2 ms·
This is how I read this: Yadda yadda blah blah blah -- real income growth curve used to be 3% (mostly true) blah blah blah -- New income curve is 2%. Changed
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
This is how I read this:
Yadda yadda blah blah blah -- real income growth curve used to be 3% (mostly true)
blah blah blah -- New income curve is 2%. Changed in 1970s (think so. So far so good)
yadda yadda yadda -- wise president Carter warned us of this but nationalistic Reagan glossed it over and it became anathema
WTF? Is this a politics article or something about the economy?
blah blah blah -- This is what it means to fall off a growth curve. (a bit extreme of an extreme judgment, at the least)
blah blah blah I will be poorer than my father
Okay. You get a couple of WTFs for any article. But we're done here. The growth curve, presumably from sticking along so far, is now 2%, not 3%. I poked around a bit, and I didn't see where you said we were on a negative growth curve. Plus any reasonable person can see that even at a negative growth, our kids are going to have a tremendously better life than we did. The very poor today are much better than the richest of rich from 70 BCE
I did not finish. From the pattern so far, I would expect lots more exaggerations and oversimplifications in order to make some quasi political point. I'm just guessing though. Sorry if I missed a good read. I thought it was important to show how these things are read.
Remember -- if you are going to put in a WTF, either do it at the beginning and then support it, or build up to it and hit it as a climax. But don't sprinkle them throughout the essay. Readers would like you to tell a story that has some conclusion, even if they disagree. But if you fail to establish common ground, we're out of here.
- jacobolus 17y agoInflation-adjusted wages haven’t had 2 percent growth since the 70s; they’ve stagnated or slightly decreased. Productivity keeps improving, but wages don’t keep up. Edit: Hmm, I did some googling, and there seem to be substantially divergent charts/numbers floating around. Some numbers have real wages going down, others have them staying approximately flat, and some more optimistic estimates have ~2% rises. I don’t have the time to do deep investigation. ---- The US also has an unprecedented and unique-among-western-countries incarceration rate; people have substantially more debt (college loans, credit card debt, etc.) than they did a few decades ago, and the laws are much less friendly to debtors than they were between the 40s and the 70s; families are less stable than before, and there are more working single mothers. There are an unacceptably high (in my opinion) number of uninsured children. And so on. In other words, we face all manner of difficult social challenges. At the same time, US society is in many ways much more tolerant than it was 30 or 40 years ago. We have many nifty technological tools that improve people’s lives, safer cars, better communications infrastructure, some great medical advances, etc. All in all, I’m optimistic about the future, but it is true that the American working class could use help from our regulatory/economic policy.