8 ms·
Ask HN: Why doesn't Adobe just kill the Flash Player?
- minimaxir 10y agoThere are still parts of the internet developed in the 2000's which use Flash. Even the magic of HTML5 will not allow those sites to easily make the transition for free. As long as there is Flash in this world, Flash will need to be supported to fix the inevitable security vulnerabilities.
- agumonkey 10y agoI wonder what's the state of HTML5 on older OS ... flash had acceptable hardware access early on, html video didn't until recently.
- nitwit005 10y agoYou could just read Adobe's blog posts on this. Not hard to find: https://blogs.adobe.com/conversations/2015/11/flash-html5-and-open-web-standards.html https://blogs.adobe.com/conversations/2015/11/flash-html5-an...
- adzm 10y agoThere are a surprising amount of applications built on Flash and still running. I'd rather they open the source or donate the source to the community than simply abandon it. The web ecosystem potentially could have ended up drastically different if that was done back when Flash was ubiquitous. Who knows, canvas and svg might not have had as much enthusiasm.
- pcr0 10y agoAside from web games where Flash is still king for older titles, Adobe AIR is a Flash platform that's still used widely in older projects. By now, I'd say most new development in Flash has completely stopped, but it will take another decade before Flash becomes completely irrelevant.
- niftich 10y agoThere is a good amount of existing Flash content on the web. Adobe has de-emphasized the production of new Flash content several years ago, and pivoted its products (and customers) towards HTML5. Killing Flash outright would do next to no good to Adobe. Google (and on their heels, Mozilla) are well on their way in making accessing existing Flash content more and more difficult [1], which probably appeals to people who think Flash needs to be banished, but most likely frustrates people who want continued to access to that content. But that being said, in all likelihood, Adobe will eventually stop issuing even security fixes to Flash Player, especially once Chrome and other browsers have put that content behind click-to-plays, warnings, etc., or if Chrome and Microsoft stop their bundling of updates. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12129691#12131403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12129691#12131403
- firefoxd 10y agoWhat do they gain by killing it?
- CalChris 10y agoThe quickening.
- rincebrain 10y agoThey tried, on a smaller scale, with dropping the Linux NPAPI plugin. Unfortunately, they were unable to manage even that, and ended up resuming updates to it after several years, since so many security vulns kept popping up in it. The major browsers are trying to leverage their forced-upgrade strategems to increasingly isolate Flash content (click-to-play, locking it in increasingly-harsh sandboxes and throwing away the keys...), because the problem was never convincing _Adobe_ to kill Flash. It was, is, and will remain convincing users who have run sites with it forever to migrate off. There are enterprise device web interfaces written in Java applets or Flash (or, on rare occasion, both), that are past EOL but still in use in a great number of locations. There are many "applications" that are just embedded web browsers doing the above dance. Flash has been around 20 years - it'll probably take at least another 10 after Adobe absolutely stops any updates (which, I think, would take either a transparent migration tool or a bankruptcy), if not more, before seeing Flash becomes an abnormality.
- vbezhenar 10y agoYup. I have HP Microserver at my home and it has remote KVM feature powered by Java webstart application. I expect this server to last for many years, so I need access to Java. I'm Java developer myself, so I figured out how to start it without installing Java plugin, but I don't think that there are many people who would do that. So probably Flash or Java will exist for many years, may be behind some obscure flags.
- rincebrain 10y agoAFAICS every major vendor's KVM plugin is either the same stack with different brandings or just multiple implementations of the same VNC+[secret sauce]+[custom auth] concept in Java - Dell, HP, and Supermicro all do this, at a minimum, as well as probably anyone (else) with an ASTxxxx-based BMC. I'm hoping OpenBMC wins the day here, at least, so that's one less place with Java or Flash.
- milankragujevic 10y agoBecause DRM, HLS, HW acceleration, H.264+MP3 (which is funny cause HTML5 can play H.264 and MP3 separately, but not them together in any container), that's what I can think of.
