4 ms·
It is beyond me why the traffic strategist quoted in the second paragraph feels that it is necessary to absolve distracted drivers. It is not a prerequisite for
by mannykannot 10y ago
It is beyond me why the traffic strategist quoted in the second paragraph feels that it is necessary to absolve distracted drivers. It is not a prerequisite for what they are doing.
- jessriedel 10y agoIt's just a terrible article. > But unlike almost every other scheme to make roads safer, Vision doesn't try to blame the victim or the perpetrator. Oh right, because the car safety tech responsible for the lion's share of the lives saved over the past few decades is all about blaming the perpetrator.
- geon 10y agoI think you misread that. It is not about blaming the driver, in the sense that we all know driver will continue to drive poorly. So if we want change, we can't just blame the bad drivers and go on designing cars and roads the same way. Instead we need to design the roads, knowing that bad drivers will be using them. We in Sweden have some of the worlds highest standards for drivers tests. You could blame bad drivers and raise the standards even more. But you know what? Some people will drive without even having a license. You can't stop people like that unless you ban cars altogether.
- jessriedel 10y agoNo, I think you misread me. I am not arguing that we should do more blaming, I am arguing the writer is wrong to assert that this is some miraculous new insight. Most lives saved in recent decades have come from improved safety tech, which has nothing to do with blame and everything to do with minimizing the bad effects of bad driving.
- ajmurmann 10y agoIt's not a prerequisite for what they are doing, but it's a prerequisite to get political buy in to go down that round rather than spend more effort on trying to enforce behavior that seems to be unenforceable. Of course you could try both at the danger time in theory but that seems like a much harder sell given most political systems.
- geon 10y agoIt is not about absolving them, but recognising that people are retarded assholes and there will be human error as long as we have human drivers. So if we want to make driving safer, we must change the traffic environment.
- revelation 10y agoSo? We can still ramp up enforcement. No, another "awareness" campaign doesn't work, banning people from driving does.
- fnordsensei 10y agoIt's a matter of practicality. They came to the conclusion that enforcement would not actually accomplish the goal they had in mind, regardless of the right or wrong of it.
- avar 10y agoBecause you can't solve systemic issues if you've got the mindset that individual users should be blamed for their statistically inevitable mistakes.
- fnordsensei 10y agoIt can't be stressed how vitally important this frame of mind is when dealing with problems of a systemic nature. It's about shifting away from an ideological frame of mind, where emphasis is placed on enforcing what's perceived as right and punishing what's perceived as wrong, to looking at the sum of parameters that affect an issue. Way too much energy is spent trying to find the perfect punishment for single individuals in narrowly perceived circumstances.
- Steltek 10y agoArguing that traffic enforcement doesn't work fails to point out that in practice it's loose to the point of worthlessness. You only need to look at drunk driving convictions to realize this. One doesn't "accidentally" drive drunk nor "accidentally" text and drive. That's not a mistake, it's an all too common cause of traffic fatalities.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThat's not the point. Yes, folks are responsible for not doing these things. But we know people do them nevertheless. Not taking this into account when designing roads and public transport seems like reality denial. All that work to get a product that only works in idealized conditions instead of designing roadways so that you get less deaths from things people are doing anyway.