5 ms·
Why is 37signals so arrogant?
- optimal 19y agoIf you want to know a person's flaws, learn what they most despise.
- NSX2 19y agoSo ... if you despised your own intelligence, your intelligence would be your flaw?
- pius 19y agoThe disdain for customers shown by Hansson of 37signals is an arrogance bound to fail. As long as 37signals is a hobby, where programmers code for themselves, it may very well succeed as a small enterprise with its current size of 10 employees. I'm happy for them, and for the numerous small developers and small companies that find their products useful. But their attitude is a symbol: a symbol of eventual failure. Too bad. A little less arrogance and a lot more empathy would turn these brilliant programmers into a brilliant company, a brilliant success. Don Norman with the zinger!
- run4yourlives 19y agoMight be a better zinger if he wasn't calling a profitable company a failure.
- pius 19y agohehe, indeed.
- mixmax 19y agoThe backlash has begun.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 19y agoAt least 8 other YC readers appear to believe that Don Norman is the first person to gripe about 37Signals.
- pingswept 19y agoSo far as I can tell, the fellows at 37signals have a highly enviable setup, and they seem happy to be arrogant. For those 10 programmers, what would constitute greater success? They only work 3 days per week? Rails becomes more popular? They become the media darlings of Mars and Venus?
- electric 19y agoInteresting... I have never found any of their (37signals) products useful either.
- redorb 19y agoIf you have clients High Rise is good.
- rvega 19y agoNot if you need to maintain any contact fields other than the (short) canned list Highrise offers. We could not use Highrise because of this. (I know nothing about Rails, but I wondered whether it might be related to their inability -- if it's not just refusal -- to add a feature that their users, judging by the forums when I was evaluating, were clamoring for.) I was frustrated by the 37s attitude. "We don't comment on development plans" was a common refrain from their staff. So... no hints on where you're heading or whether there's any plan to add a feature I so desperately need? And the focus on simplicity over suitability to customer needs was also surprising. "Use it or don't" seems to be their take on customer relations. It's their business and they can run it how they want and, yes, I can think of lots of rationalizations for the way they do things, but they're not a company I want to do business with. Maybe, as an earlier poster wrote, 92% of their customers are happy. I wonder how many potential customers they've lost. Maybe it's a good thing: It leaves a place in the market for a better product, and maybe a better company.
- tptacek 19y agoWe reported a security flaw. They responded as if it was a feature request. We asked whether it would be fixed. They declined to discuss development plans. There's lots not to like about their attitude (look how they handled their last outage), but we're still customers.
- NSX2 19y agoThey are masters at presenting information properly in terms of visual layout. But the stuff always struck me as ... how to say, "fashionista" in that it makes a fetish out of obsessing over details that have almost no yield value, ie, their impact in the final scheme of things on your finished work result is minimal, if at all. But just in case you didn't realize that using the right sort of bullet point or putting one option to the left of the other was the be-all end-all of life itself, they constantly remind you with their writing, which to me varies wildly from intuitively useful, if not always applicable outside their own companies, to vastly oversimplified in ways that make me suspect they tend to gloss over the complexities that can be found in other people's businesses. It's almost like they're saying, or at least I'm hearing, "Look - we made this very simple neat looking to-do list - why can't Microsoft make a whole operating system this neat and simple? They must be stupid or something! That's why we rule!"
- mynameishere 19y agoYes, they are arrogant -- and proud of it: "Arrogant is usually something you hurl at somebody as an insult," Hansson said. "But when I actually looked it up — having an aggravated sense of one's own importance or abilities' — I thought, sure." He looked "arrogant" up in the dictionary? I mean, he said something like, "What duh heck is dat dey keep calling me...arrogamunt...arogint", and then reached for his well-worn copy of Webster's Dictionary of Words I Should Already Know as a Functioning Adult... (???) This helps explain the calorie-free content of his blog.
- sabat 19y agoNo, man. DHH looked it up. Don was just quoting DHH. Neither Don nor DHH are calorie-free, BTW.
- mynameishere 19y agoDHH looked it up. Well, that's who I'm referring to.
