4 ms·
I don't know anything about the personalities involved, and, for all I know, the letter is quite justified; but "I think that I've done you a big favour by givi
by JadeNB 17y ago
I don't know anything about the personalities involved, and, for all I know, the letter is quite justified; but "I think that I've done you a big favour by giving you 10 minutes of my time" seems to be one of those remarks to which there is [a canonical reply](http://modernarthur.com/blog/christwhatanasshole.html http://modernarthur.com/blog/christwhatanasshole.html) (no pun intended).
- zppx 17y agoT'so is one of the leading developers of the extended file system used by Linux.
- sharms 17y agoTed Tso wrote the majority of the filesystem in question, so he is pretty much the authority on the matter. He was hired by Google, and his point is that if Ubuntu is going to make a distribution, they need to have the engineers available to solve it, instead of just bugging actual engineers over and over again, which I see is reasonable given they sell support.
- ajross 17y agoTo be fair, Ted was also involved in a public spit with the Ubuntu kernel team about a year ago regarding an ext4 bug that he tried to "not-a-bug" based on a strict reading of the standard. He ultimately lost the argument, and had to fix ext4. See: https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/317781 https://bugs.edge.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/31... and especially: http://lwn.net/Articles/322823/ http://lwn.net/Articles/322823/ Whether that has anything to do with this particular sniping incident, I obviously have no knowledge. But I think it's an important piece of context. Edit: after reading the whole bug report, it's also important to point out that the issue at hand here is a real and still-unfixed but in ext4 that has been worked around for Lucid. Ted's appeal that no one from Fedora has complained seems a little shallow given that there's a 7-line shell script at the top of the bug to exercise it. Really, this doesn't seem warranted here. I know the kernel team doesn't like Canonical. But I don't see what they did wrong here other than pick a different workaround than the one Ted suggested.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI knew who he was and still thought it was an asshole comment. Though I was particularly put off by the bit at the bottom, where he says that even if Ubuntu does hire and train up people to work on upstream kernel or filesystem issues Google's deep pockets mean they will just poach them once they are trained up. Hopefully at Google they'll actually work on the upstream Linux rather than the Android fork.
- drewcrawford 17y agoAsshole comment or not, if Canonical wants help they should pay for it. Ted's not obligated to continue work for free simply because he's done so much work for free in the past. In fact, I'm pretty sure it's the opposite. I might fix my girlfriend's computer for free, but I make sure to bill everyone else.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoAsking him to work for free, and asking him not to be an asshole are two very different things. I assume you don't act like an asshole no matter who you are helping. I'd go further and assume that even when you turn down people asking for your help, and suggest they might want to hire someone instead, you're still not an asshole to them.
- hga 17y agoIt's pretty hard to not to make "an asshole comment" when you're trying in one email to convince a company to change their way of doing business. Anyone who has watched Canonical since Hardy Heron (also an LTS release) knows that the company has deep and systemic problems. I wouldn't be surprised if the tone of Ted's response is also a result of past history with them of the sort that's illustrated by this message. I might go even further and say that if you're as serious a member of the Linux kernel development community as Ted is, you might be rather concerned about Canonical's practices and how they're likely turning off a lot of would be Linux users.
- 17y ago
- jbellis 17y agoI dunno, as someone who does a lot of free support, the quote in context sounds blunt but not asshole-ish to me. (Especially if Canonical has a track record of trying to get free work out of him or other kernel developers.) "I've already done Ubuntu a huge favor by spending ten minutes to do a quickie investigation. Ubuntu needs to learn that it can't rely on upstream developers to jump through flaming hoops on short notice before a LTS release deadline as a cost-saving mechanism to avoid hiring their own senior kernel engineers."