6 ms·
What I really want is for my state (SSD, RAM, maybe the CPU, but probably not the GPU) to be easily detachable from my human interface devices (keyboard, mouse,
by lisper 10y ago
What I really want is for my state (SSD, RAM, maybe the CPU, but probably not the GPU) to be easily detachable from my human interface devices (keyboard, mouse, display). I want to be able to use a desktop in one place, then unplug a small unit which contains the aforementioned state (i.e. the equivalent of a sleeping laptop but with no keyboard or display), carry that someplace else, plug it in to a different set of HID devices, and pick up exactly where I left off. And, of course, one possible set of HID devices would be something like a present-day laptop so that I can continue working while en-route. But there is no reason why the business end of a computer needs to be in the same enclosure as the HID, and a lot of reasons why it should not be.
I can do much of this now with a USB3 SSD, but the problem is that there is no way to "sleep" such a configuration. To change locations I need to shut down in one place and reboot in another.
- dopeboy 10y agoThis is exactly what I want. Well articulated.
- meesterdude 10y agoI do this with a vertical docked MBP. I mostly am on my own display/keyboard, but when i need to go somewhere i can just sleep it and go.
- lisper 10y agoYes, that's what I do too. But if I could detach the keyboard and display then I could fit what remains in my pocket instead of having to shlep it around in my backpack.
- Clubber 10y agoIf they could do this with a phone (x86/x64), or at least something with a cellular radio, they would hit it out of the park. I want a laptop that is just a dock with a phone slot in it. A desktop as well. Slide the phone in and instant form factor change with ports, GPU, extra HDD/SDD, etc.
- pdimitar 10y agoPart of this is promised by Microsoft with the upcoming Surface Phone (hinted at April 2017).
- wbillingsley 10y agoI believe that's supposed to be the unique selling point of Microsoft's continuum approach to mobile. Where at the mo they need to overcome the issue that desktop apps are x86 but for battery reasons mobile apps need to run on ARM
- Clubber 10y agoIs it possible for x86/x64 to approach the efficiency of ARM over time, or does the CISC vs RISC make that nearly impossible? I read a while ago that Intel abandoned their mobile chips.
- petecox 10y agoI'm sceptical a phone can emulate high-performance x86 software at the speed of a Core i7 but is Photoshop-on-a-phone the use case for most office workers? Office runs natively ARM but businesses have a few productivity apps tied to x86 (e.g. requiring a P3 or higher) that shouldn't tax the CPU too much.
- yakult 10y agoI would go a bit further: I want my state to be inside a seamless hardware agnostic VM, that I can access anywhere through public terminals that I only partially trust. I would have the option of either having my storage with me that I plug in, or in the cloud and I just provide 2fa. My device would have a cpu/gpu/etc befitting a mobile device, and the most barebones / untrusted terminals would just be screen/inputs/charger, but in better environments the terminal can optionally provide extra oomph if permitted.
- bane 10y agoTurns out these are kind of available today https://aws.amazon.com/workspaces/ https://aws.amazon.com/workspaces/ https://liquidsky.tv/ https://liquidsky.tv/ http://www.nvidia.com/object/cloud-gaming.html http://www.nvidia.com/object/cloud-gaming.html etc.
- yakult 10y agoIt's all niche ptoducts with no reach, though. I'd like something mass-consumer-oriented and ubiquous, so I can actually get (roughly) the same experience everywhere from bus stops and coffee shops to my office. The current situation is like pre-ipod mp3 players: the tech is all there, the ux and marketing effort is not.
- bluejekyll 10y agoI think the network bandwidth isn't there yet either. Latency will always be a constant that we'll have to deal with as well. VMs are great, but clientside rending/editing, etc, will probably always be best, where it's only IO for storange/persistence that goes to the cloud.
- kaosjester 10y agoYou want the Nintendo Switch of computing?
- lobster_johnson 10y agoAmazon WorkSpaces is just VNC/Remote Desktop-type tech. You get a desktop computer in the cloud, which you connect to as a thin client. Performance is exactly what you expect -- pretty bad, but probably okay if you're doing simple things like word processing or order management or call center stuff.