- maximilian 19y agoWhat the hell is wrong with looking up a word in a dictionary to be sure you understand the meaning or the nuances of its meaning. If you are going to the trouble of writing a blog post specifically criticizing someone, you had better use words correctly and spell them right too. For example, the word "irony" has a more nuanced definition than you might think. It can be either: saying something but meaning the opposite, something happening when you thought/expected something else would happen, or its use in theatre when things are clear to an audience but not clear to the characters. I'm sure there are plenty of other examples, but looking up a word and thinking carefully about its meaning is just good writing. Its also an easy way to start an article. High schoolers do that a lot at valedictorian speeches. ;P
- mynameishere 19y agoWhen people accuse you of something..."You're arrogant"...it doesn't matter if the word has a nuanced definition. "The people" don't use nuance. Now, if an intellectual makes a detailed philippic against you, it might be worth explicating carefully. Even then, probably not...especially if you're trying to sleuth out some deeper compliment buried in an insult. I don't care if he's arrogant, for what it's worth. My problem is that he is a dispenser of humdrum truisms and humdrum falsehoods that mysteriously result in adulation.
- mroman 19y agoI like how he writes that they "deserve to fail" . . . hmmmm . . . as if Mr. Norman's sensitivities were the measure by which software companies succeed or fail . . . laughable, absolutely laughable. As if ROR were not "a brilliant success."
- jbrun 19y agoIs steve jobs not arrogant? It is a fine line between arrogance and confidence in one-self. I do not know where 37signals stands on that line, but their products are very much like Apple's - simple, elegant and not for everyone.
- daniel-cussen 19y agoYou know, I'm starting to think there's no intrinsic difference between self-confidence and arrogance. Both arrogance and self-confidence amount to having balls and the willingness to piss people off because you don't care what they think. Whether you were self-confident or arrogant comes down to whether you used good means to achieve a good end. This replaces the self-confident/arrogant dichotomy with the more familiar good/bad dichotomy. Then, a lot of people are selfish. If you are doing something they don't like, they'll say you're bad, and if you help them out, they'll say you're good. My (probably inaccurate) conclusion is the people you piss off will say you're arrogant, and the people that you helped out will say you're self-confident. Nota bene: this is all pretty tentative. My guesses don't represent my opinions, or those of any startups I start in the future.
- sabat 19y ago"I'm starting to think there's no intrinsic difference between self-confidence and arrogance" IMHO, the difference is in attitude. Self-confidence says "I'm OK, I'm pretty good." Arrogance says that, plus "oh, and other people suck."
- daniel-cussen 19y agoThere's that, to a degree. But <argument from authority> PG says smart people don't think they're smart, they just can't understand how dumb everyone else is</ argument from authority>. This doesn't mean they go around telling people they suck, but that's generally the attitude at Hacker News. You often hear about criteria being about whether something sucks or doesn't suck. Also, being pretty good implies being better than others. Whether you praise yourself or dis others, you're still saying you're at a high percentile. Being good or sucky is relative.
- nonrecursive 19y agoIf I recall correctly, the "I'm not developing software for other people" quote is in regard to Rails, not the 37signals line of services. Besides that, 37signals continues to grow and be successful, and apparently something like 92% of their users are really happy with them. So, arrogant or not, they must be providing something those users want, which by Norman's own standards is "essential for business success". As much as I like Don Norman and dislike the tone and style of writing at 37s, this seems more like a reaction to being criticized than a well-thought article. It looks like he was reaching for any reason to be able to foretell their doomed future, even if that meant taking statements out of context and ignoring salient facts.
- mixmax 19y agoThe primary reason they have success is that they are really really good at marketing. This discussion is a good example - here we are talking about them, and probably referring a few users to them in the process.
- run4yourlives 19y agoThe primary reason they have as many customers as they do is because of marketing, but the reason they're successful is that many of those customers really like their products. They know they aren't for everyone, they're just betting that there are enough people out there that like them to be very successful. So far, it seems they're right.
- prakash 19y agounlike most of the rants/flames, this one is a well balanced interesting article.
- ghiotion 19y agoI don't get this article. The author compares 37signals to Southwest in their refusal to grant seating assignments, baggage transfer and in-flight meals. However, he makes a good argument that Southwest knew better than their customers what they wanted. They want amenities, but not at the expense of cheap airfare and on-time flights. Doesn't this prove that Southwest does, in fact, know what their customers want better than the customers know what they want? Can't you make the same claim about 37signals? It's like the old cliché: don't give the customer what they ask for, give them what they need.
- hernan7 19y agoYes, I suspect the author and 37signals are in violent agreement.
