3 ms·
There's a motte & bailey argument going on here where when people talk about banning fake news, they want you to just think about the completely made up stuff,
by jerf 10y ago
There's a motte & bailey argument going on here where when people talk about banning fake news, they want you to just think about the completely made up stuff, but as soon as you're not looking, they mean to apply the restrictions the stuff that they ideologically don't like.
I'm yet to see a definition of "fake news" that applies to Breitbart but doesn't apply to the New York Times without referring to ideology.
I'm also sort of curious how so many left-leaning people seem to be so excited to hand this power of labeling "fake news" and censoring it to governments or other powerful entities as we're what in is at least plausibly a large-scale swing to populist right-wing power gains in Western civilization. Maybe that will turn out not to be the case, but it's certainly a valid interpretation of the events of the last couple of years. Are you all sure this is the best time to be talking about powers to muzzle news sources? We're most likely minutes away from the Electoral College electing Trump as I write this, and while Merkel may still be in power in Germany it's not exactly like the winds are blowing her way and she's had to play some very defensive political games lately. Who's actually going to end up with the power to define "fake news"?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chc 10y agoThat may be so. I was just arguing against the false equivalence people are drawing between coverage that seems a bit biased and creating fake news out of whole cloth. It's similar to arguing against securities fraud laws because ads that show somebody getting excited for a bland hamburger are also deceptive. My point is basically: No, some things are worse than other things. Anyway, there may be bad actors advocating for fake news laws, but that doesn't change the fact that fake news is a harmful thing that needs to be dealt with somehow. I agree with a lot of what you say, but I'm also not in favor of throwing my hands up and saying, "Oh well, we're just screwed."
- rokosbasilisk 10y agoFake news will be defined by the establishment or those with power. I too find it strange the left is pushing this fake news narrative, so hard right as Trump is taking power.