3 ms·
You actually aren't free to threaten people, not even in glorious USA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intimidation#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I
by maxerickson 10y ago
You actually aren't free to threaten people, not even in glorious USA.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intimidation#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intimidation#United_States
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menacing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menacing
(probably more)
Something to keep in mind.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoSure, that's why I threw the word usually in there. My point isn't that what happened here is "Right" or "wrong" my point is, 10% of the internet freaks out about all of these things, and 10% trolls, and 80% shrugs. If you want to understand the other 90% you need to read all of what they say before you downvote it.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe rest of the paragraph betrays your usually.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoNo, what I mean by that is that it will always be legal to hurt people in certain ways with words. Those ways are not threats but emotional... such as: What I had in mind was a mother saying "I never loved you" to her kid. Or a father suggesting it's the kid's fault that Mommy left/died/drinks. Or telling somebody they're a loser and will never amount to something. Or that they're ugly and unloveable. When you go to the grocery store and you see a mother be really awful to her kid (or dog), you don't call the police (and you couldn't, unless it was physical). But instead you give them a dirty look-- you use social pressure instead of legal pressure. And we do this because the legal system isn't well equipped to handle such injustices (these cases would often be heresay, too expensive, too long/convoluted). But the social-pressure system has its own limits, and gets abused too.
- maxerickson 10y agoThis isn't good analysis: So those people who have been the victim of politics (you used a gender-specific pronoun, now I will shun you, but I'm really doing it because I don't like you and want to hurt you but have a convenient social excuse to ostracize you and look like the good guy for doing it) often overreact and take out their anger anonymously online. People aren't getting shunned for using gendered pronouns. They might think that's why people avoid them, but if that is the only thing they are doing, no.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoHow can you say nobody is getting shunned for gender pronouns? Did read the link I posted about people getting in trouble for the word "Niggardly?" The fact is, plainly that there are SOME people who use the guise of political correctness as a power game. Sorry if you don't want to believe that, but the evidence is pretty clear. Now this doesn't invalidate all of political correctness, because the world isn't black and white. The fact is, there are bad people out there, and they are on both sides (and this is true for almost any issue), and if you cannot admit this then your tribalism is actually part of the problem.
- maxerickson 10y agoHow can you say nobody is getting shunned for gender pronouns? Do you mean how can I prove it? I can say it really easily, because I believe it. Proving it would be pretty hard (logically it's impossible). But you haven't exactly demonstrated that people are getting shunned for uttering pronouns As far as the link, there's like 4 really not that horrible situations listed (a guy moved to a different job, a university decided to abolish its academic speech code (the opposite direction of reprimanding someone for speech), a teacher wrote some letters, unclear). It's not exactly evidence of the widespread horrors of PC shunning. Now this doesn't invalidate all of political correctness, because the world isn't black and white. The fact is, there are bad people out there, and they are on both sides (and this is true for almost any issue), and if you cannot admit this then your tribalism is actually part of the problem. Yes of course there are people that take things too far. But your argument is that there are so many of those people, shunning so many other people unfairly over tiny issues, that they have created a troll army on the internet. It's ludicrous.