- hsivonen 10y agoH.264+MP3 in MP4 in HTML5 tends to work in non-Apple browsers.
- traverseda 10y agoWhat's stopping a flash implementation in asm.js or equivalents?
- sparky_ 10y agoMozilla was actually working on exactly this, but seems to have stopped without explanation. https://github.com/mozilla/shumway https://github.com/mozilla/shumway
- viraptor 10y agoThere's also https://github.com/lightspark/lightspark https://github.com/lightspark/lightspark which seems to still get some work done, but I haven't seen huge changes in a while.
- bobajeff 10y agoActually that was just plain JS and they moved to TypeScript later on in its life. It would be nice if Adobe ported the Flash Player and/or AIR to asm.js or WebAssembly.
- ascorbic 10y agoIt would be interesting to see the Flex and Flash libraries ported to run directly in the browser. Syntactically, ActionScript is almost identical to TypeScript, so transpiling should be practical.
- thristian 10y agoI spent some time trying to figure out what happened to Shumway, a while ago. As far as I can make out, Mozilla figured out that with the amount of resources they could afford to put into Shumway, by the time it reached the point where it could generally play most Flash content, nobody would be making Flash content anymore so it wouldn't be a notable feature for Firefox. There's definitely still value in something like Shumway for viewing legacy, historical content, just like there's legacy in browsers being able to view old Geocities pages. But it's never going to be a feature of significant commercial value.
- MaulingMonkey 10y agoNote that "kill" is just a less ugly way of saying "stop providing security updates for." It's not a SAAS, they can't just snap their fingers, shut down the servers, and have flash actually go away. Even if Adobe actively tried to murder Flash Player, people would still end up pirating copies of the installer from shady sites for their legacy needs.
- dispose13432 10y agoNo. Kill is to _only_ add bugfixes for X years and then commit to shutting it down, while creating a migration path (shumway, whatever) for existing code. Windows XP is dead. Windows 7 is dead.
- cm2187 10y agoWin 7 is going to be an even bigger die hard than Win XP.
- cpeterso 10y agoYes. Windows 7, at 45%, is the most common operating system among Firefox users. Only 26% run Windows 10. https://metrics.mozilla.com/firefox-hardware-report/#goto-os-and-architecture https://metrics.mozilla.com/firefox-hardware-report/#goto-os...
- ConceptJunkie 10y agoI'm running Windows 10. If I could pay to go back to Windows 7, I would in a heartbeat.
- camus2 10y ago> No. Kill is to _only_ add bugfixes for X years and then commit to shutting it down, while creating a migration path (shumway, whatever) for existing code. Shumway is dead. There is no migration path for existing code. The closest thing that exists is Haxe and OpenFL but it doesn't directly support ActionScript or SWF files. What they need to do is opensource the player.
- sullivanmatt 10y agoI work appsec for a company that provides a (primarily) flash-based web platform - Apache Flex, specifically. What people don't realize is the extreme cost of porting things like this to HTML5. We have nearly 1M lines of ActionScript. The browser makers and Adobe are aware of deployments like us, and that's why they can't just pull the plug. We don't need a few months to fix this problem, we need years.
- dcousens 10y agoHow does a code base become so cumbersome, without someone signalling that there will be a price to pay?
- jasonlotito 10y agoIt doesn't. Someone always signals there will be a price to pay. The thing is, the price is not high enough when compared to the profit you gain by continuing down the road you are on now.
- lucaspiller 10y agoFurther to this, a lot of enterprise-type companies I've worked at who have web applications, but their primary business isn't tech, just don't seem to understand software maintanence, and as such won't put a budget towards it. Instead they'll just completely replace it X years later for Y times more than the maintenance would have cost.
- sullivanmatt 10y agoWell, the codebase existed long before HTML5 was supported by pretty much any major browser (remember, HTML5 didn't really stabilize to the point an enterprise could use it until 2012). So you have to continue adding to it while you wait for HTML5, and its popular frameworks and libraries, to come to fruition. Oh, and we're an enterprise SaaS app, so all of our customers run on whatever version of IE was released 4 years ago.
