4 ms·
Has anyone started talking about what a sane process for handling online copyright infringement would look like, or are we just going to continue this trolls vs
by wmf 10y ago
Has anyone started talking about what a sane process for handling online copyright infringement would look like, or are we just going to continue this trolls vs. pirates thing forever?
- eikenberry 10y agoIt will be hard for change to happen with the copyright trolls being entrenched/moneyed vs. the pirates grass roots/technical. Each will continue to go with their strengths, which mostly don't interact except in their attempts to work around the other.
- rhizome 10y agoHas anyone started talking about what a sane process for handling online copyright infringement would look like Yes: reduce the term of copyright and expand fair use. However, while Prenda used copyright infringement as a cudgel in these cases, there was no infringement in any of the suits that they brought.
- pessimizer 10y agoAt the very least, reduce the bizarre, surrealistic damage amounts.
- tomjen3 10y agoEventually we will have something like tor with enough bandwidth to handle large files and then there will be nothing for the trolls to do. I believe this way more likely than a complete change of U.S. copyright law.
- tedunangst 10y agoIt wouldn't look so different than the system we have now. The justice system assumes a lot of good faith by participants (not limited to copyright law). It's somewhat slow to react to bad actors because first assumption is that they aren't bad.
- tptacek 10y agoIt feels like this whole saga is evidence that the system isn't as broken as we think it is. Remember, no set of rules we come up with can eliminate the possibility of fraud on either side of the debate.