3 ms·
You're just talking about the design phase of a new ISA extension. I think the parent was under the impression that there were instructions in released processo
by derefr 10y ago
You're just talking about the design phase of a new ISA extension. I think the parent was under the impression that there were instructions in released processors that were undocumented.
- Senji 10y agoThere are.
- amluto 10y agoThere is at least one Intel processor with a public erratum to an instruction (or other mechanism?) that is not public. It's a timed MWAIT, I think.
- hobo_mark 10y agoAnd that impression would be correct. Furthermore, if you are a big enough customer you can also negotiate for special isa extensions yourself (can't provide citation but heard from people at Intel), then of course you'd be the only one to have the documentation to take advantage of them.
- dreamcompiler 10y agoThat was exactly my impression. I don't have a problem with new instructions in new processors being undocumented at first, but purposely undocumented instructions are troubling and would push me away from Intel for new designs.
- dbcurtis 10y agoSo, you are the decision maker for whether or not Intel CPU's get designed into your product? If so, I'm sure several Intel salespeople have you on speed dial. The 286 had purposely undocumented instructions, of this sort: "Ooops this is b0rk3d. It will always be b0rk3d. Let's pretend it didn't happen." So for generations there were holes in the op code map that people tip-toed around. Especially since Intel (meaning the internal grey-beard collective) also forgot exactly what those opcodes were and what they were supposed to do. You care, why, exactly? It's not like the NSA slips extra opcodes into executables that you compile with your own compiler in order to spy on you. They have much easier ways to spy on you. Also, it's not like it is that hard to throw unused opcodes at the decoder and see which ones give you the illegal instruction exception, and which ones do something else. You now have a homework assignment. Have fun, let us know what you find.