- 10y ago
- aburan28 10y agoIt feels like they have transformed their business model into becoming a zero-day broker for their own software
- tukelully 10y agoI'm curious how the ongoing support of Flash applications on the web compares to the support of Java applets on the web. I don't know much about the latter, but if anyone here is engaged in supporting a legacy Java applet I'd be genuinely curious to hear about it.
- x0ry 10y agoGoogle's new Developer software is pretty neat, reminds me of a really basic adobe flash 4.0, converts everything to HTML5.
- jordhy 10y agoTechnical Reasons: Because Flash is more than an animation platform. Entire applications have been developed in ActionScript (the platform's main language), significant piping was deployed (mainly in the early 2000s) in Adobe/Macromedia-based solutions where Flash played a key role as a connector/target/control interface. In other words, for many important websites, Flash was the JavaScript of today (far reaching, with critical appearances in both the back and front-end). Business Reasons: Adobe has had a rough decade. The Macromedia acquisition was a red pill (IMHO) for many at the company. The company has been dramatically slow in adapting to a new Web. Several major projects have failed or under-performed. All and all, Adobe has bigger fish to fry than to procure their developer base of a free/low-cost migration solution. Other Reasons: 1)The nature of proprietary software - a lot has been written about this so feel free to look it up on the Web but basically its hard to just discontinue software without facing several non-trivial legal challenges. 2) The Steve Jobs Effect - or the curse of having a major figure accelerate the demise of a product that should have evolved into an open standard. 3) The Adobe Coldfusion Effect - Macromedia/Adobe has a product called ColdFusion Server that used Flash technology A LOT to differentiate itself, however the transition strategy adopted by Adobe didn't immediately discontinue Flash support for ColdFusion generated reports (for example) and such a direction made developers less likely to invest in a quicker migration to HTML5. I feel your pain and, at this point, would also like to see Adobe pull the plug once and for all. But we live in a complicated world, for better or worse.
- dispose13432 10y ago>or the curse of having a major figure accelerate the demise of a product that should have evolved into an open standard. Well, they always had the option. It's not like they were working on open-sourcing it. It's an Open standard like Windows API EXEs are, you get half-support from Wine, but no guarantees.
- aub3bhat 10y agoAdobe has had a rough decade? Really, I always assumed that Adobe successfully mitigated all the revenue risk by selling recurring Creative Studio/Cloud licenses, and that Flash was not a big chunk of revenue anymore. I remember Steve Jobs planning to kill Adobe or at least news blog reporting such intentions.[0] Adobe stock has done pretty well over last half a decade even when compared with Google.[1] [0] http://www.businessinsider.com/the-real-reason-steve-jobs-wants-to-kill-adobe-2010-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/the-real-reason-steve-jobs-wa... [1] https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3AADBE%2CGOOGL&ei=2jRWWIHbNdibee3Wn6AL https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3AADBE%2CGOOGL&ei=2j...
- Spirelock 10y agoIt's not really Adobe's responsibilty to kill it. At this point in time (2017ish), users have effectively killed it by removing it from their machine. And if they really need it, Chrome is your best bet, since it handles Flash plugin, security and updates for you. So it is being killed (but by the users) and eventually die off like other old software. Maybe running in an emulator in the future.
- ekianjo 10y agothere are open source software made to provide flash compati!ility already
- caidh 10y agoRemoval of the plugin may be increasingly common among technical users, but I don't think many average users are removing it. The thing that is really killing it is deprecation by browsers (click-to-play initially).
- sev 10y agoEncrypted video playback is/was a big reason as well. The browser wars for HTML5 EME for playback of encrypted content is still crazy, but only very recently been slightly manageable. Safari - only FairPlay encryption through HLS, but only modern versions of Safari; Chrome - Widevine Dash, IE - Playready Dash (and smooth), but only recent versions, Firefox only after version 52 do they finally support Widevine Dash, otherwise no EME prior to that.
