10 ms·
ALPHA observes light spectrum of antimatter for first time
- _rpd 10y ago> Today's ALPHA result is the first observation of a spectral line in an antihydrogen atom, allowing the light spectrum of matter and antimatter to be compared for the first time. Within experimental limits, the result shows no difference compared to the equivalent spectral line in hydrogen. This is consistent with the Standard Model of particle physics
- colechristensen 10y ago>consistent with the Standard Model Is generally one of the most disappointing phrases one can read in science news. Hooray for progress and all, but everybody is hoping for exactly the opposite result.
- PavleMiha 10y agoMaybe we're running out of surprising things.
- jandrese 10y agoWe are probably just looking in the wrong places.
- plandis 10y agoLord Kelvin said something similar in 1900 about there being nothing left to discover. Within 30 years quantum mechanics would be discovered/created.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoAt that time everyone knew there was something up with blackbody radiation, classical physics gave no guide why the equipartition theorem should not apply any more at short wavelengths.
- openasocket 10y agoAnd now we know something's up with gravity, because we can't seem to reconcile it with quantum mechanics.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoI know, and the Lord Kelvin quote is too suspicious to be credible, a man like him would never have said such a thing. If we can trust Wikipedia he never did: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/William_Thomson#Misattributed https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/William_Thomson#Misattributed
- IgorPartola 10y agoDidn't Isaac Newton die thinking that he solved all of physics though?
- 0xfaded 10y agoNewton was the first to experiment with light reflectance of glass of various thicknesses. He found the relationship but had no idea how a light corpuscule could know the thickness of the glass when it decided to reflect or not. Newton published his corpuscular theory of light but I certainly don't think he would have claimed to know what was going on.
- _rpd 10y agoOur current theory of gravity doesn't even explain how galaxies form and rotate unless over a quarter of the universe is made of unspecified "dark matter." We are children playing on the shores of undiscovered oceans.
- tudorw 10y agoI'm with you, I'm uncertain we even have the right question...
- eanzenberg 10y ago
- ianai 10y agoI remember Feynman said to check the spin of the photons emitted from alien species. If they're 90 degrees out of phase with ours then they're made of antimatter and we shouldn't shake hands. (At least I think it was spin, been a while since I read QED)
- cshimmin 10y agoActually his story was about trying to explain the difference between left and right in terms of nuclear spin experiments. You also explain that humans greet by shaking their right hands. If you meet the alien and he extends his left hand to shake, he must be made of antimatter (since the combination of parity and antimatter conjugation is a symmetry of the universe). edit: jess is correct, and that's the whole point of the story actually. if CP was invariant you wouldn't be able to tell they were antimatter by describing the nuclear physics decay experiment. instead the antimatter version of the parity experiment gives the opposite result. I shouldn't try to physics so early in the morning :)
- jcoffland 10y agoAssuming a two handed alien of course.
- hossbeast 10y agoMany handed
- Semiapies 10y agoBut only bilaterally symmetrical. Radially symmetric aliens with hands give no indication! (Well, aside from whether or not they blow up whatever local matter surface they're standing on.)
- grkvlt 10y agoThat's neither necessary or sufficient! Notice that they could be bilaterally symmetric and two arms/hands positioned vertically on their front (anterior?) so no left/right hand distinction (but top/bottom instead) or; they could be asymmetric but have two hands/arms on one side, and one on the other, still giving them a left/right side choice.
- hughes 10y ago> Antihydrogen is made by mixing plasmas of about 90,000 antiprotons from the Antiproton Decelerator with positrons, resulting in the production of about 25,000 antihydrogen atoms per attempt. Antihydrogen atoms can be trapped if they are moving slowly enough when they are created. Using a new technique in which the collaboration stacks anti-atoms resulting from two successive mixing cycles, it is possible to trap on average 14 anti-atoms per trial The amount of work that goes in to producing 14 anti-hydrogen atoms is astonishing. It's simultaneously the height of human technical accomplishment yet vanishingly small quantities of the most primitive element possible.
- jerf 10y agoIf you enjoyed that, you may also enjoy the discussions of how people synthesize super heavy elements, such as in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3oY-XHwss8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3oY-XHwss8 Superheavy elements even beat antihydrogen on this scale; one of the ones recently named was confirmed to have been synthesized based on only three atoms!
- jhayward 10y agoYes, it's amazing work. Also, don't be fooled that because it is so difficult to produce today that it can't be scaled immensely. Plutonium production was scaled from nanogram levels to ton levels in less than a decade.
- hughes 10y agoWell... 14 anti-hydrogen atoms is a lot less than a nanogram. It's about 1/100th of a trillionth of a nanogram. If we scale up production in the next decade at the same pace you're describing, we might get to nanogram levels.
- jhayward 10y ago> we might get to nanogram levels Right! Now we're talking about some antimatter! Kidding of course. But there is no reason to believe ab initio that it could not be scaled to whatever quantity is useful given enough incentive for that use.
- nonbel 10y agoDumb question: Is it easier to create antimatter if you already have some? I mean using it as a nucleation point, or perhaps energy source.
- jessriedel 10y agoNope. It's a sensible question, but it doesn't help.
- lutorm 10y agoIt would be easier if you could build your entire experimental apparatus out of antimatter, but if you could do that you're probably beyond making experiments with single atoms of it... ;-)
- mikeash 10y agoI would not want to be in charge of filing the Environmental Impact Statement for such a facility.
- lutorm 10y ago:)
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoYeah, you should see the paperwork they make us fill out for something as simple as a few hundred lbs of mercury.
