9 ms·
NASA just launched 8 satellites from a rocket dropped from a plane at 40,000ft
- astrodust 10y agoGiven how SpaceX has landed things on a drone ship, presumably they're considering launching from a rocket that's been lifted above the bulk of the atmosphere using a balloon of some sort. You'd probably save a ton of fuel if you could launch from 40 or even 100K feet.
- RelaxBox 10y agoEh, not really. It's not getting to altitude that's expensive, it's speed. Orbit is blisteringly fast.
- AdamTReineke 10y agoIt's expensive to build up speed while fighting through the lower atmosphere. Density drops pretty fast[1], so you don't need to fight it with the rocket if the launch vehicle has already paid the cost. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Atmosphere_model.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Atmosphe...
- patall 10y agoWhy aren't space ports then at higher altitudes but mostly at sea-level like cape canaveral? At the beginning the rocket flies comparably slow, so the lower atmosphere density is not that important, its the speed that is hard.
- msandford 10y agoBecause there aren't any places in the US where you've got 20kft mountains right next to the ocean, on the east coast. The idea is that you launch over the ocean, near the equator so that you're getting the first ~1000mph for "free" since you're launching with the earth's rotation instead of against it. Next to the ocean is for range safety. If it's over the ocean and it blows up you don't rain down parts on populated areas. If you tried launching from the top of a mountain in the Rockies and something went wrong it could theoretically rain down on DC which would definitely get your funding cut.
- Retric 10y agoNo need for the east coast. Hawaii's highest point is 13,800 ft above sea level and much closer to the equator both significant advantages. The real advantage to Cape Canaveral is it was in the middle of nowhere with lot's of open land.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- astrodust 10y agoIt's a lot easier to get up to speed if you don't have to deal with cutting through a heavy chunk of atmosphere on the way up. Plus, rocket designs could vary, be less concerned about aerodynamics, if they were starting from a launch platform already in very thin air. A wider, shorter rocket might work better in thin air, for example, but that would be impractical launching from sea-level as is tradition.
- msandford 10y agoI have this dream that someday we'll build a SR-710 that's 10x the size and carry a BIG payload. And then putting stuff into orbit will basically be strapping your thing to a "big" upper stage (but small relative to a whole rocket stack), loading it into the cargo bay and then some fancy flying. I know it'll never happen for a variety of reasons. But it's such a cool plane and when you think about cruising at mach 3 (2000mph+, 15% of escape velocity (http://www.sr-71.org/blackbird/sr-71/) http://www.sr-71.org/blackbird/sr-71/)) it seems like it could make the rocket equation for a plane-launched rocket much, much more forgiving.
- Scramblejams 10y agoOne big reason it'll never happen: The square-cube law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square-cube_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square-cube_law
- Symmetry 10y agoWith a wider, shorter rocket and lower pressure you could also use wider engine bells, for more efficient thrust.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoWhen you're dealing with LEO velocities, the difference between the speed of the aircraft they launched with (significantly <M1) and a drifting balloon is relatively negligible considering the benefit of start at the edge of the atmosphere inexpensively, I would think. Definitely a new technique that would have some hard problems, but not fundamentally infeasible, I would think.
- greglindahl 10y agoSpaceX was originally going to build a 4-engine Falcon for Stratolaunch, which is building a huge carrier aircraft, but later decided it was a distraction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratolaunch_Systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratolaunch_Systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9_Air https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9_Air Stratolaunch's latest strategy is to use Pegasus XL to launch from their plane, as many as three in a single flight. While they had flirted with a rocket that had one cryo stage, Pegasus XL and the other rocket that OrbitalATK might build for them are both all-solids.
- Roritharr 10y agoI've heard of this concept lately, not sure what to think tbh. http://www.zero2infinity.space/ http://www.zero2infinity.space/
- ygra 10y agoThat'd require a rather huge balloon. Rockets are quite heavy. Pegasus XL has a mass of over 18 Mg, for payload mass of just over 400 kg. Not sure how this relates to SpaceX' drone ship landings. Falcon 9 couldn't launch from the air, as cryogenic fuels mean you have to launch rather soon after fueling. Furthermore fuel is cheap (compared to the rocket), and their mode of operation seems to work rather well (despite CRS-7 and Amos-6) with normal launch and propulsive landing. SpaceX also has made it clear that a lot of the things they're doing, trying, and learning are designed to work in other places as well. While you can land with parachutes on Earth, you can't do so on Mars. Same holds for balloons. They just won't do it.
