4 ms·
> 2) This ultimately led to overhaul and standardizations for fuel / weight calculations. You have no idea how hard it is to get Americans to use 100% metric e
by walrus01 10y ago
> 2) This ultimately led to overhaul and standardizations for fuel / weight calculations.
You have no idea how hard it is to get Americans to use 100% metric everything, even in the year 2016 in a highly technical field. It's incredibly frustrating. I'm amazed at the number of people under age 30 who have clearly not been taught even the basics of the metric system in middle school and high school, or intentionally disregarded/forgot it.
Working in the US domestic economy is unavoidable to do many things in US customary units when construction/physical engineering of things is involved. For example if building mission critical telecommunications towers to EIA/TIA 222G standards, everything is going to be in US customary units (the tower structure itself, the fasteners, the guy cables, the anchors, the foundation/concrete job, the dimensions of the equipment shelter, the electrical conduit, etc).
- engi_nerd 10y ago>You have no idea how hard it is to get Americans to use 100% metric everything, even in the year 2016 in a highly technical field. American in a highly technical field here. I have no issues with using SI units when appropriate. But there is a tremendous lock-in, at least in some areas. Aerospace is a nasty mishmash, resulting in things like aircraft that "think" about altitude in feet, fuel in pounds, gear displacement in inches, but electric field strengths in W/m^2 and geopositioning in meters. All of those choices were made long ago, I'm stuck with them. My only defenses are to keep meticulous track of units and convert where necessary (while paying attention to things like numerical error).
- walrus01 10y agowe are pretty much resigned to the fact that buying all of the pieces to build a datacenter/colo/telecom facility, everything is going to be in US customary units, because that's what the suppliers have. It's a vicious cycle of nobody in the US choosing to stock metric items, so nobody can buy it, and all of the end users just use things that are US units. It can be the smallest things like threaded rod uses to hang overhead fiber trays in a datacenter (all of the fasteners, bolts, nuts, the rod itself, etc) are all in US units. All the way up to the largest things like $150,000 generators where all of their specifications are in US units and fuel consumption figures in gallons, etc. If it involves the construction industry it's 99% of the time going to be US customary units. We only get down to proper metric units when dealing with the fiber itself, but even that is lashed to aerial pole-to-pole strands, where the steel strand is in US units, all of the hardware is US. The battery backup shelves for large AGM lead acid batteries: All US units. The batteries themselves are specified in inches and pounds. Once again it can all be converted, but that's the default unit from the manufacturer. Floor loading calculations? Pounds per square foot.
- jaclaz 10y agoA related serious incident (mistaken units) in aerospace was the NASA Mars Climate Orbiter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Climate_Orbiter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Climate_Orbiter >However, on September 23, 1999, communication with the spacecraft was lost as the spacecraft went into orbital insertion, due to ground-based computer software which produced output in non-SI units of pound (force)-seconds (lbf·s) instead of the SI units of newton-seconds (N·s) specified in the contract between NASA and Lockheed.
- engi_nerd 10y agoYes, this is the kind of thing we have to zealously guard against. Formal specs for data exchange are very important!
- Hondor 10y agoI know of Chinese manufacturers making parts for US customers using out-of-spec metric materials that happen to also be in-spec for imperial. Eg a 6.5 mm steel plate that was made too thin for the 6.5 mm tolerance might be within tolerance for 1/4 inch (6.35 mm). There's a market for this "faulty but turns out to be useful" material because metric is more readily available in China. I have a feeling that with the decline of American manufacturing, they'll feel more pressure to convert to metric because it's a bit cheaper on imported things and there's less locally made stuff that needs to convert.
- Declanomous 10y agoThe thing is that what's left of American manufacturing tends to be producing the things that you just mentioned: steel, fasteners, rebar, etc. The labor advantage that China has is more than offset by the massive weight and volume construction materials have for a given price. Non-construction materials are already readily available in metric units. I can buy grade 8 bolts in any size, metric or US customary. I can't buy 400 x 800 plywood, and why the hell would I want to? Everything here is built on 24 or 18 inch centers. You'd have to be insane to build a house using metric dimensions. US customary units are nowhere as difficult to use as people make them out to be, especially at the scales being used for construction. I find metric and US customary equally easy to use, and I think that metric is much easier to use when it comes to electricity, but I find US customary much easier to use for everything else. For instance, the meter is widely held to be better than the traditional US customary units. I think this is true for science, but when it comes to everyday uses I find the US system easier to perform math with purely because it's base 2 rather than base 10, and most of the time I'm dividing things in half several times. Need to find the center of a 1-7/8" board? It's 15/16ths, which is really easy to calculate if you understand fractions. That's basically like figuring out the center of a 50mm board -- 25mm, obviously. However if you divide each board again, you get 15/32nds, or 12.5mm. If you divide again, into eighths, you get 15/64ths, or 6.25mm. Maybe 15/64ths seems a bit clunky, but my tools usually have markings down to 64ths, and I have bits available all the way down to 64ths. The example I picked was deliberately bad for US imperial, and it still was pretty easy to calculate. I think US customary units are really confusing to metric types because they don't really have a reason to use fractions in daily life. Math with fractions is really easy to do in your head though, and most tradesman are doing the math in their head. I wouldn't be surprised if we saw a bigger push towards metric as education shifts away from pencil and paper. Metric makes way more sense than US customary does when you are doing math on a computer.
- zeveb 10y ago> You have no idea how hard it is to get Americans to use 100% metric everything, even in the year 2016 in a highly technical field. It's incredibly frustrating. I'm equally frustrated by how hard it is to get others to use standard units instead of the French ones. There's no particular reason why 'technical fields' should mandate use of French units: one can fly an æroplane, run power to a lightbulb and get a man to the moon all in standard units — indeed, that's how those things were initially done.
- azernik 10y agoThere is a reason technical fields should mandate uniformity and compatibility, and that isn't going to happen with customary units (so called because they're not even compatible with pre-metric British units). Sure, you can fly your plane with bolts measured in inches and fuel measured in pounds, but good link getting replacement parts or accurate refueling next time you're in a stopover in Japan or Italy or Egypt. And have a good time trying to sell machine parts into an international market, or trying to buy from that same market.
- GrumpyBen 10y agoWhy do you call them French units while it has been an internationally agreed system for decades?
- na85 10y ago>get a man to the moon all in standard units Not quite. At least as far as the flight guidance and navigational systems, NASA used metric internally for the moon missions and had the computer display the converted equivalent in US customary units to the crew. http://www.doneyles.com/LM/Tales.html http://www.doneyles.com/LM/Tales.html
- run4yourlives2 10y agoYou'd have a stronger point if you had France vs. US and no other standards. In reality, you have the accepted world standard and the US one, with a small smattering of UK units thrown in. To argue the entire world should switch back to the US standard instead of the other way around is ridiculously obtuse.
- kriro 10y agoOn the flip side of this I noticed (from attending school in both countries) that in math radian was used more often than in Germany (which is a good thing imo).