- josho 10y agoSimply amazing. I still thought antimatter was a theory. Can anyone recommend a book on this topic for the layman?
- lutorm 10y agoNot a theory at all. You get antimatter out of many common radioactive materials: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission It's the building atoms out of it that's tricky, but antimatter is nothing new.
- kkylin 10y agoAnd with practical applications as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission_tomography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission_tomography
- tjohns 10y agoNot only that, but a PET scan (a common medical imaging technique, tangentially similar to an MRI or CT scan) relies on antimatter. The name stands for Positron Emission Tomography, in fact. The general idea: You get injected with a tracer containing a β+ emitter. This produces positrons (antimatter) through radioactive decay. When the antimatter collides with regular matter inside your body, it annihilates, producing a pair of gamma rays moving in opposite directions. Those gamma rays can be detected and used to triangulate where the annihilation occured, generating a 3D image of where the tracer has accumulated in your body. Typically, the tracer will be something that looks like glucose to the body, so it's accumulated in areas of high metabolic activity. This allows us to see what parts of your body are active. (For example, seeing which neurons in your brain are firing.) More reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission_tomography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positron_emission_tomography
- komali2 10y agoIt is a theory, like everything else in physics, including the workings of gravity. It's a bit of a shame that in elementary school and high school, people are taught about "facts" such as Newtonian physics without exploring also some of the weirdness of quantum physics that challenges classic physics. I.e. I had no idea about all the controversy around how gravity "actually" works until I read a book on string theory - I went 25 years just assuming "yup gravity is a thing and we understand 100% how it works." Sorry, I don't have a book to recommend, just babbling away. EDIT: Maybe the string theory book I read would be a good place, actually? I can't remember if it delves much into anti matter - The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Theory (Paperback) https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8049273-the-elegant-universe https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8049273-the-elegant-univ...
- duncanmeech 10y agoStop posting physics articles on hacker news. Just because everyone here has watched too much Star Trek and Star Wars doesn't mean we actually understand a single solitary shred of this stuff...although it sounds cool.
- nitrogen 10y agoYou may want to reread the HN guidelines. And although I am not a physicist, some HN readers are.
- dguest 10y agoI work at CERN. Before I worked there I worked on trapping "normal" atoms (as opposed to antimatter ones). So some of us do understand this stuff.
- corndoge 10y agoReading is how you learn.
- 4ad 10y agoReading real physics, not "popular science" articles.
- odrekf 10y agoI understood the article, and I'm not a physicist or anything like that. And I suspect almost everyone else here who read it understood it too. It's not uncommon for HN readers to be interested in how the Universe works, and therefore this wouldn't be the first physics article they've ever read.
- bmh100 10y agoIn case anyone is wondering about what antimatter actually is, antimatter is basically like normal matter, but the electrical charges are reverse. Take hydrogen for example. It is a massive, positive particle (the proton), orbited by a light, negative particle (the electron). Anti-hydrogen is a massive, negative particle (the antiproton) orbited by a light, positive particle (the positron) [1]. Why do matter and antimatter annihilate each other? Matter and antimatter are very similar, except for opposite electrical charges. Opposite charges attract. If antihydrogen meets normal matter, the positrons quickly find and combine with the electrons, and the antiprotons do the same with protons. These combinations all release radiation. Therefore, one of the main challenge with studying antimatter is making sure that it doesn't touch normal matter, which is basically everything in the lab. Why don't electrons and protons normally combine, being oppositely charged? Electron sit in stable orbitals, volumes of space with associated energies. These orbitals are like valleys. While an electron nearing the nucleus will fall into an orbital, it would take extra energy to get the electron out of the orbital and into the nucleus [2]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antihydrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antihydrogen [2]: http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/30939/what-keeps-electrons-in-an-atom-from-flying-away-or-falling-into-the-nucleus#30943 http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/30939/what-keeps-...
- euyyn 10y ago"Falling into the nucleus", as stated in that Stack Exchange question, is a classical (as in "wrong" :) ) way to look at it. The 1s orbital of the electron is spherically symmetric, with non-zero probability of the electron being right in the center of the atom (so within the nucleus), and decreasing probability of it being farther away. So e.g. a good approximation of the He atom is of two neutrons, two protons, and two electrons, all in exactly the same position (with the electrons having "more spread"). At the end of the day, there are interactions that are seen in Nature and interactions that aren't. We codify the patterns as conservation of lepton number, baryon number, etc. If the numbers of what you have add up to zero, they can annihilate. These conservation laws also accommodate other weird things, like beta decay, in which a neutron decays ("splitting") into a proton, an electron, and an anti-neutrino. It's not that the neutron is "composed" of those three things. But its total energy is higher than the sum of the energy at rest of those three particles: Whenever that's the case and the conservation laws allow it, we see it happen naturally.
- glandium 10y agoSo, if antimatter has the same light spectrum as matter, what makes us theorize that there is currently more matter than antimatter in the universe?
- btouellette 10y agoIf you're asking how do we know there is more matter than antimatter in the universe the answer is that it is consistent with the observations/calculations surrounding Big Bang nucleosynthesis and CMB anisotropies. If you're asking what do we theorize is the reason there is more matter than antimatter in the universe there isn't a satisfactory answer yet. It's one of the biggest open problems in physics.
- Retra 10y agoIf there were more antimatter than theorized, we'd expect to see much more radiation due to matter-antimatter annihilation. If we don't see this, then there must be a heavy bias in one direction or the other.