- mozumder 10y agoApple currently already does this very well via their iCloud sync. You stick 1TB of your files in your Documents directory (or app-specific data folders..), and you can access them in any device that supports iCloud, including iPhones & iPads. Try it, you'll like it, and you don't have to deal with physical storage devices. I mean, have people never even tried iCloud sync?
- rocky1138 10y agoWe're not just talking about files and folders, but the actual user as well (including all settings, etc.)
- lisper 10y agoExactly. And all my running processes too.
- lostlogin 10y agoI haven't. After using iCloud for my photos it's going to be an awfully long time before I trust any Apple cloud service. It's was shambolic and is still deeply dysfunctional.
- patrickg_zill 10y agoSun did something similar with their Sun Ray hardware and software. You could close a session with a number of apps open, go to some other location, and login with a different Sun Ray located there, and your session just as you left it would be there, no rebooting or loss of state (assuming that the Sun Ray was somehow connected or federated to the same server that had your login details and apps).
- protomyth 10y agoSun Ray was pretty nice, but I want the opposite. I carry a ok processor, storage, and some memory that can hook to a dock which gives me more processing, storage, and memory. I get the feeling we need to look back to things like Newton Soups for the storage and then applying those concepts to the others.
- Fnoord 10y agoI guess you want something akin to what Razer Core is for Razer Blade, but then you don't want more graphics power. Apparently it uses USB-C to achieve this. Does that give confidence we may see this feature more commonly?
- protomyth 10y agoI consider the current group of GPUs to be more processing power, but yes, something like what USB-C is supposed to offer. I would expect it will need to go beyond the use external memory and CPU.
- rch 10y agoI've wanted this for a while too. The OQO tried to make it work, but was too early. It would be interesting to have something like process migration across VMs, but with mobile devices.
- derefr 10y agoYou could keep a virtual machine on the SSD, with each docking host having the same VM software installed. Then you'd literally be able to hibernate the VM and physically move it.
- milankragujevic 10y agoI literally thought about doing this today. Have Ubuntu + VirtualBox on multiple computers and any OS in a virtual machine and use a USB 3 SSD (you can get either a specialized one or a generic SATA SSD and a USB 3 enclosure) as the storage medium. I'm going to try it now, might even make a blog post if it works out.
- girvo 10y agoI ran VMs on a Thunderbolt HDD, and had issues with VirtualBox being frustrating to setup regarding file-paths. There might be a better way of handling that now, at least!
- eps 10y agoHaving a VM in picture decimates video and storage performance. I've tried this exact approach not a week ago. There's an NVMe drive with ~700MBps read speed and a GFX 10xx hooked up to a 4K display. The best I could squeeze from VM was 245 MBps in read and I couldn't get rid of a lag in cursor movement when running Visual Studio full screen. Going up and down one a page was OK, but when you get to the edge, there was a very noticeable hiccup before it started scrolling. CPU and memory throughputs were largely unaffected though. That's using VMware Workstation 12.5 with Win 8.1 as both guest and host. I ended up with just sticking all data onto an encrypted USB3.1 SSD and setting up the desktop and the laptop identically. Not as elegant as a VM would've been, but works really well so far.
- ryanlol 10y ago>Having a VM in picture decimates video and storage performance. No, using shit virtualization software decimates those. You can pass through both the GPU and the disk directly to the VM.
- richardkmichael 10y agoThe OQO was mentioned elsewhere, I too wanted it for this years ago, along with a Pico projector and virtual/projection keyboard. Now that I've been disappointed by both the new MBP and the price of the current gen Google/Android phones, I've started wondering if I can spend $1000 on a new "phone" and use it for everything (with peripherals left at each site). I briefly investigated this approach just a few days and found Debian noroot and AndromiumOS (see also their related Superbook kickstarter, which did really well -- though personally, I don't want a laptop if I go this route). Quite a bit needs testing, but it seems promising, maybe one generation away still (USB-C/3.1gen2 everything, with power).
- newman314 10y agoCheck out the InFocus Kangaroo
- lemming 10y agoAbsolutely. I actually feel like the Mac Mini form factor could be good enough for this. It's not pocket sized, but it's better than a laptop, I could happily schlep it from the office to home again. The one thing it's missing is being able to turn it into a laptop somehow when I do actually need that, i.e. when travelling.
