9 ms·
Pardon Edward Snowden
- r34yll2k 10y agoI want to puke. He agreed, like all security professionals, to uphold an agreement. He is a thief and a liar.
- ra1n85 10y agoI'd rather he uphold the constitution rather than some implicit "security professional agreement".
- bitJericho 10y agoAll government workers must swear an oath to uphold the constitution. Snowden is an inspiration in that he did just that.
- r34yll2k 10y agoWe have a pathway to the courts. Cowboys always crash and burn. Hes now a Russian. Hope he loves it there. He's NEVER coming back.
- thearn4 10y agoSplitter hairs, but wasn't he a contractor with Booz Allen Hamilton, and not a civil servant? I don't think support service contractors swear an oath.
- r34yll2k 10y ago"Upholding" the Constitution is not his job. Leave that to the courts.
- pinkrooftop 10y agoLike the founders left it to the English courts
- rqebmm 10y agoSo what should he have done considering the organization(s) he worked for failed to uphold their agreements?
- jessedhillon 10y agoHe could have gone to the IG: http://www.politico.com/story/2014/02/nsa-inspector-general-edward-snowden-103949 http://www.politico.com/story/2014/02/nsa-inspector-general-...
- Avenger42 10y agoYou mean the IG that is facing termination for retaliating against other whistleblowers? http://www.pogo.org/blog/2016/12/intelligence-community-landmark.html http://www.pogo.org/blog/2016/12/intelligence-community-land...
- jessedhillon 10y agoAre you supposing that Edward Snowden knew that these allegations would come out three years after his initial leaks and decided to completely bypass even trying official channels for whistleblowing before jumping immediately to exfiltration of classified information?
- Avenger42 10y agoThe statement says Ellard had "previously retaliated" against a whistleblower - but no timeframe is given. Unless other information is given out[1], who's to say that that activity didn't happen before Snowden's actions, and that Snowden could look at that retaliation and decide not to report anything to Ellard? Even if not, Thomas Drake is a prime example of what happened to whistleblowers at the NSA - and Drake was an employee, who (theoretically) had access to greater whistleblower protections than Snowden would have had as a contractor[2]. So yes, I'm saying that it's very easy to believe that Snowden took a look at what happened to NSA whistleblowers and took a different path. [1]: from the POGO story: "POGO has been told that mention of the finding will appear in a semiannual report (SAR) of the Intelligence Community IG (ICIG) that should be released in the near future. It makes brief mention of the case without citing Ellard by name." So we may get some more information about timeframes at some point. [2]: From TechDirt (https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20161215/16354636293/snowdens-proper-channel-whistleblowing-being-booted-nsa-retaliating-against-whistleblower.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20161215/16354636293/snowd...) today: "The new directive created better protections but would have done nothing to aid Snowden in taking his complaints to the proper channels because he was only a government contractor, not an actual government employee."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rublev 10y agoSo which alphabet boys payroll are you on?
- sqeaky 10y agoHe only agreed to it for the good of the country and constitution. Anyone can see that the NSA and other clandestine "intelligence" organization were flagrantly attacking the constitution and abusing powers granted by the country.
- SirFatty 10y agoAnd a traitor.
- sergiotapia 10y agoIs he also part of the Rebel Alliance?
- na85 10y agoYou sure about that?
- pinkrooftop 10y agostealing classified information is different from whistleblowing
- BinaryWaves 10y agoThat's your moral compass? A dumb piece of paper over the interests of the public against corrupt and tyrannically clandestine pockets of govt? I don't care if the Constitution itself allowed genocide and rape and merciless tortures. Would you ignorantly carry out such acts on its behalf? Is your psychological hangup so bad that you can't even see 10 feet in front of your face enough to stand on your own two feet and think for yourself?
- nickff 10y agoThese authors (columnists who plead Snowden's case to the government) seem to be looking for any reason to forgive a horrific array of individuals and organizations which have spent decades abusing power, and hiding the truth from the public. The persecution of Snowden was not some strange accident, it was the latest in a long series of blows against liberty and human rights.
- azernik 10y agoReally? I thought they were asking for Snowden to be forgiven, usually phrased in the language of him doing a public service by leaking. sure, they're not simultaneously, asking for the people who made this surveillance happen to be punished, but that's like asking for $10, getting turned down, and then someone telling you that you should have asked for $100. One thing at a time, especially since a pardon can help shape public perceptions of NSA surveillance and its legality.
- nickff 10y agoI would bet you that the mechanism of state surveillance continues to expand, and that none of the people who created or expanded it are ever brought to any account. The NSA's take-away from the Snowden revelations was that they have to be more careful with their IT staff. The NSA is not pulling back on their unconstitutional surveillance. I am advocating for a complete stop to the violation of individual privacy, not just a meaningless token gesture.
- wineisfine 10y agoWould be a nice gesture of Obama on his way out. Just to soften the broken promise of not being able to close Guantanamo.
- japhyr 10y agoIf you haven't seen Citizenfour, watch it when you have a chance. I already respected what Edward Snowden did, but I came away with even more respect after watching him bring Glenn Greenwald up to speed with what's been going on. His deliberate decision to share this story with the world was amazing, and watching his commitment to that decision was inspiring and motivating. https://citizenfourfilm.com/ https://citizenfourfilm.com/
- wcummings 10y agoMore than anything, the movie drove home how much he is "one of us". Everything down to the dorky jokes (his "mantle of power") reinforces that he comes from the same subculture, and he's just another hacker. In a lot of ways he could have been someone you or I know.
