7 ms·
Malicious tweet gives journalist Kurt Eichenwald an epileptic seizure
- unfathomable 10y agoSo precautions for preventing a death for a health condition you have are supposed to be put on everyone else? No one forced him to watch the gif. If anything it's twitters fault for autoplaying the images.
- jadell 10y agoSo if you're standing in an area, and I start firing bullets into that area while shouting "You deserve to be shot!", you're saying the onus was on you to not be in that area when I started shooting?
- unfathomable 10y agoYes. I would have probably done something deserving of being open fired upon. Probably I had called a huge portion of the country "deplorable" continuously.
- mmastrac 10y agoIf it is public knowledge you are allergic to peanuts and I intentionally throw some at you, that's clearly intent to cause harm. Intent is a big factor in law.
- celticninja 10y agoSo much stupidity here. If Twitter are responsible for autoplaying then the sender is more responsible because they sent it. But seriously can't you see that the sender knew that it could cause the receiver harm, their tweet stated that was their intent, it caused harm, they are therefore responsible for that outcome. Imagine I flew a drone into someone and they were hurt by it. I knew flying the drone I to them would hurt them, but I didn't make the drone, I didn't make the power that enabled it to fly. I didn't make people fragile enough to be hurt by the drone. But I directed it with intent, just like the sender did in this situation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bsder 10y agoYou can be convicted for expressing intent, as well, you know. Both intent and crime are embodied in the message itself. Once they find the person, the case is pretty much a slam dunk.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoWow! What is wrong with you? The fault is with the person who sent that gif!!! Seek help.
- dang 10y agoWe've banned this account for using HN primarily for political and ideological battle, which is an abuse of this site. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13202289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13202289 and marked it off-topic.
- unfathomable 10y agoSo because I reply to threads I'm interested in I'm somehow using it for political battle? Lmao
- unfathomable 10y agoI wonder if you could torment diabetics or obese people by spamming them offers to low priced treats. If gif images are this dangerous to you, I think it falls on the person to take precautions with their browser to prevent gifs from autoplaying.
- stefantalpalaru 10y agohttp://www.howtogeek.com/257408/how-to-stop-animated-gifs-from-playing-in-your-web-browser/ http://www.howtogeek.com/257408/how-to-stop-animated-gifs-fr...
- doctorpangloss 10y agoWhat if the accessibility settings let you set a maximum framerate for automatically playing moving image content in Safari?
- jordache 10y agoThen the attacker can just pad the malicious content with something benign and then surprise you while watching
- iaw 10y agoThere are a number of potential ways to mitigate this type of attack, what concerns me more is the person/people that do this.
- conistonwater 10y agoI'm looking at http://www.epilepsy.com/learn/triggers-seizures/photosensitivity-and-seizures http://www.epilepsy.com/learn/triggers-seizures/photosensiti..., and it seems it's not just the framerate that matters. In particular, 5 to 30 frames per second might be enough, and it depends on the actual image contents. It also makes it sound like static images might also be triggers.
- darkhorn 10y agoThis explains why a guy had epilepsy in the metro few days ago. There are bulbs every few meters apart in the tunnel and while the train travels fast it looks like the windows of the metro train flash.
- iaw 10y agoWow, this is equivalent to sending someone a mail "bomb" that doesn't explode but electrocutes them severely. I hope the offender ends up with a reasonable length prison sentence. There's a clear line, and the intentional infliction of physical harm is well beyond it.
- unfathomable 10y agoSo to be clear, you want someone to be imprisoned because they sent a tweet.
- junto 10y agoThe target could have died. The actions of the attacker were deliberate in trying to induce a seizure that could have killed him. That's attempted murder, and whether it's via a tweet or not is irrelevant.
- mmastrac 10y agoYes. This is akin to shouting fire in a crowded theatre [1] or phoning in a bomb threat. In the United States, freedom of speech is limited in certain cases where the harm caused by the speech outweighs the damage of limiting freedom. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
- iaw 10y agoI actually think it's worse than your examples, one could argue that the harm caused in those instances are because of recklessness. In this case the person intended to inflict harm on another specific person.
- SAI_Peregrinus 10y agoPlease stop using the "fire in a crowded theatre" phrase, it's not actually part of law in the US. [1] The standard for restricting speech in cases like this is if it poses a "clear and present danger". That's likely the case here, as a premeditated attempt to cause a seizure is a clear and present danger to epileptics. There's plenty of law to cite that doesn't depend on over-broad censorious decisions that got overturned later on. https://popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackneyed-apologia-for-censorship-are-enough/ https://popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackne...
- concinds 10y agoTwitter has a prominent checkbox in the setting allowing you to turn off autoplaying of videos and GIFs. Given that most are not epileptic, and that Eichenwald is, he should have had the mindfulness to check whether the platform could be adapted to his needs.
- pekk 10y agoYou are implying that it is Eichenwald's fault and the attacker should be exonerated. Right?
- concinds 10y agoNo. Please avoid two-dimensional thinking. The attacker is still responsible.
