6 ms·
I'm from Poland, where recently the government introduced a "500+" program, which means that every family in the country receives 500PLN per month, per child, f
by gambiting 10y ago
I'm from Poland, where recently the government introduced a "500+" program, which means that every family in the country receives 500PLN per month, per child, from the day they are born to the time when they are 18 year old.
Now, my parents run a company which mostly has physical workers - and for a physical worker, in the "poorer" part of the country, 1500PLN/per month(after taxes) is an ok salary.
The day the 500+ program started, several employees left, literally saying that they have 3-4 children, so by just getting the money from the government they will be better off than working and they don't need a job anymore. They are all jobless and living off 500+ as far as I know.
I would say that's a pretty good indication what will happen with UBI - I'm sure there's loads of people who wouldn't leave their jobs because they like having more money(me included) but for a lot of people if free money is enough to get by then that's what they are going to live on.
- inimino 10y agoThey now have free time to pursue another career, further their own education, or put more time and energy into the next generation. The interesting question is what would happen if it was for everyone and not just those with children. Do you think this would be a bad thing?
- misja111 10y agoMy guess is that many of them will use their free time to make another couple of kids and raise their income with another 1000.
- mrottenkolber 10y agoIf the question would have been "what would you do?", would your answer have been the same? If not, why do you think little of us other humans?
- misja111 10y agoThese people quit their jobs because they were happy with their child benefits of 500 per child. This given fact, that they quit there jobs, makes me suspect that they would rather choose the strategy of increasing their salary by their number of kids than by working. If the question would have been 'what would you do', I think I would have quit my factory job as well, actually.
- sidlls 10y agoThat isn't a reasonable inferrence from their actions. All one might conclude is that they find their current income sufficient.
- mrottenkolber 10y agoThese people quit their shitty jobs because they are no longer forced to do them for the sake of survival, and now have more time to spend with their family, which–I guarantee you—is more valuable than whatever they were doing at work. Why do you think wanting to quit your job is anybodies fault, but the employers? What you suspect of other people tells a lot about you, and very little about other people. I would be careful with that.
- schlowmo 10y agoWhile I second mrottenkolber that your guess is highly stereotypical, the intention of the polish state introducing their "500+" program seems to be exactly that: increasing the birth rate.
- mrottenkolber 10y agoDo you have a source on that, or do you think lawmakers might also be concerned with the well being of children, mums, dads, single parents, young parents–no matter how many children/parents there are?
- schlowmo 10y agoThere are various (english) news articles (for example [0][1]) and also a paper for the European commision [2] (so called ESPN Flash Report) claiming that. But besides those sources there is also the fact that the child-raising benefits are only unconditional from the second child on, for the first child there is a maximum monthly income to get it.[2] If the main goal was the well being part, then this would not make much sense. [0] http://www.thenews.pl/1/9/Artykul/250612,Poland-pays-out-millions-in-bid-to-raise-birth-rate http://www.thenews.pl/1/9/Artykul/250612,Poland-pays-out-mil... [1] http://nytlive.nytimes.com/womenintheworld/2016/02/11/poland-approves-monthly-benefit-for-families-to-bolster-low-birth-rates/ http://nytlive.nytimes.com/womenintheworld/2016/02/11/poland... [2] http://ec.europa.eu/social/BlobServlet?docId=16077&langId=en http://ec.europa.eu/social/BlobServlet?docId=16077&langId=en [PDF]
- RealityVoid 10y agoAnd if the intended effect of UBI is lowering the need for employment, then your little anecdote seems to indicate it would work.
- rwmj 10y agoThe interesting question is how did your parents' company react to this: Increasing automation? Increasing productivity amongst existing workers? Increasing salaries to attract people? Employing childless people? [in the UBI case that would be analogous to employing non-citizens or illegal workers] Producing less output? Something else?
- ido 10y agoAnd yet "Kindergeld" (same principle in Germany & Austria) is more money than that and has existed for decades, and neither country has a much higher unemployment rate than Poland (much lower than Poland in Germany, about the same as Poland in Austria). Furthermore they have fewer children per woman, so this apperantly did not spur a huge baby boom. So not really sure what we can learn from that. Perhaps salaries are simply too low in Poland?
- paulddraper 10y ago> So not really sure what we can learn from that. Having UBI produces similar unemployment rates?
- wlievens 10y agoKindergeld in Belgium (Flanders) is about 120€. That's a little over 10% of thr minimum wage. In this Polish story it was 33%, big difference. What ratio is it where you are referring to? For reference, full time day care in Belgium will cost you about 500€ per month if you are not poor.
- ido 10y agoIt's 190€ till age 26(!) in Germany but you get other benefits (most significantly a large income tax break, and 14 month parental leave). Childcare is about 0-400 depending on your income but you have to be outrigh wealthy to get close to the latter (we pay 128€/m with a high 5-figures €/year household income).
- mrottenkolber 10y agoSince we are speaking in anecdotes, have you considered they might have just disliked their particular workplace?
