4 ms·
I wonder if people will actually get documentation for these, unlike many of their other devices. I'd hate to see server kerenels end up as much a wreck as phon
by swiley 10y ago
I wonder if people will actually get documentation for these, unlike many of their other devices. I'd hate to see server kerenels end up as much a wreck as phone kernels.
- raverbashing 10y agoMy thoughts exactly If Qualcomm thinks they can pull the same crap with proprietary modules in the server space and living 'off tree' they're in for a big surprise Let's see what happens when a sysadmin can't apply a security fix or a needed upgrade to the kernel because Qualcomm's "proprietary driver" has not been updated
- rwmj 10y agoI can't really go into details because of NDAs (oh the irony) but these machines will boot fully open source and upstream kernels out of the box. We are very much trying to avoid the problems encountered with phone-grade ARM chips.
- userbinator 10y agoWill there be datasheets and other programming documentation available? ARM core documentation is, but everything else on the SoC is also important. Just because there is open-source code for it doesn't mean it's been documented, because the code only shows "how" and not "why". Qualcomm is notoriously closed with docs, about the same as Broadcom. Intel is starting to close up, but is still more open because of the x86/PC legacy.
- rwmj 10y agoI don't know (and if I did know, I couldn't say at present). However the points raised in this subthread are absolutely correct. Having upstream kernel support is vital so that any distro boots on any h/w and so that security fixes can be applied. Having good quality drivers is important, and documentation very helpful too. Red Hat is taking the high road here and working with server manufacturers to make sure that upstream kernels work painlessly on ARM server hardware. We don't think that ARM in the datacenter can be a success otherwise.
- fnj 10y ago> I can't really go into details because of NDAs This does not instill confidence of seriousness about documentation.