- lisper 10y ago> it's better than a laptop Can't say I agree with that. The mini is awfully fat, and most of that space is power supply, fan, and a rotating hard drive. (Seriously, Apple, don't you know it's 2016?) So I still need a bag to carry it. I'd much rather have an MBP than a Mini. (Also, a mini can't sleep unplugged.)
- protomyth 10y agoI had a camera bag that exactly fit my Mac mini and accessories and carried that from home to work to my parents for visits. It was quite nice loaded up.
- tzhenghao 10y agoYeah, I really like that idea. Here's a writeup I had quite a while ago. Not sure if it's in any way similar to yours, but I guess we're trying to address a similar problem here https://medium.com/@tzhenghao/why-your-smartphone-is-soon-becoming-the-only-computer-youll-ever-need-2419f38c4e65#.kgfoqrefh https://medium.com/@tzhenghao/why-your-smartphone-is-soon-be...
- jpalomaki 10y agoThis is want I have been dreaming about. While sitting by the desk, I want to use desktop class CPU since there's no need to save power. However I don't want to drag a workstation class laptop while traveling. I've tried having two different computers. Dropbox makes it easier, but still you have the problem that you need to maintain two separate systems. I think technically this is not so far fetched. With the portable USB3 memory you could almost achieve it. This would just require that the operating system supports waking up in a bit different hardware (at least different CPU, possibly also different amount of RAM).
- BoorishBears 10y agoIsn't this the same as the gaming-oriented laptops that have offered external hot-pluggable docks for dedicated GPUs in the past? Iirc there are even generic Thunderbolt based docks that could hook up some of the beefiest desktop GPUs to a laptop. The CPU aspect is still an issue, but high end full voltage mobile CPUs are pretty powerful, and can still scale down power usage.
- sudhirj 10y agoThe Intel Skull Canyon NUC works great. Didn't even realise I was doing just this until you mentioned it.
- lmm 10y agoThe Surface Book is a step in that direction, particularly with the GPU going in the base. You can keep one or more Surface Docks connected to monitors, keyboards and what-have-you in the places where you work, and carry around either the laptop-sized unit (with keyboard, GPU, and a chunk of battery) or even just the large-tablet-sized screen piece. And you can keep your programs running the whole time. A 13" tablet is still a bit big to be carrying around - I'm hoping they'll eventually manage to make an x86 phone with enough oomph to operate as a development workstation - but it's getting there.
- justinator 10y agoNo one mention the Mac Powerbook Duo, so I'm just going to do that, for completeness. http://www.techradar.com/news/mobile-computing/laptops/slick-capable-and-connected-it-s-time-to-go-back-to-the-powerbook-duo-1279870 http://www.techradar.com/news/mobile-computing/laptops/slick...
- kaitnieks 10y agoSurface Pro comes close to this - it's very small and easy to carry around, and you could use the Surface docking stations for easier transitions I suppose. The only difference from your dream is that the display doesn't come off, but sometimes it can be an advantage. What I want is to have docking stations with extra computing power/GPU/RAM/HDD etc built in, so that I can keep the small Surface with its limited battery for the road but have an absurdly powerful desktop PC when I dock it.
- lisper 10y agoBut then I would have to run Windows :-(
- phire 10y ago> maybe the CPU It's a good question if a CPU should be included or not. On the one hand, I want a desktop class CPU in some situations and a laptop class CPU in other situations. And it would be nice to upgrade your entire computer without even having to shutdown the OS. On the other hand, an Skylake or Kabby lake laptop class processor is actually the same silicon as the desktop class processor, just but with some cores disabled, clocked at a lower speed and binned for low power usage instead of performance. So theoretically, you could have CPU which can be a quad core desktop processor when plugged into a beefy power source and cooling solution, but disables cores and downclocks when power and cooling is more limited.
- Brakenshire 10y agoSurprised no-one's mentioned EOMA68: https://www.crowdsupply.com/eoma68/micro-desktop https://www.crowdsupply.com/eoma68/micro-desktop It's an open hardware standard for switching the computer between different interface devices.