7 ms·
A note: Constantly referring to women as girls is a part of the problem. There are certainly women that I know and would use that term to refer to them, for var
by Jtsummers 10y ago
A note: Constantly referring to women as girls is a part of the problem. There are certainly women that I know and would use that term to refer to them, for various reason. Familiarity, primarily, as in: "Hey, what are the girls doing tonight?" as a question posed to a female friend about our common group of female friends. But you use girl not just for the specific person (Julie Horvath) but for all women ("If a girl feels harassed..."), and not in a case of familiarity. It's removing them from the category of peers (as adult persons) and putting them into a subordinate group (child persons). And it presents the possibility of dismissing the claim because they're not mature and don't really understand the difference between harassment and ribbing.
Language matters.
- edblarney 10y agoI agree that language matters but I don't agree with your assertion. 'Girl' is the feminine of 'Boy' but it is ALSO the feminine of 'guy'. As in: "the guys and I are going for lunch, are you in?" There is no condescension or diminution.
- edblarney 10y ago"This is an indicator of the bubble you're living in. It may be common vernacular amongst all or nearly all of the people you interact with, but it is simultaneously highly disrespectful. It might be worth taking a step back and asking yourself what other things you consider normal might actually be disrespect" You might want to consider that you live in a bubble - and that your finger wagging is condescending. 'Girl' is the feminine of 'Guy' - just as much as it is also the feminine of 'Boy'. Consider those words for a moment and their common usage. I'll bet that 'girl' is your vernacular as much as it is mine, because it's universally common. "That guy/girl is smart" - both acceptable. "The guys/girls are going out for lunch" - both acceptable. "Guys/girls, huddle in, let's chat" - both acceptable. "The guys/girls from marketing are in town this week" - both acceptable.
- throwaway-hn123 10y agoBoy, you're wrong.
- edblarney 10y agoIn what way? You've attacked me twice now with ad-hominem, even worse, not providing any reasonable argument. In which case above, do you think the interchange of 'guy' or 'girl' would not be acceptable? Try to take thoughtful position, without trolling ad-hominem.
- throwaway-hn123 10y agoWhat ad-hominem, boy? I really hope you're not trying to suggest the use of the word 'boy' is some kind of ad-hom attack. The irony would be too strong.
- zepto 10y agoCould it be that you are both living in a bubble and both being condescending?
- sanderjd 10y agoYeah, we all live in our own bubble. You're right that I was being condescending. My goal was to point out that things that appear indelibly true to you may not be universally true throughout society. Probably not a fight worth having, oops!
- zepto 10y agoTo me? Or to the person you were replying to? In any case - I agree with you that we are at a time when we need to confront the fact that different social points of view can have equal validity and it's not just a matter of one side overpowering the other anymore.
- 10y ago
- sanderjd 10y agoThis is an indicator of the bubble you're living in. It may be common vernacular amongst all or nearly all of the people you interact with, but it is simultaneously highly disrespectful. It might be worth taking a step back and asking yourself what other things you consider normal might actually be disrespectful.
- beachstartup 10y agothe more language- and thought-policing you try to push, the more of a right-wing backlash (i.e. trump) you will see from the public at large.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TenOhms 10y agoA more plausible explanation is that there is a cultural difference. Things must be taken in context, and every culture has words or thoughts that seem demeaning to another culture, but they were not intended to be. As an example, compare the use of the N word between a group of black people and a non-black group of people.
- Karunamon 10y agoThe fact that you see it as disrespectful is just as indicative of the bubble you live in. Everybody has one, and your statement has not been proven to have value outside of your own.
- sanderjd 10y agoI agree with the part about everybody being in their own bubble (and I find my comment that you replied to rather cringe-y now in its implication otherwise), but I'm not sure about the part where my statement has not "proven to have value" outside my own bubble. I'm not totally sure what that means, but from my perspective, it is valuable to know when the things you say are disrespectful to a different set of people than the ones you usually interact with.
- lostboys67 10y agoCite - yes I know in some countrys "guys" is used in non gendered way now. But I have Never heard that Girl is the Feminine of Guy (hint English does not have gendered words like say French does)
- geoka9 10y agoHonest question: what would be the equivalent of "guy" in your opinion when referring to a female in a professional environment (assuming that referring to males as "guys" is acceptable)?
- sanderjd 10y agoI don't think there is one. One of the results of society being imbalanced for a very long time is that language is also imbalanced. It can be frustrating.
- chrischen 10y ago"Gals"
- edblarney 10y ago"Honest question: what would be the equivalent of "guy" --> "I don't think there is one." No - the feminine of 'guy' is 'girl'. Point blank. "The guys/girls are in town this week" "Those guys/girls are from Facebook" This is very common and normal language.
- zepto 10y agoThey are not equivalent because they have different connotations. These aren't values in an enum, they are socially constructed symbols.
- Jtsummers 10y agoGirl is a diminutive. Guy is not. When you're familiar with someone it's probably fine to use girl with them. But when you aren't familiar, or are speaking about them to others in a professional sense, it's probably bad form.
- monksy 10y agoOn that same note. Girl may be "diminutive" (I don't agree with that), it's not derogatory. (Unless you say a teenage girl for someone who is an adult) Even if used intentionally to putdown your subject, it's not effective. ("You're a girl" .. well yes, the meaning of the word is incredibly flexible and doesn't indicate maturity or explicitly state negative qualities) I don't think women have the equivalent to "boy." Boy is used by women to adult men to degrade the subject. Even though we have two similar words which may belittle the person, we have another case where the womens' version is watered down to belittle less. ----- That being said "dude" is a pretty weird neutral term is odd in use, and formality.
- kefka 10y agoAnd this is a great example of derailing a conversation by attacking the specific language used. This tactic is used to great effect by SJW's. I only need look down the thread to see how much you caused. Many a times, this type of harassment is mainly what women claim against men. But what exactly is harassment? Well, there's no real good definition. There's a point where any sane individual would agree... But I've also met people that simply asking to go on a date was "harassment". I've also seen cases of obvious sexual harassment (me, when I was sexually harassed by a manager, and then they were subsequently fired). And then I've also witnessed claims of it that one party blew out of proportion. Except, because someone says " girls", you jump all over that and derail the underlying ideas of harassment and how to develop ideas of what it actually is, and not gut feelings.
- Jtsummers 10y agoNot sure I derailed anything. Tallied the comments. Mine and the responses to it are about 43 in total. But there are 353 (at the time of writing this) comments on this post. So 310 comments unrelated to my comment. I suspect, then, that no derailment actually occurred. Rather, a bunch of discussions are happening simultaneously, and language and its implications are one of those conversations. Also, I'm not a TLA, I'm a human benig.
- yarou 10y agoLet's be honest here, we both know what you were doing. I'm surprised the mods tolerate this type of virtue signaling and inflammatory behavior. You're clearly trying to bait the person you're responding to. And you're not even doing it correctly. Gendered pronouns in general shouldn't be used. Please use "Xir" or "Zhe" when referring to a group of individuals whose sex may be female, but whose gender identity is unknown.
- st3v3r 10y agoThe guy's entire post was dripping with disdain and contempt for women. Calling them girls was just an example. That is used out of disrespect. I guarantee you that guy would not use the term "boys" to refer to men.