- bouncingsoul 19y agoIt's not that 37signals writes software for themselves and no one else: they write it for themselves and people like them. Their thinking is that they know themselves and what they want, so they seek to satisfy their needs. If they tried to satisfy other people's needs – needs they don't have or understand – how will they know how to succeed? Companies do that, yes. Apple is doing it by adding enterprise features to the iPhone – I'm not sure Apple gets the enterprise culture, and Apple employees probably don't use Microsoft Entourage, but they're adding enterprise features to satisfy a customer that isn't them. 37signals has chosen not to do that. And I think that's a choice they can make. I also don't find anything inherently wrong with arrogance. Norman's article seems contradictory. He says at the beginning that simplicity is bad, but says customers complain about complexity, then he highlights Southwest Airlines refusal to add requested features as a good thing – but 37signals is bad because they don't add requested features. I love my Backpack. I've enjoyed using Writeboard in the past. Ironically, I feel like Norman's saying I'm dumb for being satisfied with these tools. Norman's post reminds me of designers complaining about the success of MySpace. "It's so poorly designed, it's success must be a fluke! If people only saw a well designed option they would abandon MySpace." Here Norman is saying 37signals doesn't deserve success because they aren't doing things the way he's familiar with.
- ibsulon 19y agoThey did, once Facebook allowed open registration.
- webwright 19y ago"It's not that 37signals writes software for themselves and no one else: they write it for themselves and people like them." I don't think that's true. I think the correct statement is: "It's not that 37signals writes software for themselves and no one else: they write it for themselves and people WHO HAPPEN TO BE like them." There's a difference. I think you are utterly misunderstanding Norman. He's not saying you're dumb for using those tools-- he's saying that 37s is dumb for not trying to understand and adapt to their customers. (Incidentally, is exactly what Apple is doing with the SDK and Enterprise features) Because of their arrogance, they are leaving money, customers, and customer happiness "on the table". No harm in that-- they're rich and have enough happy customers...
- jsmcgd 19y agoDesigning for yourself doesn't show contempt for the customers but quite the opposite. They design for themselves as they are representative of their customers. This is true because this is what they've always done. If you design for someone else it is harder to know if building the right thing. Also you are less likely to be enthusiastic about the product and therefore quality will probably suffer. This attitude doesn't show contempt but courage. The courage to be able to say no and disappoint a few to protect the quality of the product that serves many very well.
- abhi 19y ago+1
- davidw 19y agoWell... ok, but there's also an argument to be made along these lines: they're not "ignoring their customers", they're using their own needs, wants and tastes as the truest guide to what their customers want, because they don't want everyone as their customers, just those who self select because they have basically the same tastes as 37 signals. Perhaps the perceived arrogance is that this model probably doesn't work for all industries, and the 37 signals guys are sure... well, loud, about how great their model is.
- mrtron 19y ago37signals successfully became the company I spoke with a few friends about starting quite a few years ago. Make good products leveraging new technologies aimed at small business. Work smarter, not harder. Make a strong, useful core set of features and provide simple interfaces. We decided against doing it because we estimated it would be too difficult to market our products, regardless if they are superior to their competitors, because of the target market. Although our plan was selling actual software, in a pre-web technologies world. How 37signals has been successful in doing that is quite impressive. That gives them the right to be arrogant in my opinion. Now whether or not it is going to help or hurt their sales is an issue that needs to be addressed. Just because they CAN be arrogant doesn't mean they should. But if they are trying to start some 'beef' to get some PR going and its working, then kudos.
- Prrometheus 19y agoBy earning enough revenue to cover their costs, 37signals is automatically more successful than 98% of other software startups that have ever existed. If the author believes his philosophy is better, then I suggest he buy them out and have them work his way. But honestly, I think he is blogging just to see himself type. Both 37signals and the author aim to "make something people want", but they approach that problem with different philosophies. The author acknowledges that the 37signals philosophy is successful at making simple things for people with simple needs, a valid market niche. The 37signals attitude is not "a symbol of eventual failure" as long as they can continue to make things people want. By focusing on his customer feedback, I'm assuming Don Norman can also be successful. There is no One Right Answer, and it riles me to no end when people insist that there is. In fact, these approaches aren't even mutually exclusive. Does Don Norman honestly believe that 37signals NEVER reads customer feedback and NEVER does any usability studies? Paul Graham insists that a startup should not focus on revenues, but Viaweb did in fact sell a service and was profitable. Should he then write angry blogposts condemning his past self for "doing it wrong"? Should he yell that young Paul Graham is "bound to fail"? The only thing that I learned from this article is that I never want to work for Don Norman. He should have a nice cup of tea, reflect, and then delete this blog post.
- ericb 19y agoOpinions like Don's sometimes come from envy and a sense that successful people should be humble and not affront one's sensibilities by disagreeing, and especially not disagreeing AND succeeding. To summarize: Successful people should be humble and know their place, and not threaten my inflated ego by flaunting their success. If the actual results of 37 signals' philosophies are bad, the market is the judge, and so far, the market seems to be saying "nice work."
- alexfarran 19y agoStrategically speaking, since you know that people are predisposed to envy, it might be a good idea to at least appear humble on the outside. You make more friends and allies that way.
