-25-14.36.08.png http://ilsr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Screenshot-2014-0... [2] https://solarpowerrocks.com/infographics/solar-infographic-state-solar-investment-returns/ https://solarpowerrocks.com/infographics/solar-infographic-s... [3] https://twitter.com/katyperry/status/444228348319784960 https://twitter.com/katyperry/status/444228348319784960 "Omg someone just called my stage the TESLA of tour stages... It was like, the coolest modern compliment ever."
- sandworm101 10y agoOil competes with solar wherever a diesel generator powers something that might be powered by solar, and there are a lot of diesel generators out there. Oil also competes with oil for home heating in many areas (electricity v. oil). In my world, my parent's new retirement castle is powered by an off-grid solar/diesel system. Solar isn't putting up much of a fight (Canada+winter+mountains = maybe 2hours of direct sunlight on panels).
- toomuchtodo 10y agoVery little electrical generation, at least in the US, is from petroleum of any sort (less than 1%). http://www.npr.org/2015/09/10/319535020/coal-gas-nuclear-hydro-how-your-state-generates-power http://www.npr.org/2015/09/10/319535020/coal-gas-nuclear-hyd... EDIT: We have far more coal and natural gas fired generation to displace than off grid petroleum generation.
- sandworm101 10y agoLol, read my first comment re grids. There is plenty of power out there not on grids. And 5+ percent of carbon emissions come from ships, which are tricky for solar and are certainly not tied to grids. And aircraft ... apples and oranges.
- codecamper 10y agoI think if you guys did the math, you'd find that some cheap chinese solar panels + a battery would be way cheaper than running a generator. (For the battery: a tesla powerwall 2 if you can get one, or sort of build your own from LifePo4 batteries & an http://electrodacus.com/ http://electrodacus.com/ controller) Have a look at electrodacus. He lives in Canada. Powered 100% by solar. He even plans to heat with solar, but that requires a specially built house.
- sandworm101 10y agoBut good luck running a half-dozen saws on a construction site during a canadian winter. Not every diesel generator senario has the time/space/light for a solad rig.
- wallace_f 10y ago>One downside of cheap solar might be a drop in crude prices, resulting in its more frivolous use. I'd hate to see improvements in shipping meant to conserve fuel, and thereby lower carbon emissions, be set aside once fuel becomes cheap again. We need to watch for this and, perhaps, get regs in place to ensure it is burnt as sparingly as possible. There is R&D with deploying wind power to help reduce fuel costs on cargo vessels. In some ways it makes a lot of sense: You have no loss in converting mechanical energy into electric charge, then back into mechanical energy, and also losses in transmission (as is the case with traditional wind - and there's a big difference in efficiency when you crunch the numbers). On vessels, it's just straight mechanical energy->mechanical energy, and energy density is also very high. It's a crude solution, but also elegant and clean solution[1]. Business needs incentives to move on these kinds of renewable technology opportunities that exist but are not exploited because the fruit hangs too high for the free-market alone to justify the cost for the charity of the environment. My own biased opinion is that one good solution might be a carbon tax, which could align private business incentives with optimal public outcomes. 1: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/28/science/earth/cargo-ship-designers-turn-to-wind-to-cut-cost-and-emissions.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/28/science/earth/cargo-ship-d...
- theparanoid 10y agoWind powered shipping is also called sailing.
- wallace_f 10y agoSure, well probably not in this case. Not sure what the point you're trying to make is, but the research being done is to make the ships supplemented by wind power (one such ship deployed a parachute-like sail). They're not actually capable of navigating alone by the wind as is the case with sail boats.
- jnordwick 10y agoA parachute like sail? Absolute craziness. If only... http://kimrobertsmarine.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Victory-under-Spinnaker-lg..jpg http://kimrobertsmarine.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Victo...
- floatrock 10y agoSomething like a quarter of US energy consumption is in transportation. As you mentioned, the storage density of electricity still far lags behind petroleum. It also takes an hour at a supercharger to "fill up" an electric car vs. a few minutes at a pump. Hydrogen and biofuels (in the US) are generally seen as energy sinks (they take more energy to produce than they give off), but what they lose in conversion they make up for in suitability towards a transportation fuel. The point is transportation is a tricky application for renewables, and the amount of storage needed to make it work is mind-boggling huge, even assuming decades of compounding growth. According to LLNL [1], the US consumption of energy in transportation is 27.7 quads. A quads is a measure of a lot of kWh. Specifically, 27.7 quads is 8,118,068,643 MWh. Tesla's gigafactory is slated to produce 35 GWh worth of battery storage production per year at full capacity (slated for 2018) [2]. So, our annual energy consumption in transportation alone is 8,120,000 GWh, and our largest factory will, in two years, produce about 35 GWh per year worth of capacity. Lets assume some compounding magic and imagine the gigafactory will be only the first of many self-replicating automated tesla factories. Say we grow our capacity at 5% every year... after two decades, in 2038, that puts annual capacity at 92 GWh, with a cumulative installed capacity of 1,250 GWh. We're trying to hit 8,120,000 GWh. That's not gonna work. Okay, lets assume instead of 5% growth, we somehow get 50% growth (we need more gigafactories, but lets say we also get better at building batteries, something closer to moore's law). Now after two decades of 50% growth, in 2038 our new annual storage production is 116,000 GWh, with something like 350,000 GWh of cumulative installed capacity. Still short of 8,120,000 GWh. (But this exponential growth is only starting to hockey-stick upwards at this 50% growth... we WOULD hit our goal within the third decade) So, even assuming very optimistic conditions where the storage capacity production is exponentially growing, consumption stays flat, and capacity does not degrade once installed, electric cars still will barely make a dent in petroleum usage in transportation after two decades. I hope I made some error on my metaphorical napkin here (like a battery can be recharged... if you have 365 Wh of annual consumption, that can technically be serviced by a 1 Wh battery being used every day, right? So we don't quite need to match the 8,120,000 number exactly, right? Maybe like 1/10 or 1/100th of that?) Because if I didn't, that means we need an Apollo-level effort sustained for a few decades to have a meaningful path off fossil fuels. [1]: https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/content/assets/images/energy/us/Energy_US_2015.png https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/content/assets/images/energy/us/... [2]: https://www.tesla.com/gigafactory https://www.tesla.com/gigafactory
- beefield 10y ago>One downside of cheap solar might be a drop in crude prices, resulting in its more frivolous use. I'd argue this logic is backwards. Only way solar can cause a drop in oil prices is by reducing it's demand. And if it is reducing the demand of oil, then the total demand of oil can't increase. Further, only sustainable way to keep oil unused in ground is to get the market price of oil so low that nobody bothers to dig it up. I mean, if the oil price is $500 per barrel, there is simply no international agreement that will stop people and countries drilling oil from every possible site from north to south pole.