4 ms·
Evade local regulations that everyone else follows in the name of 'innovation' even though the reality is they are just taking a free pass on conducting backgro
by mindcrime 10y ago
Evade local regulations that everyone else follows in the name of 'innovation' even though the reality is they are just taking a free pass on conducting background checks, and skipping safety guidelines.
When they replace all taxis, do they really think they can just permanently ignore all driving laws?
Since when do hackers bleat about obeying laws and regulations? What happened to having a "we can do better" mindset? Has everybody wigged out and flipped their "I want a nanny state to protect me 24/7" bit?
And as far as that goes... I guess no "certified" taxi driver has ever turned out to be a criminal or done anything to harm a passenger? Me personally, I prefer to exercise some personal discretion and simply decide whether or not I will ride with a particular Uber driver, or cabbie, or Lyft driver, or whatever, based on my own judgment in the moment, as opposed to abdicating responsibility to either the State or a corporation.
- lacampbell 10y agoSince when do hackers bleat about obeying laws and regulations? What happened to having a "we can do better" mindset? Has everybody wigged out and flipped their "I want a nanny state to protect me 24/7" bit? Hacker News is fairly progressive/authoritarian. The kind of attitude you describe can still be found on slashdot.
- Apocryphon 10y agoIt looks like they're pretty much on the side of government/against Uber in the story about Uber flouting DMV regulations: https://tech.slashdot.org/story/16/12/15/1559226/uber-we-dont-need-a-permit-for-self-driving-cars#comments https://tech.slashdot.org/story/16/12/15/1559226/uber-we-don...
- mindcrime 10y agoHacker News is fairly progressive/authoritarian. It has become more so over the past few years for sure. It was a lot more balanced in the past, as I recall.
- vertex-four 10y agoAnd as a leftist, Hacker News is very, very libertarian-leaning most of the time by nature of its general support for startup companies no matter what laws they break and its general dislike of laws and systems designed to protect people from the sociopathic entities we call companies. There's some dissent, but it's certainly not a progressive haven. This is one of those places where people will happily sit around and argue that breaking laws is moral and necessary, no matter what the law.
- lacampbell 10y agoThe sociopathic entities we call governments are far more powerful and do far more damage than those we call companies. MacDonalds has yet to bomb anyone that I am aware of, and I can't recall Google using force to prevent someone leaving a country, or Amazon water-boarding people it has captured through overseas kidnapping.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoYou're proving his point.
- microtherion 10y agoCorporations generally don't do their own bombing and waterboarding, but they sure hire OTHERS to do their bombing and waterboarding for them. Cf Pepsi's role in the Chilean coup https://www.theguardian.com/business/1998/nov/08/observerbusiness.theobserver https://www.theguardian.com/business/1998/nov/08/observerbus... or the United Fruit company's role in Colombia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_massacre or Guatemala https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobo_Árbenz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobo_Árbenz And of course, in their regular operation, many companies routinely pollute the environment: http://www.prwatch.org/news/2011/05/10722/koch-industries-toxic-gifts-wisconsin http://www.prwatch.org/news/2011/05/10722/koch-industries-to... Funny how libertarians never seem to consider dumping millions of lbs of poison into the environment an "initiation of force", but god forbid government raise taxes by one cent.
- 10y ago
- jplasmeier 10y agoSomewhere in between "Since when do hackers bleat about obeying laws and regulations?" and "I want a nanny state to protect me 24/7" exists a middle ground where people realize that government regulation exists for a reason. You can't just throw away the law for the sake of your definition of progress...
- mindcrime 10y agoYou can't just throw away the law for the sake of your definition of progress... Sure you can. Laws aren't magical and there's nothing about the State that gives it any actual innate authority.
- Frondo 10y agoNo, you're right, there's no "law" molecule in nature. What gives the state its authority is that me and three hundred million other people continue to give the state its authority. Break a severe enough law and we'll take away your freedom of movement for a while. Behold, society!
