4 ms·
They did actually review the submissions (not a formal peer review process though), and initially rejected the Sokal paper for multiple issues, eventually accep
by ucaetano 10y ago
They did actually review the submissions (not a formal peer review process though), and initially rejected the Sokal paper for multiple issues, eventually accepting it with no changes for their "Science Wars" issue.
The irony that they decided to accept it exactly for the Science Wars issue, after initially rejecting it, is amazing. If they had published it in any other issue, the impact wouldn't be as dramatic.
- foldr 10y agoReview means "peer review" in the context of a journal. Even very low-tier academic journals have a formal peer review process. Social Text was really more of a magazine than an academic journal.