7 ms·
The best way for people in civilized societies to defeat terrorism is not to live in fear, and to keep on advancing rationality and freedom.
by tokenadult 17y ago
The best way for people in civilized societies to defeat terrorism is not to live in fear, and to keep on advancing rationality and freedom.
- drunkpotato 17y agoIn order to "keep on" advancing rationality and freedom we would first have to start advancing rationality and freedom. Both are in short supply.
- DrSprout 17y agoYou could start by making a rational argument instead of appealing to a cynical belief that everyone is irrational and intent on restricting freedom. The essence of the irrationality that pervades American political discourse is exactly that sort of "everyone is crazy" mentality. There are plenty of people advancing rationality and freedom. You aren't one of them.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoappealing to a cynical belief that everyone is irrational and intent on restricting freedom I don't see that in the GP. It looks to me that he's working from the observation that personal liberty is decreasing, presumably revealing that the decisions being made are not rational. In particular, there's no reason to read into this anything about scope ("everyone"), nor their intent (to restrict freedom). Clearly it would be incorrect to impute this to everyone when the restricted liberty can only be caused by the few in power. Also, it may not be their intent to restrict freedom. Indeed, their intent may be to save our freedom, but due to the observed lack of rationality, their efforts carry the (assumedly unintended) side effect of restricting freedom.
- drunkpotato 17y agoThank you, that was a very clear and succinct rebuttal. I would add to it, that "advancing freedom" is one of those phrases that is, when you examine it, quite poorly defined. Freedom is more a set of associations than a strict definition, though I'm sure one can find philosophers who have attempted to strictly define it, so you get "freedom sub Professor X". Freedom is much easier to talk about in the abstract than to define, and lends itself to pithy (or, less charitably, glib) phrases that can be twisted to whatever one's own definition of freedom is. My original post was flippant and lacking in nuance, to be sure (still not warranting the personal attack; I do, in fact, attempt to point out logical fallacies and bring about reasonable discourse). I am not immune to making the odd sound-bite myself, though calling my post cynical and then making a strawman attack also does not advance the cause of rationality.
- CWuestefeld 17y ago"advancing freedom" is one of those phrases that is, when you examine it, quite poorly defined I agree, which is why I instead used the term "liberty" in some places. While the term "freedom" has in modern times become clouded particularly with the notion of "positive" freedoms, I believe that the term "liberty" tends to be more strongly associated with the more traditional notions of "negative" liberty. But I must concede that even this difference is at the grossest level, and there remain much more nuanced differences in definition beyond the negative/positive distinction.
- boredguy8 17y agoI hate to admit it, but I quick-clicked the upvote on your parent basically -as- I started reading your comment and thinking. Normally I'm firmly in the "misdiagnosing stupid" camp. It's sad and frustrating to realize that we, too, are human! and so must constantly self-check on these sorts of things. While the word "community" gets over-used, I think that's part of what community can do. Or perhaps: civilization. Thanks for the gut-check.
- shaunxcode 17y agoand yet your comment was created on a machine built upon rational being used to communicate on a network built upon freedom. start? more like recognize and celebrate what has already happened whilst rejecting the birthing pains.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoused to communicate on a network built upon freedom Actually, it was built by the Department of Defense, aka The War Department. The freedom aspect was purely unintentional. Indeed, I suppose that the reason that the best way to make the network robust results in making it free, creates an interesting analogy to the original point. At the very least, it proves that it's possible to be both more free and more secure, simultaneously.
- slackerIII 17y agoPlease study some history before you make claims like that. Have you seen any witches burned recently? Have 100K Japanese people on the west coast been put into camps recently?
- billybob 17y agoDepends on how you define "recently." I think the idea that humans are getting smarter and nobler is hogwash. There were plenty of professional philosophers in Rome while the emperor was burning Christians on pikes as party candles. And Rome was certainly the pinnacle of civilization in its day. The worst evils of the 20th century were done by people with lots of scientific, industrial and psychological knowledge propping them up. And the worst evils of the 21st century will be no different.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- chbarts 17y ago> I think the idea that humans are getting smarter and nobler is hogwash. OK, find me a duel and a bear-baiting match in America and I'll believe you. Otherwise you're just mindlessly cynical, like any number of other teenagers.
- nl 17y agoA Duel? UFC doesn't count? How about this, just from a quick search: http://current.com/news/92277104_a-near-fatal-shoot-out-between-incarcerated-rapper-gucci-mane-and-young-jeezys-entourages.htm http://current.com/news/92277104_a-near-fatal-shoot-out-betw.... You're probably right about bear-baiting. But there is plenty of organized dog fights and cock-fights around.
