4 ms·
What's stopping people from taking their universal income and moving to a different country with a lower cost of living. Do you you have to collect it in person
by koolba 10y ago
What's stopping people from taking their universal income and moving to a different country with a lower cost of living. Do you you have to collect it in person? A UBI of $1-2K/month isn't that much in the western world but you could live like a king[1] in the third world.
[1]: Okay maybe not a very rich king but but you'd definitely be doing more than fine.
- taxtaker 10y agoBenefits are usually contingent on residency. Go away for too long and you lose your benefits.
- conanbatt 10y agoAssuming that recipients are also taxed on their world income there is little difference between someone not working and living somewhere else or or not doing it without the country. It might be something unfair but i cant fathom it being significant at scale. The problem is the people coming in: how do you stop high levels of immigration from people that would not be as productive as finnish people and hence would quickly become a drain on the state. The greatest single enemy of open immigration is welfare.
- omash 10y agoDon't give it to the people coming in?
- conanbatt 10y agoTheres something uneasy about 2 people doing the same job at the same gross salary, but different net salaries.
- koolba 10y agoUneasy to you maybe. If the immigrant has it worse not coming to the land of free money and jobs (even if they're not getting the free money), they're still better off than not coming. Separately, in a way we already have that uneven net for the same work. If you work two jobs you get paid less (net) than one person doing either of your jobs (for that job, not total). That's what's what a progressive tax does.
- conanbatt 10y ago> Uneasy to you maybe. If the immigrant has it worse not coming to the land of free money and jobs (even if they're not getting the free money), they're still better off than not coming. Its a market distortion that could create all kinds of problems. You could argue that's discrimination( there are equal pay and equal wages laws around employment). You would not be allowing immigrants from doing a wide range of jobs that are desirable (and hence pay less) and 'condemn' them to do the worse jobs that pay more. So for example, immigrants will be less represented in arts, journalism, administrative work. Low paying jobs in general will not be living wages without UBI. Think that minimum wage is likely to drop considerable if you have UBI. It undoubtedly creates an "US vs them" gap measurable in money. > Separately, in a way we already have that uneven net for the same work. If you work two jobs you get paid less (net) than one person doing either of your jobs (for that job, not total). That's what's what a progressive tax does. UBI is very likely not going to apply to most workers, maybe minimum wage and down. You dont really need much of a minimum wage if you have an UBI, which means many pleasent low skill jobs would pay very little (clerical work for example). So immigrants would be barred from such jobs without UBI. Also its true that taxes make 2 people get different net income but that comes from their wealth, not their nationality. Someone with a house and a mortgage might get more income than an immigrant that has nothing. That makes it a regressive tax (the immigrant pays taxes that goes to the richer guy).
- douche 10y agoI'm curious in what universe clerical work is considered pleasant? In a world with UBI, I'd be very tempted to pack it in and go do some rewarding, enjoyable manual labor, like farming or forestry or carpentry or improving hiking trails.
- conanbatt 10y agoIn comparison to janitorial, customer service, retail sales, garbage disposal, truck driving, etc etc. There are waves of people that would quit their job for a cozy clerical/administrative work that was cost-effective for their suffering. HOw much I dont know.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]