2 ms·
You're right on the surface, in the literal sense, the manifesto is not directly saying engineers should disagree with managers. But, unless management wants t
by dahart 10y ago
You're right on the surface, in the literal sense, the manifesto is not directly saying engineers should disagree with managers.
But, unless management wants to get rid of estimates and deadlines, it is advocating an antagonistic belief system. It is insubordinate and will cause people to act insubordinately merely to believe that estimates should be avoided at all cost, and that contact between engineers and managers should be minimized and not done on a regularly scheduled basis.
Managers can't do their jobs if engineers believe those things. Programmers can't either, some of them just don't know it yet. You can't succeed as an engineer if you can't produce work on a deadline, and estimate and budget your time to meet the company schedule.
Accepting that, and understanding why estimates and deadlines and scheduled communication are important to your manager and to the company, and learning how to better facilitate and participate in those activities will make you a better, more valuable engineer.
- discordianfish 10y ago> But, unless management wants to get rid of estimates and deadlines, it is advocating an antagonistic belief system. I agree that 'at all cost' doesn't seem reasonable. Yet I think they should try very hard to avoid them. Estimates, meeting and deadlines might be required some time. You might had to announce a release date for some new features. That's a deadline you can't always avoid. But you can avoid arbitrary deadlines that are just there to 'motivate' engineers and get them to ship "something". That leads to worse quality and technical debt decreasing overall productivity on the long term.
- bjourne 10y ago> You're right on the surface, in the literal sense I have a feeling that whoever wrote that manifest prefers if it is read literally. ;) I guess that is the heart of the issue, isn't it? The author thinks it would be better if companies adapted to how engineers prefer to work over engineers adapting to how companies prefer to work.