- roel_v 17y agoUFC is not a duel in the traditional sense, nor is it 'violent' in the same way a war or aggravated assault is 'violent'. It's a technical sport (well UFC is a league of MMA fighters, where MMA is the sport) with well-defined rules designed to minimize damage to participants. Saying that the popularity of MMA shows that our society is getting more violent doesn't make sense, on the contrary - it's proof that we are able to channel primary urges to measure ourselves with our fellow humans in controlled and structured ways. As for your link, an anecdote does not data make. If you want to argue that our society is getting more violent you need to prove that the amount of violent episodes now is higher than in the past, not that there happen violent events now. And as a matter of fact, overall in most of the Western world, the amount of violent crimes has been on a steady decline for the last 50 years at least (the amount of other crimes has gone down too, by the way).
- acangiano 17y agoIn fact, the best thing we can do is stop reporting terrorism in the media. Don't give these fanatics the spotlight they so much crave.
- axod 17y agoThe problem is, we as a society crave sensationalist news entertainment. How to fix that? :/
- rbanffy 17y agoEducation would be my fist guess. When people become aware of stupidity, they are at least free to try not being stupid.
- axod 17y agoBut here we are, sitting on HN voting up the most ridiculous non-useful articles. HN is often full of sensationalist entertainment news - endless appstore policies, iPad raves/rants etc. Why this is dead, why X is a Y killer. Endless rants about privacy. We're just as bad as the general population as a whole. Our "Terrorism" is "possible affront on privacy" or "Apple might be evil!"
- derefr 17y agoThe problem is "news." Without sensational news—without ephemera, in other words—the concept of "news" crumbles. We don't need to know the ongoing developments in stories that don't affect us personally, but we still crave to. If humans were stripped of this urge, this and every social news site would be reduced to magazines, publishing only after-the-fact analyses of completed narratives.
- inerte 17y agoMaybe a way to start doing this would be telling people that they are dumb. The past couple weeks I've been thinking that people are ok with small/short/quick news because it makes them think they have figured out the whole thing. Maybe they are satisfied that they've learned something, or maybe they think it is enough. I think folks are overestimating their ability to put loosely connected ideas into something bigger. You get a little here, a sprinkle there and you're cool with that. It's like a fast food for the brain. You're constantly satisfied, almost by the second, because you're supposedly "learning" something. But I don't know. My train of thought stops there. I don't know how to strip people of this urge.
- raquo 17y agoThat's the best way to achieve much more than merely defeating terrorism.
- duck 17y agoA terrorist is a person who uses violence, especially murder and bombing, in order to achieve political aims. I agree, but by the definition of it as long as we have politics we will have terrorism, so there really is no defeating it.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- dionidium 17y agoThat's a great thought and probably the correct long view, but what a lot of people mean when they talk about defeating terrorism is addressing the existence of actual terrorists alive today. I suspect that the general promotion of rationality wouldn't have been as effective at stopping Zarqawi as were the missiles that hit his safe-house.
- MichaelSalib 17y agoAfter we kill Zarqawi, what then? Do you think AQ just disappears into a puff of smoke? Historically speaking, targeted leadership strikes have not been terribly effective at stopping terrorist movements. You kill leaders and more arise. You kill those and yet more take their place.
- nir 17y agoThat's an easy advice to give when you're not really facing terrorism, but an extremely difficult one to follow when there's non-negligible chance your children's school bus will be bombed.
- moultano 17y agoThere's a much greater chance that your children's school bus will be in a horrific traffic accident.
- nir 17y agoAgain, depending on where you are.
- tokenadult 17y agoWhere is the danger of a terrorist attack on a schoolbus currently the greatest? How does that danger there compare to the danger of a traffic crash involving a schoolbus? There should be official statistics on all these issues anywhere where governance hasn't completely broken down.
- nir 17y agoYou are extrapolating from your own experience on situations which are very different. My argument has two points: 1. I don't consider the current situation in the US "terror". I'm talking about different times and places. If you were boarding a bus in Israel, Sri Lanka, Iraq during certain periods of time, you would have a higher chance of dying from a bombing than from an accident. 2. The natural response to terror is anything but rational. It is a completely different feeling to go on a bus knowing there's a possibility of an accident to going on a bus knowing that one of the passengers may be carrying a bomb.
- pyre 17y ago> It is a completely different feeling to go on a bus knowing there's a possibility of an accident to going on a bus knowing that one of the passengers may be carrying a bomb. I would compare the feeling to the feeling of wanting to do something, but not having the guts to just 'do it.' In this case, you want to search everyone on the bus that you don't trust until you are satisfied there is no bomb, but social pressures prevent you from doing so. This causes the stress. The difference just being acceptance. When you believe that someone may be carrying a bomb you hold onto some hope that something can be done to stop them. When you get on a bus knowing that there is the possibility of an accident, there's not much you can do short of wrestling for control of the bus from the driver (or just not getting on the bus). People have accepted that accidents happen. People have not accepted yet that 'terrorism' is a fact of life.
- 911miss 17y agoCan this be real?: http://imgur.com/fwP2Z?tags http://imgur.com/fwP2Z?tags
- mkramlich 17y agoI love old George Bush quotes like that.