3 ms·
Hmmm. I agree with this more than I thought I would have. I think the real thing here is that the reason to protect against self-incrimination is really a prot
by geofft 10y ago
Hmmm. I agree with this more than I thought I would have.
I think the real thing here is that the reason to protect against self-incrimination is really a protection against abuses of the justice system, against the ability for judges to force false confessions out of people. If you somehow knew that that a piece of testimony would be guaranteed honest and guaranteed uncoerced, is there still an argument for not requiring you to testify about it, just because it's about yourself?
I think we're left with diafygi's argument about muscle memory, that a suspect may have literally forgotten the passcode and the courts shouldn't be able to say "No you didn't."