- ericb 19y agoI tend to take that approach personally, but on the flip side, you get a lot more attention being brash. Attention for a startup can be life or death. Attention is a huge advantage YC delivers and another reason I'll be applying.
- bonsaitree 19y agoArrogance?! Kettle, pot, black Mr. Norman?
- sabat 19y agoI love Don Norman, and have since the '80s. But, he's contradicting himself here. "But I would prefer someone who designed software for other people. If you want a hobby, fine, indulge yourself." ... "Use Southwest Airlines as the model ... It is not because they ignore their customers. On the contrary, it is because they understood that their customers had a much more critical need." ... That's exactly it. 37signals isn't trying to ignore their customers. They're keeping apps simple because feature bloat is to web applications what reserved seating is to Southwest Airlines. I am at a loss to explain why Don doesn't see this.
- ghiotion 19y agoThank you. That was exactly what I was trying to get across, but you did it much more eloquently.
- jgrahamc 19y agoBecause they can get away with it.
- ruslan 19y agoHmm.. don't you guys think that whatever they (37signals) say is being said for PR purposes only and has very distant corelation with the real truth ? Or am I over-paranoid ? :-)
- simplegeek 19y agoI think both 37signal and Don Norman are being arrogant (where arrogant in this case should be defined as state of mind that doesn't allow your mind to churn out sensible ideas). Please note that I've enormous respect for both of them, as I've read most of the Norman's and 37signals's work. Believe it or not, I still am at a loss to figure out the philosophy of their design. Even pg once said that he tried using Highrise and even took the trouble to email Jason but then again he was being arrogant. But what worries me is that people are still paying money for it. That said, best thing they have done is Rails, all other products are well hmmmmm (technically I somewhat like Campfire :-) )....
- sayrer 19y agoLooks like a misguided reaction to their rhetoric, and the related design strategy of not attempting to please everyone.
- manny 19y agoIf the coders for 37signals are arrogant then they are automatically on my good-list. For better or for worse, I have come to see that it is these arrogant, idealistic, committed people who are usually the visionaries. That said, the best of luck to them.
- tlrobinson 19y ago"Arrogant is usually something you hurl at somebody as an insult," Hansson said. "But when I actually looked it up — having an aggravated sense of one's own importance or abilities' — I thought, sure." Is he trying to be ironic here?
- hschenker 19y agoHi, is this the line for bitching about all stuff related to 37signals? If so, my complaint goes back a couple of years - when someone on my team suggested using Basecamp for managing our web site projects. Without too much thought, we signed up and began to use it. To pay for it, I used my personal credit card. Of course, that meant I had to expense it. To give you some perspective, the expense system at our 5,000-plus person enterprise heavily weights ass-covering over ease of use, meaning that it takes about 30 minutes, 85 clicks, two printouts, an in-person signature from a superior, and a short jog up the stairs to deposit a hard copy in a finance department inbox, regardless of whether you have one receipt or ten. I didn't think much of it the first or second month I paid, but by month three, I was thinking, boy, there must be a better way. At least let me prepay for a year of service, I thought - and I looked around the site for just such an option. Not finding one, I sent an email to the site admin to ask if I could prepay for a year, or preferably even longer. The reply I got was: "We only bill monthly, sorry." Thinking that perhaps they hadn't considered the reason I might be asking, I replied and explained just how arduous the expense process was at my organization, and suggested that offering a prepayment option might make it more likely for large enterprises to start using their product. The following was the reply I got: "I understand your position, but we are a month-to-month service. Some of the largest companies in the world use Basecamp and gladly pay month-to-month. And the smallest companies in the world love it too."
- nonrecursive 19y agoI wonder what the "the smallest companies in the world" would be... Ship in a Bottle Distributor? Traveling Flea Circus?
- joshwa 19y agoeasy: nanotech!
- run4yourlives 19y agoWith all due respect though, you can't blame them for the retarded process at your company... why should they spend the money to change process and structure when your company isn't willing to? (No, the answer isn't because you pay them $25 a month.:-)
- tptacek 19y agoThe premise of this article is that, because the author doesn't like Basecamp, and 37Signals doesn't respond by catering to him, they're an "arrogant hobby" business. Vote accordingly.
- ebuchholz 19y agoYes, in general, simplicity in design is good, but I agree that 37signals takes it a step too far by deciding what their customers need or don't need. Attitudes aside, it's great that they are successful.I understand the concept of forced scarcity through limited features and staffing, but I don't agree with their attitude with their customers. Sure, 92% of their customers are happy with them, they provide a month to month service, the unhappy ones left long ago.