6 ms·
As a Dutchman living in Stockholm I can tell you one thing: they should fix their goddamn bike lanes. Sure, they have them, which makes them better than 90% of
by vanderZwan 10y ago
As a Dutchman living in Stockholm I can tell you one thing: they should fix their goddamn bike lanes. Sure, they have them, which makes them better than 90% of the rest of the world. They're still shit. There's no separation of car- and bike traffic. To turn left a cyclist first has to cross parallel car traffic, making this unsafer for cyclists (and annoying for the people in cars, for that matter). Key issues:
- the cyclist and driver should meet at a (near) 90 degree angle, so neither requires eyes in the back of their head
- separate the goddamn lanes so neither car nor cyclist feels uncomfortably close to the other
- don't require extra space because every square meter counts in a big city
Well guess what, we've figured this out decades ago in the Netherlands:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlApbxLz6pA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlApbxLz6pA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HDN9fUlqU8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HDN9fUlqU8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41XBzAOmmIU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41XBzAOmmIU
- lacampbell 10y agoIn New Zealand they have a nasty habit of painting a bit of the road green, then painting a bit of the footpath green. So the "cycle lane" effectively veers on and off the road, or over busy driveways where no car is looking for cyclists on what to them is the footpath. It's extremely dangerous to follow the cycle lanes our government conjures up. I imagine they have some quota to meet like "X metres of cycle lane".
- vanderZwan 10y agoIn general I'm flabbergasted as to why countries don't just look at what has been tried in other trailblazing countries with issues like this. In the case of cycling, the Netherlands and Denmark are so far ahead of the rest of the world that catching up should be a matter of asking us about everything that we've tried, about did (not) work and why, and then stealing the good ideas.
- chrismealy 10y agoThe degree of "not invented here" among city officials is astounding. I think a lot of them don't really want to succeed.
- lacampbell 10y agoDoesn't help that in NZ wearing a "safety" helmet is mandatory, which seems to have had a big affect on the number of people who ride a bicycle.
- jonathantm 10y agoLike how less people drove cars and went back to horses because when seat-belts became mandatory?
- lacampbell 10y agoIt's not a useful analogy, because seatbelts have a proven safety record, are apart of the vehicle itself (you don't have anything extra to carry around, or leave on the outside of the vehicle where it can be easily stolen or damaged), and aren't nearly as uncomfortable. The safety record of bicycle helmets is dubious at best, adds an extra cost for low income people, and makes bike sharing programs near unworkable.
- cuddlybacon 10y agoDon't forget about finding a place to store the helmet once you're at your destination.
- lacampbell 10y agoYeap. I have a distinct memory of ending a shift at a temporary factory job, only to find my bicycle helmet had been somehow crushed or smashed while it was attached to the bicycle. The cost of replacing a helmet was worth about 3 hours of my labour at the time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 10y agoI completely agree. Part of the problem I suppose is that the seasons are much more pronounced in Stockholm than in (say) Amsterdam, so the number of cyclists biking to work at rush hour tomorrow is vastly lower than the number you'll see a Monday morning in summer. That leads to poor utilization of the infrastructure in winter, should more of the (already limited) space be dedicated to cyclists. For cycling to be really viable I'd like to see cross town bike roads not just dedicated lanes on regular roads. A few streets have been shut down for road traffic already but I hope more will come.
- sebcat 10y agoI would rather just ride the subway in Stockholm to be honest. I see no benefit in riding a bicycle as a pure mode of transportation there.
- unicornporn 10y agoMay I ask why? As a year round bike commuter without a metro card I can not find any good reasons to chose bus/metro over riding a bike. The bike is almost always faster and gives me superior flexibility.
- henrikschroder 10y ago1) Cold 2) Snow 3) Ice 4) Did I mention the cold?