- antidaily 10y agoProminence of that setting is debatable.
- concinds 10y agoThe checkbox is present in Twitter's main settings page (the one you land on immediately after clicking "Settings", not a subsection) and is also above-the-fold. Also, I just found out he said a few months ago: "I was carrying my iPad, looking at the still image on the video and, without thinking, touched the PLAY button." So it seems he's aware of it.
- kevinbowman 10y agoFrom his writing about this in Newsweek [0]: > I was carrying my iPad, looking at the still image on the video and, without thinking, touched the PLAY button. Sounds like autoplay was already turned off. [0] http://www.newsweek.com/epileptogenic-pepe-video-507417 http://www.newsweek.com/epileptogenic-pepe-video-507417
- carlesfe 10y agoIt's impossible not to reference Snow Crash by Stephenson. I wonder how much "physical" damage can you deliver with an electronic message or image.
- concinds 10y agoThe AssociatesMind article[0] on this is much better than the ArsTechnica link, and goes into detail in the legal dimension of this question. In this case, Kurt's situation likely constitutes assault; and this would also likely be considered assault even if you believe that Eichenwald lied about having a seizure, as I've seen some people question. Here's the conclusion of that article: "Just as someone can be held liable for a spring-gun despite being miles away, there is no reason to think that someone cannot be held liable for assault delivered electronically across great distances." [0]: http://associatesmind.com/2016/12/16/can-you-sue-someone-for-a-tweet-that-induces-epilepsy/ http://associatesmind.com/2016/12/16/can-you-sue-someone-for...
- praptak 10y agoI wonder how hard would detection be for this kind of dangerous content. A basic detection for rhythmic spikes in frame brightness should not be very hard to implement.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoSeems like the best solution to me would be an accessibility option on the device that prevents this type of flashing. May seem hard, but compare that against stopping people from being immature/malicious on the internet. The added upside would be that it would prevent completely accidental cases of exposure to flashes (e.g. watching an episode of Pokemon).
- nickpsecurity 10y agoPrecedent for this is the attack on Epilepsy Foundation website: https://archive.wired.com/politics/security/news/2008/03/epilepsy https://archive.wired.com/politics/security/news/2008/03/epi... I'd support criminal charges for attackers who do this. It's just a digital way of causing physical damage. The federal government is already all over this stuff in terms of things like SCADA attacks. The FBI would be sympathetic to the case given that plus hating hackers in general.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoFor those here who don't understand why a lot of the internet doesn't care about this kind of thing (or sometimes tries to shows disdain in an immature way by trolling), here are the nuances. In America, usually freedom of speech is the basic law of what can be said. That means that I can say what I want to you, even if it's hurtful, even if I do it TO hurt you, no matter what. Message is message. The reason this works so well from a legal perspective is because trying to put law around what can be said becomes so murky and ripe for abuse. However, the fact is, words often can hurt more than physical violence. So instead we have norms around what messages are appropriate. Certain words are "off limits" in most settings "Nigger, Cunt, Retard" and people will socially shun you if you use them with negative intent. However, again, this becomes murky and ripe for abuse, think of those who keep playing the "you're a racist" card as a political tactic. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word_%22niggardly%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word_%...) So those people who have been the victim of politics (you used a gender-specific pronoun, now I will shun you, but I'm really doing it because I don't like you and want to hurt you but have a convenient social excuse to ostracize you and look like the good guy for doing it) often overreact and take out their anger anonymously online. I bring this up because. I think once both groups understand each other, this entire quarrel will start to subside. Those who don't even try to understand the other side I can only assume want the quarrel to continue.
- CamperBob2 10y agoHowever, the fact is, words often can hurt more than physical violence. Spoken like someone who has never been the victim of meaningful physical violence.
- ern 10y agoWhile your analysis may be accurate, I don't think this case has anything to do with freedom of speech. If the attacker had walked up to the journalist with a strobe light with the intent of inducing a seizure, it would have no different to what happened here.
- alexandercrohde 10y ago
- hkon 10y agoI have a hard time believing he got a seizure from an image tweet. Sounds like fake news.
- sappapp 10y agoTrying to keep the conversation away from his meltdown w/ Tucker Carlson
- hkon 10y agoWow. I looked into what you are mentioning. Just wow...
- madgar 10y agoI see a host demanding a guest reduce their answer which might require many words down to either "yes" or "no". Clearly the guest's answer was not as simple as "yes" or "no" but the host required the answer be that simple. They clearly weren't pressed for time so I don't understand why the answer had to be only one word. Maybe the audience doesn't want to hear more than a one-word answer?
- hkon 10y agoYes I can see that, but do you think he would be telling his life story if he could substantiate his claims? I think not.
- wfzimmerman 10y agoI'm looking for someeone who call help me build a mitigating plugin. https://github.com/fredzannarbor/strobefree https://github.com/fredzannarbor/strobefree
- sappapp 10y agoNo record of pressed charges as of this morning. Seems more likely to be a media redirection of his meltdown with Tucker Carlson.