3 ms·
I have a bunch of friends who are philosophy students and right now they are "on strike", occupying a building at Middlesex University. The irony that they gle
by gaius 17y ago
I have a bunch of friends who are philosophy students and right now they are "on strike", occupying a building at Middlesex University.
The irony that they gleefully proclaim that they aren't studying a lowly "vocational" or "technical" course, yet have purloined the language and ideology of, umm, actual workers seems to have entirely escaped them.
Then again, several of them genuinely believe that writing essays at university is morally equivalent to building tractors at a factory... Marxists, eh? They'll be in for a bit of a shock when they have to meet the real world.
- arethuza 17y agoTop tip for annoying an academic: refer to the "real world" in a way that implies that they don't belong to it. The professor I used to work for used become incandescent with rage when someone did this. :-)
- gaius 17y agoWell their message to taxpayers is "work harder for longer for less so we can go on sneering at you from our ivory tower", so they really don't belong to the real world. Yet, but they will soon...
- tensor 17y agoThey don't belong in the real world in the sense that people get paid in the real world. Meanwhile, most academics go into debt, earn very little, and work long hours trying to genuinely contribute something to society as a whole. This is why so many phd students in computer science and related technical fields go into industry where they can get over double the salary from day one. Many academics do have a very negative view of none academics, precisely because of the sentiment that you so eloquently put into words. The irony is that society is eager as ever to consume the technologies and knowledge that comes from academic research, yet somehow expect all that for free, and even get angry when their results don't come fast enough. The me generation indeed.
- arethuza 17y agoMy experience is in the the UK, but when I worked in academia (from '89 to '95) I was paid roughly the same amount as my friends in the private sector. Looking at academic salaries these days they don't look too bad when you compare working conditions, perks (access sports centers etc.), long holidays and the rather generous final salary pension scheme. Yeah, I can imagine PhD students have a hard time everywhere - but I really don't have much sympathy for salaried staff in academia (or most of the UK public sector) complaining about wages and conditions.
- thebooktocome 17y agoAdmittedly, it seems prima facie ridiculous. The thing is, socialism, Marxism, worker's rights, and etc., started in the university and spread from there. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_1968_in_France http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_1968_in_France , for example. So it's not so much that the philosophy students have purloined the language and ideology of "actual workers", but rather that their intellectual ancestors created the social context in which these "actual workers" were able to strike, form unions, and etc.