To be honest I think they did the best they could do given the technology and given its tradeoffs a solution that wasn't as bad as other people think. Maybe 10

To be honest I think they did the best they could do given the technology and given its tradeoffs a solution that wasn't as bad as other people think. Maybe 10 years from now they will do a remastered version where the CG is more convincing. The issue I saw was that the skin was glassy possibly due to the lack of translucency. If I were to do it I would have made it into a holographic voice call for Tarkin and keep the reveal with Leia since there was less lighting and screen time for her. If they had recast Tarkin we would also probably still see complaints.