- gambiting 10y agoSure, but they have directly said that they are leaving because of 500+. Again, this is the internet, you don't have to believe a word of it.
- mrottenkolber 10y agoThey can afford to leave because of 500+, they are leaving because they don't want to work there.
- gambiting 10y agoWell, yes, very true. Personally, I love my job and I can't imagine doing something I don't like, but at the same time I know several people to whom the idea of liking your job is extremely foreign. Just as a side note - I think it would be extremely difficult to find people who genuinely enjoy doing hard physical work for 8 hours a day, even at a high price point.
- mrottenkolber 10y agoTo me it seems you imply that its OK to coerce certain people into taking certain work. I view the second paragraph as an attempt to justify that position, despite its conflict with basic humanist ideals. Ignoring the hypothetical nature of your second paragraph, I think you miss the incentive to all "work", which depends on how much the worker thinks his work is worth. Take my friend the farmer, who happily works on a tiny organic farm (hard physical work) for very little pay, because he feels his work is sustainable, and productive (helps others, provides food). Also take my friend the construction worker, who would love to build houses for the rest of his life despite low wages, but won't, because he is unable to find employer that will enable his labor to bear fruit. Sure he could build mansions, and commercial monoliths to no end, embedding stone chipped from the Italian coastline into German upper class house-fronts, or build shopping malls. But he's not an idiot, he won't waste his life pouring his talent into luxury products and consumption infrastructure that won't help anyone in the end. He wants to build sustainable housing for people to live in, houses so cost effective everybody can have one. Depending on coercion to motivate a work force, implies that the work to be done is actually detrimental to society.
- schlowmo 10y ago> "which means that every family in the country receives 500PLN per month, per child" Looks like this isn't quite correct: "The new, universal child-raising benefit of PLN 500 (EUR 114) monthly is granted for every second child under 18, and for the first child if the family income is below PLN 800 (EUR 182) per capita per month (PLN 1,200/EUR 273 in the case of child disability)."[0] [0] http://ec.europa.eu/social/BlobServlet?docId=16077&langId=en http://ec.europa.eu/social/BlobServlet?docId=16077&langId=en [PDF]
- gambiting 10y agoWell, yes - you don't get money for the first child, unless your income is very low. Those employees left their job, became jobless, and therefore were able to claim for the first child too.
- Fnoord 10y ago> The day the 500+ program started, several employees left, literally saying that they have 3-4 children, so by just getting the money from the government they will be better off than working and they don't need a job anymore. They are all jobless and living off 500+ as far as I know. Yeah, yeah... I know that kind of story. This isn't the complete picture. You are presenting anecdotal evidence, and omitting important details. Some important details you are ommiting: 1A) For the job you provide, is the QoL of the work low compared to the wage and potential health hazard(s)? This seems to be the easiest counterpoint to your entire argument. You also lack statistical relevance. 1B) You omit the question wether those workers were easily replaced. If yes, what type of income & benefits did those people receive? If no, why not? Aside from that one: 2) Which other social benefits exist in Poland? 3) Are these affected by child support benefits? 4) How exactly do the various tax systems work in Poland? 5) Are/were they performing unreported work? > I would say that's a pretty good indication what will happen with UBI - I'm sure there's loads of people who wouldn't leave their jobs because they like having more money(me included) but for a lot of people if free money is enough to get by then that's what they are going to live on. Do you have children yourself? Children are a huge joy, but also a huge burden. It is a living hell to both work, and also have children. What some people with good wage do is work full time, both, and have child caretaker(s). Those are going to be employed. There's also the problem that unskilled work in the West is in decline. I don't know if that is true for Poland though. And there is the notion that you either work full time, or you don't work at all. Why these extremes? With 3-4 children you are overburdened by them, and it'd be an option for one of the parents to not work full time.
- gambiting 10y agoHi, sorry that you feel that I'm omitting anything. As you noticed - it's an anecdote. My parents run a business, they lost some employees when 500+ started, as far as I know all of the people who left cited 500+ as the reason why they are leaving. That's about the extent of my knowledge on the situation. I don't see why the answer to point 1A would be a"counterpoint" to anything - I don't think I presented an opinion on the 500+ program? I did mention what I think will happen with UBI, but again, I don't see the answer here being relevant. I also think that you might be under the general impression that I am against 500+ or UBI - while nothing could be further from the truth. I'm happy those people can live and care for their kids without having to work. If people can pursue their interests without having to work on UBI - great! I'm just saying that with UBI, I think it's a very safe bet to say that a lot of people who are in employment right now will actually stop working altogether. But it's just my opinion, it's not backed up by professional research or anything.
- nkrisc 10y agoDoesn't that open jobs for people who don't have kids or still need work?
- douche 10y agoIn a world where childcare costs for 2-3 children can swallow up the lion's share of a full-time salary, I'm in no way surprised that there would be some who can do the calculus and realize that getting paid to stay home and take care of their own kids might be a better deal than working hard to earn money to pay someone else to watch their kids.