3 ms·
I'd be kind of bummed to lose dark matter as a concept. I want to hold onto the idea that it's just as rich as our matter, with its own quantum chromodynamics a
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
I'd be kind of bummed to lose dark matter as a concept. I want to hold onto the idea that it's just as rich as our matter, with its own quantum chromodynamics and an equivalent to the electromagnetic force, leading to a "shadow" universe with their own planets, life, etc. that exists side by side us, trying to figure out why their gravity measurements are just slightly off...
- some_guy_there 10y agoI wouldn't be so worried yet. Verlinde's theory is quite fresh and it will take time to conclusively rule out Standard Cosmological model. As of yet, no one has properly worked out entropic gravity equivalent of various gravitational effects that arise in General Relativity such as gravitational lensing, a part of which was used in the paper discussed in the article. Never the less, Verlinde's ideas are more interesting and reasonable than other proposed modification of gravity, but that's just my opinion.
- mentalpiracy 10y agoI had this thought as well. Time to start subscribing more heavily to a viable multiverse theory, at least to support my tastes in science fiction novels anyway.
- CoryG89 10y agoSounds like Stranger Things to me.
- logfromblammo 10y agoYou can also have the idea that there are one-way interactions between the normal-matter universe and the dark-matter universe. It isn't too difficult to formulate a mathematical system where two subsets are completely identical when considered in isolation, but when interacting, one subset operates as if the other doesn't exist, while the other is easily perturbed by any values in the mirror subset. I'm not sure if you can do it without at least one dimensional basis unit that squares to zero, though. Imagine, if you will, that there are dark-matter people. We have no evidence whatsoever that they exist, any they are constantly annoyed by all the real-matter people that wander between their dark-couches and dark-televisions, and the real-matter bicyclists that pedal through their dark-bedrooms at the worst possible times.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoWouldn't there be some sort of energy exchange for this to happen? Wouldn't we notice that there's an unexplained loss of energy whenever we do anything? Or did I just invent a crappy layman-author's explanation of where inertia comes from?
- logfromblammo 10y agoConservation of energy/mass is a rule for the known universe. If we knew all the rules for the dark part of the universe, we wouldn't even be having this discussion. Anyway, the way the math works out, it is impossible for a known-universe person to even measure the effects the known-universe has on the dark-universe. The numbers can't come back to the known-universe without an additional input from it, and they would be explainable with another hypothesis that did not include a dark-universe. It way be that all effects we observe to be random are actually perfectly predictable to a dark-universe observer.
- yongjik 10y agoIANAP, but I think the most widely accepted view on dark matter is that it is made of "dark" particles that cannot lose energy by radiation. In other words, it cannot condense and form dark stars or planets. When two lumps of dark matter collide they just pass through each other. Sorry for ruining your dream. :/
- pavel_lishin 10y agoYeah, I googled around after my comment, and that explained it pretty well - it apparently also explains why most of the dark matter is in halos around galaxies, since it can't slow down enough to collapse into galaxies themselves, and is on mostly highly elliptical orbits, spending most of the time away from whatever it's orbiting. I can still dream, though.