- hsivonen 10y ago> Firefox only after version 52 do they finally support Widevine Dash, otherwise no EME prior to that. What's your source for this? Firefox shipped EME support for Adobe Primetime on Windows in Firefox 38. Firefox shipped EME support for Widevine on Windows and Mac in 47 and on Linux in 49.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Qantourisc 10y agoNot really an answer to your question: but it's up to developers(of websites and applications) and users to kill flash, by not using it any more.
- senthilnayagam 10y agoQuestion should be "why Adobe does not open sources the SWF format and the flash player"
- Sanddancer 10y agoThe SWF format's been open for the better part of a decade [1]. http://wwwimages.adobe.com/content/dam/Adobe/en/devnet/swf/pdf/swf-file-format-spec.pdf http://wwwimages.adobe.com/content/dam/Adobe/en/devnet/swf/p...
- dispose13432 10y agoHow accurate is that document? Windows API is open (you can get documentation for it) but it's known that "in the real world" the API doesn't follow documentation, which causes problems for Wine.
- ars 10y agoGo google for online kids games in the browser and you'll have your answer. They are virtually all written in Flash, and it's a huge market. You would have a lot of unhappy kids if it all just went away. Some new games are HTML5, but most aren't - and the old games are still fun.
- gaius 10y agoSo the only argument for keeping it around is "won't somebody think of the children"?
- ahstilde 10y ago"Won't someone think of the children's market" is a very good reason to not kill software. So long a market exists there is money to be made from it.
- Applejinx 10y agoRainbow Dash is in flash ;) (or to put it another way: the wildly popular gen 4 of My Little Pony, with a substantial adult audience, began as a TV series authored in Flash for its animation, and AFAIK still authors most shots in it) Vectors are scalable, you see… if you're good with an art style using puppeted animation in vector graphics (which can be much quicker and still look good and move well!) then Flash is right there, able to be used, flexible to any screen size you like. Lines made with Bezier curves are appealing to the eye, and the rendering is super clean (when it's not glitching out, see the MLP cyclops horse glitch) I've spent hours poking around on the web seeing if there were ways to render Flash clips to, say, SVG: simply because I know Natron exists, is a WAY more powerful compositor but much like Shake (and presumably Nuke, out of my pay grade) can composite numbered image frames, including SVG. That means you can zoom and scale SVG-based clips infinitely without losing clarity. (I'm aware of Fusion and just learned of 'free Nuke' doing a lastminute google check on this stuff, but I favor Natron because it's not restricted to noncommercial/hobbyist purposes and as it's a opensource option, it should be possible to keep a working version of it indefinitely so long as there's been at least one working version on your system. The big commercial software projects, I always worry they will forced upgrade you out of what you use)
- snadal 10y agoWe're here also maintaining some big platforms using Adobe Flash. Even I mostly agree on the need to reduce unnecessary Flash usage on the public web, there are some features Flash provides that can not still be replaced by HTML5, like audio recording on browser which is not available on some still widely used web browsers. If there is a need of providing support for those features on relatively old browsers in corporate environments then the best (the only?) choice is Flash Player. I can also argue on the far less number of development and testing hours needed compared with HTML5 equivalent, where you know that content will render perfectly on all browsers that include Flash Player. IMO, before killing player itself we will should focus in killing all those old browsers versions to provide developers a real alternative for these features.
- szastupov 10y ago> like audio recording on browser which is not available on some still widely used web browsers Like Safari, and it's a modern browser, so much for the "Steve Jobs Effect"...
- CaliforniaKarl 10y agoIf Flash was killed, then virtually all of Homestar Runner, and much of Newgrounds, would stop working properly. That cannot be allowed.
- shmerl 10y agoThe only promising replacement (Shumway) that could be suitable for legacy applications was discontinued by Mozilla.