- astrodust 10y agoThe thing about balloons is they're relatively cheap, and the stuff you put in them isn't expensive either. If you want to flirt with danger, hydrogen filled is one way to do it. The drone part is mostly to do with automation, as a terrestrial platform allows a lot of hands-on work to prep the rocket for launch. A high-altitude platform would have to be automated. Plus the way rocket physics work is the less fuel you need to punch through the atmosphere at speed, the less fuel you need overall, which reduces the weight of the rocket exponentially, as the fuel itself requires more fuel to get lifted. Anything they can do to get to a higher altitude without paying a heavy price is worth considering. Turning a theory into a viable launch strategy is not easy, I understand, but they've shown a remarkable ability to innovate.
- nickik 10y agoThere is a reason basically nobody ever uses a balloon, it just does not make sense. It does get you far to little for not enough. You don't save that much energy and you have way harder time starting. You can't do deep cryo fuels and you can't do static fires in lunch conditions.
- gremlinsinc 10y agoCouldn't we build a launch pad above the clouds, at 100k? I know building a space elevator is rough/difficult but if it's a lot easier/cheaper to launch from that high up, why not a permanent structure as high as you can get?
- greglindahl 10y agoLike most ideas, you can read about it in science fiction! Not so practical, though. https://www.dezeen.com/2013/09/24/science-fiction-author-proposes-20-kilometre-skyscraper/ https://www.dezeen.com/2013/09/24/science-fiction-author-pro...
- outworlder 10y agoHint: if altitude were such a problem, why don't rockets go straight up to 80km or so, and only then thrust sideways? Rockets clear the most dense portion of the atmosphere very quickly. Building up speed is what takes time (and fuel). Of course, the exponential nature of the rocket equation means that you'd get to save a lot of fuel. You'd still have to lift a lot of rocket though. With a balloon so big that would put the ships from the original Independence Day movie to shame. Maybe it would be worth it on Venus.
- planteen 10y agoI worked on the software for the star trackers in these. Glad to hear they have already made contact. :-)
- bootloop 10y agoGreat! You didn't fuck it up than right? Or does it take some time to tell? I guess we will see soon. I will come back to you and this comment if they go down!
- devnonymous 10y agoYeah, we'll downvote the comment, that'll serve 'em right! :-)
- bootloop 10y agoI thought its funny... People are too serious. At first it even got some upvotes.
- comboy 10y agoI can't get my head around how this thing works. Apart from the direct GPS signal it's able to also receive the part of it that was reflected by the ocean? How does the reflected signal tell anything about the wind speed? And btw what are star trackers used for? As a fallback for GPS?
- wrigby 10y agoIIRC, star trackers are used as both a position and an attitude reference. GPS gives you only position (though more sophisticated systems can be used to determine attitude). While a GPS outage is a minor inconvenience for most of us, it could be pretty catastrophic for spacecraft if they didn't have another position reference. EDIT: See below - I was off; they're just attitude, not position
- planteen 10y ago
- ucaetano 10y agoLifting a rocket that high before firing it carries another benefit besides the (small) altitude gain and lower fuel requirements due to drag: Max Q, the maximum dynamic pressure that has to be sustained by the rocket usually happens at a lower altitude than that (depending on the mission). This means your rocket has to sustain a far lower structural load, making it safer and lighter.
- valarauca1 10y agoMax Q for the Peagus and Saturn V are actually at the exact same altitude. ~14-16km. And nearly identical pressures. The thing is because all rockets follow the same trajectory to orbit, The gravity curve. So you hit similar speeds at similar altitudes. If you don't, you either aren't making it to orbit, or you're wasting fuel. This is because the gravity curve is a straight line if you ask Einstein, just earth's gravity makes space-time look wibbly-wobbly. Newton calls this the derivative of the balastic arc. There isn't a magical trajectory to orbit that is cheaper.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI was disappointed to realize that "balastic arc" was just a typo. I thought I'd learned a new word. :)
- lukealization 10y agoLighter? I'm not so sure. Most of the reduced mass has to be added back in again for Pegasus to have aerodynamic control during stage 1 flight. The overall benefits of the platform are questionable, at best, especially considering its absurd launch cost.
- coolspot 10y agoDamn, $56M+, that is expensive...
- Retric 10y agoThe altitude gain is significantly less important than the horizontal velocity. An aircraft can easily launch from the equator and add 650+MPH.
- jbuild 10y agoJust an FYI, NASA live streams mosts of these launches here: https://www.nasa.gov/multimedia/nasatv/#public https://www.nasa.gov/multimedia/nasatv/#public
- Animats 10y agoThe Pegasus launch system has been around since 1990. First private orbital launch system that worked.
