3 ms·
This seems pretty silly - the Copyright Clause gives Congress the power to enact a particular kind of legislation and states the broad purpose of such legislati
by pvg 10y ago
This seems pretty silly - the Copyright Clause gives Congress the power to enact a particular kind of legislation and states the broad purpose of such legislation. It doesn't say every single copyrightable work has to 'promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts'. It doesn't say much about what specifically is a copyrightable work at all.
- wtallis 10y ago> the Copyright Clause gives Congress the power to enact a particular kind of legislation and states the broad purpose of such legislation. The phrasing actually grants Congress the power to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts", and restricts the means of doing so to the granting of temporary exclusive rights. This is quite different from something like the Second Amendment, where the explanatory text about "A well regulated Militia" doesn't actually modify the meaning of the clause that has legal effect.
- pvg 10y agoWell, I'm no lawyer let alone a constitutional one but the purpose is clearly to enable a particular kind of legislation for a particularly defined purpose. It doesn't say 'every work granted the temporary exclusive rights must promote [...]'.
- PeterisP 10y agoIt kind of does say what can be a copyrightable work - it does not give Congress the power to enact a particular kind of legislation as Congress wishes; the authority is limited to the purpose listed there - the Congress is allowed to do only the things explicitly listed there; that's how 'rights of government' work, quite opposite from rights of people. It does not say "you can do X in order to, among other things, achieve Y" - the current wording pretty much means "in general, X is prohibited. We'll allow you to do some X because it seems necessary to achieve Y, but not more than that". Any copyright-style law made for a different purpose is simply not a valid law - the Congress has not been given authority to pass such a law, so even if they did, the law is not binding. For any generally valid law, if parts of it don't fit the purpose, these parts are not valid law - again, the Congress has not been given authority to do this, so even if they did, that part should not be binding, and when challenged in court, may be contested and rightfully eliminated. The abilities of government are different from abilities of people - while people, in general, can do anything not explicitly prohibited by law; the government is not allowed to do anything unless there is explicit constitutional permission that mandates that it can do so.
- pvg 10y agoNothing you've typed leads to the conclusion 'The Copyright Act is unconstitutional because its criteria for what is and isn't a copyrightable work do not provide an ironclad guarantee that every copyrightable work itself promotes the advancement of arts and science'. It isn't what the clause asks.