3 ms·
> the public sector pays a great deal less. CHP officers often make $100-200k per year. Their salaries are public record. There's a middle ground to be had b
by mywittyname 10y ago
> the public sector pays a great deal less.
CHP officers often make $100-200k per year. Their salaries are public record. There's a middle ground to be had between six-figure salaries for 30 years followed by a windfall valued at ~$5MM, and creating punitive incentives.
If they want to provide delayed incentives, then a generous 401k contribution with a very long vesting schedule will suffice. But current pension systems are completely broken. The pension system should only pay out a fraction of earnings and distribute that amount based on "shares" owned of the pension. Shares are earned by paying into the system.
- dragonwriter 10y agoCHP officers are not, either in salary or retirement, typical public employees.
- ec109685 10y ago401k's are a bad deal because employees are at the mercy of the stock market at the time of retirement. Pensions should be able to smooth out ups and downs of investments better than a private 401k.
- smileysteve 10y agoWhat do you think pension funds invest in? Also, with 401ks, you can invest in anything from small cap / developing world stocks, s&p 500s, large cap dividends, private bonds, public bonds, and U.S. treasury bonds.
- ec109685 10y agoPensions have an unlimited time horizon, while personal 401ks don't. Yeah, you could put the money in more conservative investments, but you still as an indivisible bare the brunt of the risk.
- smileysteve 10y agoIf you have a large group of people commencing to draw down your fund, your time horizon can be quite short. Similarly, if you have future workers not in the program, you can't "pyramid scheme" it. 20 years of investing are required for most classic pensions and the CHP example workers are likely to have as many or more years than that. An appropriate age based fund (which would admittedly, likely have huge fees) would reduce risk of the money you'd be drawing down on in the next 10 years.