- Analemma_ 10y ago> Since when do hackers bleat about obeying laws and regulations? ... Has everybody wigged out and flipped their "I want a nanny state to protect me 24/7" bit? Please stop perpetuating this myth- started by Eric Raymond and happily encouraged by SV "thought leaders"- that hackers must, by definition, be laissez-faire capitalists who love Ayn Rand and treat breaking laws as a noble goal in and of itself. I do none of those things, because I recognize that many times regulations are vital for ensuring human health and happiness, and think that free-for-all capitalism leads mostly to misery for all but a few in the plutocracy. "We can do beter" implies not settling for a world like that. Other people don't have to agree with my politics, but if they want to say I'm "not a hacker" because of that, they can take their very-politically-motivated prescriptivism and... well, I got told by dang the other day and I'm trying to cut down on the angry HN posts because of it, but you get the idea.
- emblem21 10y ago> regulations are vital for ensuring human health and happiness I agree. The regulations created for the war on drugs has lifted millions of African Americans out of poverty and into group-oriented communities that promise shelter, free food, and at least one hour of happiness per day.
- mindcrime 10y agoPlease stop perpetuating this myth- started by Eric Raymond and happily encouraged by SV "thought leaders"- that hackers must, by definition, be laissez-faire capitalists who love Ayn Rand and treat breaking laws as a noble goal in and of itself. Nice strawman. Luckily I didn't say anything about esr, laissez-faire, capitalism, or Ayn Rand in the post you replied to. Hell, I didn't even say that breaking the law is a "noble goal in and of itself". All I'm saying is that it's disturbing to me how so many HN'ers have just completely sold out to the idea that the State is their proper master, and should regulate / control pretty much everything and anything. It seems to me that in the past, there was a more individualist / freedom oriented mindset around sites like this - whether it was from "American style libertarians" or socialist anarchists or whatever. Personally I find the change to be a bit depressing.
- Apocryphon 10y agoSince when do hackers bleat about obeying laws and regulations? What happened to having a "we can do better" mindset? Since when does hackerdom constitute blindly following dogma, whether it be libertarian or not?
- mindcrime 10y agoStrange that you would respond with that, given that I'm arguing exactly against "following dogma". What I'm saying is that, as hackers, we have traditionally taken on a mindset that says "we can use our intellect, reason, science, etc. to figure out better solutions" without regard for dogma. And more and more people seem to be drifting away from that and just punting and saying "fuck it, the State will make everything OK". That's what gets me, is the way hackerdom seems to be losing that spirit of independence that it used to have.
- Apocryphon 10y agoThe very fact that you treat this state as a separate entity from the people is a problem. In a republic, the state is the citizenry. Hackers are part of the state and can influence the state and should work with the state. No one here is agitating for delegating all responsibilities to the state. The point is that private businesses should work with the state and seek to change and reform regulation when necessary, not permanently act in defiance of the laws of the state. Hackers understand the use of a good tool, and if the state is one, then hackers should use that tool. To throw it away is blind libertarian dogma with empty rhetoric about "nanny states" and other bogeymen. Furthermore, even supposed would-be laissez-faire capitalists know this- I doubt that startups pass up the chance to use government policies to their own advantage, or pursue rent-seeking behaviors that help their startups. The perfect libertarian society you envision exists next to the perfect communist society, as utopias that contravene human nature.
- mindcrime 10y agoIn a republic, the state is the citizenry. In theory. I think we're pretty far removed from that in reality.
- jimmywanger 10y ago> Since when do hackers bleat about obeying laws and regulations? Bleat? People would give Uber a pass if they actually created new and innovative technology. Right now they're much more of a financial services (attracting VC funds) and DC lobbying firm than a technologically innovative company. They have a few (albeit NP complete) interesting technological problems. The rest is mostly legal and finance. Why wouldn't people complain about companies who try to muscle in with money and lobbying featuring products that are not noticeably superior at all?