- unicornporn 10y agoHaha, yeah, guess I've turned fanatic over the years. But really, I hear these comments all the time and I can't get my head around them. 1) It's definitely no colder than taking the metro. I put on significantly less clothes when I hop on my bike an hour from now and with proper clothing I stay dry and ventilated. 2) Snow clearance is prioritized on the bike roads. So far this year snow has only been a problem one day. That's when the snow chaos hit Stockholm. My friend got stuck in a car for 7 hours. My bike commute took 20 minutes longer than normal. 3) I have have studded tyres, I have not installed them this year though. Ice is hardly ever a problem. The bike roads are salted, which, ironically is the biggest problem of them all for me. Salt ruins the bikes, so I recommend using a cheaper bike in the winter. It's faster, I get an hour of "free" workout each day and I can get to wherever I like inside the city without combining different modes of transportation using and app and standing in the cold waiting. When it's cold outside, I'd rather be moving.
- chrismealy 10y agoMark Wagenbuur's videos are spectacular, and they just keep getting better too. I wish every traffic planner and urban politician in the world watched them so they could see where the bar is set.
- henrikschroder 10y agoTo be fair, shitty bike lanes mostly appear in the inner city of Stockholm where bikelanes have been retrofitted onto existing roads using only roadmarkings. Yes, the Dutch way of building bike lanes are superior, but there's also a lot more bikers in the Netherlands, so it's easier to justify spending money on rebuilding roads instead of retrofitting there.
- unicornporn 10y ago> there's also a lot more bikers in the Netherlands, so it's easier to justify spending money on rebuilding roads instead of retrofitting there. And a reason for that could be that the infrastructure for riding bikes is so excellent?
- Coincoin 10y agoChicken or egg. I'm pretty sure they went iteratively until the demand matched the offer.
- Steltek 10y agoIt was an aggressive campaign for road safety stretching back to the 70's. The demand, in some form, was always there but it took a while for the road designs and technology to catch up.
- henrikschroder 10y agoIt's more likely that it's flat enough. Denmark is the same, it's really flat (highest mountain: 150m), which makes biking to work or the store less work, so you don't arrive in a sweaty mess. It's easy to bike, so more people do it, so there's more demand and infrastructure for it. Denmark also has an incredibly high spot-tax on cars, which makes biking even more attractive. I have a bunch of friends in Stockholm though who bought electric-assisted cargo bikes, which make it easy enough to take the kids to school or get to work or go grocery shopping, so that might make biking more attractive overall.
- avar 10y agoHow else would you turn left? Cross two sets of traffic lights instead and double the wait?
- mjevans 10y agoStop at the intersection, use the cross-walks to kitty corner.
- vanderZwan 10y agoIn practice that's what I do most of the time anyway, because trying to cut off a car, truck or bus is a much worse idea.
- avar 10y agoYou turn left by getting in front of the row of stopped cars, e.g. [1] in Amsterdam shows such an intersection. This is a common pattern in The Netherlands, and the one I personally prefer to what you describe, since aside from a full roundabout it offers the best trade-off between safety and commute speed while on a bicycle. Granted, my experience of The Netherlands is biased towards central Amsterdam, since it's the only place I've lived, but there's plenty of places there where car & bicycle traffic is mixed. It seems fine to me to mix car & bicycle traffic as long as you force the road speed down, or ensure that the bicycles have priority e.g. on left turns. 1. https://goo.gl/D3jAeF https://goo.gl/D3jAeF
- vanderZwan 10y agoIn my experience the fastest option is a short, separate simultaneous green light for pedestrians and bikes, like it's done in Groningen. Takes a while to get used to though. http://groningenfietsstad.nl/en/ http://groningenfietsstad.nl/en/
- avar 10y agoVery interesting. I didn't know about that, or that as their FAQ[1] indicates that local city law can override general Dutch traffic law. I.e. instead of priority to the right applying to these intersections[2] nobody has priority. Seems confusing, especially as their FAQ stipulates the same intersection will revert back to priority to the right at night when the yellow lights are blinking, but admittedly "priority to the guyw ho wins the game of chicken" is the way it works in the rest of the Netherlands anyway. 1. http://groningenfietsstad.nl/en/green-light-for-all-cyclists-how-does-it-work/ http://groningenfietsstad.nl/en/green-light-for-all-cyclists... 2. Per RVV 1990[3] article 15: "Op kruispunten verlenen bestuurders voorrang aan voor hen van rechts komende bestuurders". 3. http://wetten.overheid.nl/BWBR0004825/2014-03-20 http://wetten.overheid.nl/BWBR0004825/2014-03-20 [4] 4. Yes my footnotes now have footnotes.
