3 ms·
Genuine question: how can they charge you for sending a file over the web? Even if you accept patents, and software patents, since when did a patent on an enco
by ZeroGravitas 17y ago
Genuine question: how can they charge you for sending a file over the web?
Even if you accept patents, and software patents, since when did a patent on an encoder or decoder (or equivalently a compiler or runtime) then give you the ability to restrict what is done with the product created by that patented process?
Is this just some business model left over from the shiny disc era that no-one has bothered to question, or are a bunch of other folk going to start charging you to put things on the web.
I thought the GIF thing was about production of GIFs, but maybe they made the same claim?
(I'm also genuinely appalled that the only case he considers worth talking about is "will they charge me to watch cat videos on Youtube?", his advice if you want to do something "commercial" (whatever the hell that means)? "talk to a lawyer".)
- rlpb 17y agoI think that this is a very important point. The only reason you need to license something is if the law prevents you from acting without a licence. However, if you are processing the video in any way, or shipping software that does, then you will need a patent licence, won't you? In this case, the license terms could impose appropriate terms (eg. "we will license the patent to you in return for $x for every file you send over the web"). Licensing an encoder might also come with extra terms in the EULA (eg. "if you give us $x we will let you use our h.264 encoding software but you must also agree to pay MPEG-LA $y under these extra terms"). So essentially the whole system can be enforced purely via contract law, non-withstanding the dubiousness of the validity of some EULAs. This suggests to me that a Rapidshare-type site would not need a licence even though people can use it to send h.264 video over the web. However a Youtube-type site would, because they are doing h.264 processing themselves - and a licence could come attached with additional terms.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoAh, so this explains why even Final Cut Pro doesn't let you use the produced file commercially. It's not the web streaming you're paying for, you're actually paying (again) for the encoding. Even in the rapidshare case they know that you've not already paid to encode it commercially, and nor has the uploader, because they don't offer that licence.