4 ms·
> HN's moderation works Frankly I think it's starting to fray a little around the edges. Downvotes and flags are supposed to be used to suppress non-construct
by lisper 10y ago
> HN's moderation works
Frankly I think it's starting to fray a little around the edges. Downvotes and flags are supposed to be used to suppress non-constructive comments and submissions but I see them being used more and more to express disagreement (or, to be more precise, I see more and more comments being downvoted and stories being flagged that seem to me to be constructive and respectful but which express unpopular points of view.)
- aaron695 10y ago> Downvotes and flags are supposed to be used to suppress non-constructive comments and submissions. This is not actually true for downvotes. Or if it is true it's currently ambiguous, it's not in the FAQ. But I find it rare that an unpopular opinion will get downvoted if it's well justified. Where as I think upvoting of popular opinions is an issue.
- duncanawoods 10y agoFor the downvoters of the parent, here is the citation: PG: "I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
- lisper 10y agoHe wrote that back when downvoted comments didn't get greyed out the way they do today. Because of the grey-out, a downvote today is effectively a vote for, "No one should read this." IMHO, disagreement should not have that effect. There really ought to be a way to distinguish between "I disagree" and "This comment is not constructive and should be suppressed" -- and there is. If you disagree, you can post a comment to that effect. But whether PG intended it or not, a downvote today is suppression because of the way HN works.
- grzm 10y agoThanks for pointing out the context of when the pg comment was made. I wasn't aware of this, and the comment makes more sense to me now. It also reinforces—for me at least—that having separate "agree/disagree" and "constructive/unproductive" button pairs may be a good idea. Open questions: - how they'd play into karma (probably just the constructive/unproductive points, maybe agree/disagree displayed as a pair but not contribute to karma) - whether this is would be too complex from a UX perspective - while I think "disagree" and "unproductive" can be usefully distinguished, whether "agree" and "constructive" would be useful. That said, if we want people to comment for disagreement (substantively, I would hope), I wouldn't want to see or encourage a bunch of "+1" or "me, too", or "this" comments. I think users want to show support for good comments, and up-votes are currently the only way to do this if you have nothing else to add.
- lisper 10y agoActually, HN already has a separate "flag" link. The only real change needed would be to dim based on flags rather than downvotes. Then downvotes could go back to their original meaning (disagree). I would abolish karma. It turns HN into a silly game.
- grzm 10y agoI agree that dimming should be a function of constructiveness rather than agreement. If flag is to be used for that purpose, there's currently no way to express "I think this is a constructive comment", no way to balance "I think this is not a constructive comment". Having such a button is effectively the same as having "constructive/unproductive" buttons: the flag link would be subsumed. As for karma, I think it serves two purposes: it acts as a gating function to ensure members have contributed usefully before allowing them to behave in a potentially unproductive manner (e.g., creating throwaway accounts to down-vote or flag). It also encourages continued constructive contributions. Yes, it's artificial, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it can't serve that purpose. I don't think karma is perfect, but I think it is, on balance, a constructive feature on HN. If there are other methods of serving those two purposes more effectively and as simply as karma does (and I admit to ignorance here), I think they'd be worth exploring. I think there needs to be some pressure over the lifetime of an account to encourage constructive comments, non only on a per-comment basis.
- duncanawoods 10y ago> seem to me to be constructive and respectful "Constructive" is interestingly subjective. The higher the raise the bar, the more likely it is to be controversial because e.g. you require posters to share and build on the same assumed knowledge. You are welcomed to challenge assumed knowledge from a position of expertise but not from a position of ignorance. I give "I disagree" downvotes on topics I am very familiar with and the poster is simply insufficiently experienced to be broadcasting their bogus opinions however polite they are. I can surely imagine even more inexperienced posters would see that poster as constructive and helpful but its not the case.