- sargun 10y agoOrbital ATK has been building and launching the Pegasus XL (https://www.orbitalatk.com/flight-systems/space-launch-vehicles/pegasus/ https://www.orbitalatk.com/flight-systems/space-launch-vehic...) for a bit now. It is an extremely cheap platform that is launched from an airplane. What's neat is the User Manual is available online: https://www.orbitalatk.com/flight-systems/space-launch-vehicles/pegasus/docs/Pegasus_UsersGuide.pdf https://www.orbitalatk.com/flight-systems/space-launch-vehic... [pdf]
- greglindahl 10y agoExtremely cheap? Initially it was $6mm, now it costs almost as much as a Falcon 9 launch. Part of that is due to its extremely low launch rate -- this was the first launch since 2013 -- but still.
- sargun 10y agoif Orbital launched as much as SpaceX, the Pegasus cost before margin could be 20% of what it is today.
- greglindahl 10y agoWith Stratolaunch buying a bunch of Pegasus XL rockets, we'll know in a couple of years.
- nickik 10y agoHow is it extremely cheap? It can almost not compete now and it has very little option of re-usability. Everybody else is pushing for reusable systems, SpaceX is almost there. If they could get a extremely high lunch rate the might be able to do it at a good price, but that will be hard.
- partycoder 10y agoWell, kudos to NASA but also kudos to ISRO for taking the initiative in making satellite launches more cost effective.
- greglindahl 10y agoPegasus XL is a private launcher (NASA is the customer), and it's not cost-effective. It costs nearly as much as a Falcon 9 for a much smaller payload. I'm not sure where the India reference came from? The EU and Japan both operate smaller launchers. A couple of startups are getting close to their first launch, too.
- partycoder 10y agoI see. I made the wrong assumption then that sending 8 satellites from a rocket that gets some help from a plane (requiring less propellant/size) was more cost-effective. Thanks for clarifying.
- peteretep 10y agoThis is probably a tremendously dumb question, but what are the major impediments to literally sticking a big freaking balloon to the top of a rocket and floating it up much of the way?
- Analemma_ 10y agoIt wouldn't save you nearly as much fuel as you'd think. The majority of the delta-V (fuel) to get something into orbit is for pushing it sideways, not pushing it up - you need about 8 km/s of sideways speed to get into even a low orbit, and that's where the the fuel is going. When you see balloons lifting cameras (or people) out of the atmosphere, they're going to space, but not to orbit - they fall straight back to Earth as soon as the rope is cut, even though they might be at the same altitude as the ISS which does not fall. xkcd had a helpful explanation about the vertical/horizontal mistake that is often made when thinking about space travel: https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/
- blater 10y agoWhy bother with the rocket? It sounds mad, but you can actually just send the balloon. to orbit... http://www.jpaerospace.com/atohandout.pdf http://www.jpaerospace.com/atohandout.pdf
- andrewflnr 10y agoWell, with some help from "hybrid electric/chemical propulsion". Also, hydrogen. Yikes.
- mrfusion 10y agoWhy do they need the space station part?
- blater 10y agoBecause the orbital ship is structurally unable to cope with higher atmospheric density so must be assembled and maintained at altitude and never go below the height of the station. There's a few challenges there...
- velox_io 10y agoA little off topic.. I've always wondered why NASA lunched rockets from Cape Canaveral (only 3 meters above sea level). Granted, it's a little tricky to transport rockets, but surely it would have made more sense to move the operations to a mountain near the equator? How much fuel would be saved by lunching 3000 meters above sea level instead?
- karkisuni 10y agoNot much at all. Low earth orbit is ~200km so the mountain is only helping by 1.5% of the needed altitude. Altitude is not even the most difficult part of getting to orbit. Getting to the necessary horizontal speed to stay in space takes a hell of a lot more fuel than going straight up.
- velox_io 10y agoSo say a 4000m launchpad is feasible, that's 2% of the needed altitude. While gravity will be roughly the same (yeah it's higher altitute, but there's the mass from the mountain). There is much less atmosphere* (~50% less pressure & 1/3 less of it to get through). Given that payload to fuel ratio is roughly 1:10, this does seem to add up to a significant saving. *Air pressure numbers http://www.mide.com/pages/air-pressure-at-altitude-calculator http://www.mide.com/pages/air-pressure-at-altitude-calculato...
- karkisuni 10y agoyou're missing the point. altitude and drag losses are nothing compared to horizontal velocity. you need to be going 7.8km/s. Per second! That takes a lot more energy than gaining any kind of altitude or overcoming atmospheric drag. It's not significant savings.
- Merad 10y agoObligatory xkcd: https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ In short, gaining altitude, even 3000m, isn't that hard for a rocket. The problem is that they have to go fast.
- 10y ago