- cmurf 10y agoThe U.S. would drive you mad. Pun intended. But yeah, there's a lot of bike lanes without car/bike separation in U.S. cities. The best (worst?) example of this are lanes with sharrows. http://cossdotblog.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/sharrow12NE2.jpg http://cossdotblog.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/upload... This is madness for cyclist and driver. As a cyclist, I don't like basically taking up the whole line by riding right over the sharrow, which is what I'm supposed to do to avoid being doored. But then a car can't legally pass if there's a double yellow line. And yet they do pass in the U.S. in this case, because the average U.S. driver doesn't know this is illegal, they don't know it because the primary means of learning to drive: parents or family member > other people honking at you and you decide to change your behavior > traffic tickets. There's no mandatory 3rd party (government or private, accredited) school. And on top of it, everywhere else there are no sharrows, increasingly people think cyclists are riding on those streets illegally, which is not true.
- ams6110 10y agoSlow vehicles are also supposed to move over to allow traffic to pass if they are impeding traffic. I never see cyclists do this.
- mjevans 10y agoI /rarely/ see it, but then I also /rarely/ see cyclists. So it's a small portion of an already small (not representative quality) observation sample.
- Steltek 10y agoFWIW, this is not the law in every state. In MA, bikes have the right to use the full lane, even if there is a bike lane.
- Anasufovic 10y agoYeah, in California it is similar except you need to use the bike lane if there is one and it is safe. But you are allowed to leave it for debris or other reasons. On single lane highways with no passing lane, if 5 or more cars are behind you, you are expected to turn off so they can pass. But most will just illegally pass.
- smallnamespace 10y agoI think your requirements are fundamentally impossible to implement because they conflict with one another. > - separate the goddamn lanes so neither car nor cyclist feels uncomfortably close to the other This requires more space. > - don't require extra space because every square meter counts in a big city This requires less space. Like, it's easy to gripe about any particular traffic design, but the domain is constrained by a large set of fundamentally opposed requirements, so it's always a big compromise in the end.
- c06n 10y agoDid you watch the videos he linked? They explain how to do that.
- vanderZwan 10y agoFirst, I linked videos explaining how to solve this. Second, even if that was not the case, you have no idea how insanely wide many of the sidewalks are in Stockholm. Here, look: https://www.google.nl/maps/place/Stockholm,+Sweden/@59.3428735,18.0450206,3a,75y,266.65h,62.28t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sCITd8miYo0EHXUX22fl9uA!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo1.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DCITd8miYo0EHXUX22fl9uA%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dsearch.TACTILE.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D392%26h%3D106%26yaw%3D207.465%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656!4m5!3m4!1s0x465f763119640bcb:0xa80d27d3679d7766!8m2!3d59.3293235!4d18.0685808!6m1!1e1?hl=en https://www.google.nl/maps/place/Stockholm,+Sweden/@59.34287... You could fit ten people side-by-side on there. There are a few areas where this is necessary. Most do not, and this is one of the latter. Also note how they squeeze a tiny strip of bike lane between parking and regular road. Even without any other change, there is no reason to prefer road/bike lane/parking over road/parking/bike lane.
- unicornporn 10y agoYear around bike commuter in Stockholm here... Thanks for that roundabout video, it was a freaking joy to watch. The bikes can cruise at a good speed while being separated from the cars and the pedestrians too.
- mikekchar 10y agoWhen I was living in the UK, I was lucky enough to have some separated cycling lanes. The only problem was that they accumulated trash. Generally speaking, you couldn't use them, because they were dangerous to ride on. This, in turn, made drivers (very reasonably) grumpy when you chose to avoid the cycling lanes. Cycling lanes with no dividers had no such trouble and I vastly preferred them. I suppose if you go the divided route you need to make sure you have the infrastructure to keep them clear. BTW, growing up in Canada and spending most of the rest of my life in Japan, I was stunned by how courteous UK drivers (in general) are towards cyclists. When I hear people complain about cycling in the UK, praising the Netherlands, I've got to think it's some sort of cycling paradise. Cycling trip there is definitely on my bucket list.