3 ms·
> When you make it at home you know you are not to allow it to spill over yourself. She was served coffee, they got in a car and drove a few minutes, the car p
by DanBC 10y ago
> When you make it at home you know you are not to allow it to spill over yourself.
She was served coffee, they got in a car and drove a few minutes, the car pulled over and she burnt herself so severely she needed several surgeries and her life was at risk.
I suspect that most coffee made at home would be at a lower temperature after the same length of time. Mostly because mugs and metal teaspoons conduct heat better, and people use chilled milk, and mugs don't have lids.
And while we all know "coffee is hot" we don't expect it to cause life threatening injury. That's the thing that really bugs me about this case, is that people don't understand just how serious full thickness burns are.
In England if you get a full thickness burn, especially on any joints or the face or neck or genital regions you make your way to your nearest A&E department or MIU, and that hospital then transfers you, by ambulance, to a more specialist burns unit.
Having been inside several burns units (Bristol Frenchay; Salisbury; Birmingham Selly Oak; and Chelsea & Westminster) I know they're not fucking around when it comes to burns.
> but how were they at fault for her injury?
Several safety organisations had called for coffee to be served at a reduced temperature. That's still too hot to drink, and will still cause burns. It just reduces the risk of severe burns. McDonalds decided to ignore that request to reduce temperature.
And no-one is asking them to stop serving extra hot coffee. They just asking them to only serve it on request.
- mc32 10y agoI think you make a pretty good case for the regulation of the temperature at which coffee is served. And if we had such then yes, McD would be at fault for violating the law. It would make sense to me that if coffee injuries are seriously injurious that we should have such regulation. As it was though, there didn't seem to be such regulation and as such I would imagine that common sense on the side of the producer and consumer would have been expected and in such case we'd have split the fault more 50:50 rather than the 90:10 it was.
- chc 10y agoThe underpinning of your thought process here seems to be something like "People can't be fully liable for harm they cause if they weren't breaking the law in the process." But that's not so. If I wildly wave my arms around in a somebody's house and break their expensive china, that's not against the law, but I can't say, "Oh, I only owe you half the cost since it's your fault you didn't protect yourself against the perfectly legal action of me flailing around the room."