- dispose13432 10y agoBecause people/companies rely on it? This is the sad issue with Web based tech. On desktop, you can run most software from Windows 95 on natively on your modern Windows 10 computer. Think about it. That means that I wrote a small utility in 1996, you bought it in 1997, I went out of business in 1998, and you can run it in 2017 (that's 20 years later). How much of Websites/games/utilities from the 90s/2000(!)s are dead because the #1 open language was found to have too many security holes (or more precisely, couldn't update properly) and no ones around to re-write them in HTML5. ---- How much of current HTML5 javascript will be "turned off" in a few years? What if browsers (read - Google) decide that "eval is evil" and ban it in JS?
- icebraining 10y agoI don't see this as desktop vs web. Running a Flash-based site from 1995 still works in IE, Chrome or Firefox, while running a Mac desktop application from 1995 doesn't.
- dispose13432 10y agoThat's true, Apple never really cared for backwards-compatibility.
- user5994461 10y ago1996 would be a 16 bit application on Windows 95. It's not gonna work on Win7 x64 or Win10.
- ido 10y agoWin95 was 32 bits. Win3.x was 16 bit.
- ksec 10y agoMay be it is just me, but I actually like Flash for a lot of reasons. I hate it as a web tech, but generally it is very good for games and animations. Rather then killing it, I hope they just open source it. It is in some ways better then what we have in HTML5, but being closed source and not able to optimize enough for Mobile usage causes its death.
- enobrev 10y agoI haven't worked with flash in at least five years, though I had worked on quite a few decent sized projects with it before then. I became quite competent with Actionscript 3 and absolutely enjoyed working with it. I'd always hoped Javascript would lean in that general direction, as was generally assumed early on (not that I dislike ES6). I especially liked the potential for writing things dynamically and then refactoring toward strictness over time while moving a project beyond the prototype stage. I'm surprised there's no AS3 => JS compiler.
- jsjohnst 10y ago> I'm surprised there's no AS3 => JS compiler. There sorta is. Checkout Haxe [0] sometime. Technically it's a superset of AS3, but you can take most AS3 and use it as Haxe code. Then there are numerous transpilers for converting Haxe => whatever (one of which being JavaScript). [0] http://haxe.org http://haxe.org
- voaie 10y agoAgree. Just need more enhancement of security, accessibility (for the disabled), and user privacy, yeah by open-sourceing it.
- crististm 10y agoI hope they don't. The html5 performance in Firefox compared to Flash is a joke...
- expertentipp 10y agoThey are not even able to update it, how would they be able to kill it?
- _nalply 10y agoThere's still a killer feature which is only just now (autumn 2016) being slowly supported by HTML5, and this only for some browsers: Client side video recording and streaming to server. Another one is peer-to-peer. WebRTC is more complicated than RTMFP and still not implemented for all browsers. We have started to develop a replacement for our Flash app and are fighting a lot with specified but not yet implemented features. Especially configuring the webcam (resolution, frame rate) is still in a very sad state of implementation. An example is MediaTrackCapabilities: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/webrtc/issues/detail?id=4807 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/webrtc/issues/detail?id=4807 and on MDN you get Not Found: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/MediaTrackCapabilities https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/MediaTrackC... In short, if you try to implement this: here be dragons! while this is working in Flash for years.
- adolph 10y agoIn terms of installed user base that isn't going anywhere, Computer Based Training (CBT) embraced Flash deployment and as a result has tons of conversion resistant legacy content.
- rbanffy 10y agoIf Adobe kills it, malware makers will continue the development by patching binaries.
- Esau 10y agoI almost liked it better when we needed Flash for video and audio, because now with HTML5, I continuously run into website abusing the feature for advertising. (Whoever decided to use autoplay video and audio for web advertising should be killed.)
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoWe need Click-To-Play for web video. I'm not even kidding.
- cpeterso 10y agoOn Firefox, you can flip media.autoplay.enabled = false in about:config, though this may confuse some JavaScript media players that think the video is playing when it's not.