- Fnoord 10y agoAgreed, and I often ponder on how much that counts for any NSA employee, and I find that a frightening thought.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- glitchdout 10y agoI'd say it counts a bit. At least according to Keith Alexander who recently said that NSA's best are "leaving in big numbers". https://www.cyberscoop.com/nsa-morale-down-keith-alexander-mike-rogers/ https://www.cyberscoop.com/nsa-morale-down-keith-alexander-m...
- marcoperaza 10y agoI can see a reasonable argument being made for pardoning Snowden for revealing the domestic dragnet programs. But how can he possibly be pardoned for revealing the details of our foreign intelligence operations? Spying on foreigners is the raison d'être of intelligence agencies.
- Tarq0n 10y agoTwo reasons: 1. The practice of intelligence sharing makes the distinction between spying on one's own citizens and foreign nationals less meaningful. Collaborating with foreign intelligence agencies like five eyes is a convenient way to bypass the outdated legal framework around domestic intelligence gathering. 2. While spying on foreign nationals may be, within a limited perspective legal; performing dragnet collection on the private communications of millions of people may still be unethical and disproportionate to the U.S.'s interest. Not to mention a violation of the human right to privacy of these people.
- marcoperaza 10y ago#1 is an interesting point, but that's not the extent of what was revealed. For example, Snowden revealed details about our intelligence activities in Germany. #2 is a great point to make to Congress, but I'm sure they've already considered the issue at length. Perhaps it is against US interests to partake in that kind of dragnet activity against foreign civilians, but it is not an individual NSA contractor's job to determine what the American interest is.
- peterkelly 10y agoWe are all foreigners - it's a term that only has meaning within the context of a given country. In case you hadn't noticed, those of us who do not not hold US citizenship and do not live in the US have the same inherent rights, and deserve the same protections, as those who do. We are not lesser people than you, and to suggest that it's perfectly ok to treat our privacy as less important than your own is simply arrogant. Regardless of the merits or otherwise of the disclosures to the US itself, his actions benefited humanity globally by exposing the evil and corrupt nature of the US intelligence agencies, along with those of the UK, Canada, New Zealand, and my own country, Australia.
- zwieback 10y agoI don't get it. I tried reading this New Yorker story when it came out and thought it was terrible and has little to do with Snowden. Now it's on the front page of HN? Did anyone understand the story itself?
- fullshark 10y agoI don't either. I think it's about obnoxious intellectuals but that might just be me projecting my own opinion of the characters.
- rory096 10y agoThis was an impressive HN experiment, at the very least. 14 comments now and only one person even glanced at the article.
- kbenson 10y agoDepending on what you think upvoting the submission means, you might interpret it anywhere from deplorable to perfectly normal. I myself sometimes upvote for the submission (after at least minimally reviewing it), and sometimes for the discussion (sometimes before viewing the submission), and sometimes for the concept which I think deserves eyes and hopefully a discussion, even if the submission itself is anemic. Rather than treat submission score as some proxy for article quality or importance, I try to think of it as what I think it actually maps most closely to, which is interest, and in the most broad reading of the word and what it applies to. Edit: Although, it's possible you meant experiment in the entirely literal sense in that it exposes behavior, and there is no implied judgement.
- fullshark 10y agoTook me too long to realize this was fiction
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- WhatIsDukkha 10y agoClickbait title. It's broadly, if not totally, irrelevant to the piece.
- bdcravens 10y agoTrue, but mods lean heavily towards original titles vs editorializing.
- WhatIsDukkha 10y agoIt clear from the surrounding comments here that wasn't the right choice.
- dang 10y agoYes, but we didn't get to it in time, so may as well leave it now. The tendency of the community to react purely to titles is so strong that it's one of those things that goes far beyond HN and into human nature. I'm still working on figuring out why.
- framebit 10y agoThis is a fictional short story involving a fictional poetry contest centering around the theme of Snowden. It's not an article or even an opinion column. Nothing wrong with fiction, just wanted to point this out as an FYI.
- eternalban 10y agoIn light of the recent (fake?) news about contending camps in the deep state, interesting to consider if Edward here was a CIA asset doing damage to an adverserial NSA.
- sjbase 10y agoNot remotely what I expected to read based on the title... but interesting nonetheless. I gather we're supposed to be repulsed by the conversation between the two characters (I certainly was). A reminder that no profession, no matter how "noble," is safe from petty politics and those who thrive off of it. I imagine there's a tiny population of poets on HN. Would love to hear what they read from this.
- r34yll2k 10y agoHe's a Russian now. Maybe Trump will hug him. Fuck traitors.
- jwtadvice 10y agoI'm so confused. This article appears to have nothing to do with Snowden?
- module0000 10y agoHow often does the justice department say "Oh, we were wrong, let's make it right."? Ever? Pardoning Snowden(whether right or wrong) is not going to happen.
- tanderson92 10y agoSo if I understand this (hopefully, work of fiction^) correctly, it was a perverse interest in the wrong kind of importance to circulate a poetition. And the patriarchy appears to feature prominently as an explanation for why an individual was possibly forgotten in the request for signatures. The complaints about Bob Dylan also seem petty and not fully considered. Maybe I don't understand this piece at all, but it appears to make no sense at all. ^ I say I hope this is a work of fiction because if it is a reflection of how NY literary circles think or act then that is terrifying. Like the cuckold from the piece, I would then characterize this not as willful blindness but willful myopia to the surveillance state.
- mi100hael 10y agoDafuq did I just read?