3 ms·
"It's very hard to be the only person promising to revolt, but it gets easier the more people that do it." Been there, done that. Several times. It's why I don
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
"It's very hard to be the only person promising to revolt, but it gets easier the more people that do it."
Been there, done that. Several times. It's why I don't do it anymore. That threshold is higher than many people think. What happens most is insider attack where a person unsure will sell the people out to administration or management. Revolt gets squashed with that person maybe getting some compensation for it. Hard to build up to the necessary threshold without this happening. Once it does, it's witchhunting time. Most people just aren't cut out for spending long periods of time in such circumstances.
I doubt the tech people hoping from one cozy job to the next at six digits will have more endurance or patience than rebels in other sectors. I still see potential, esp if a wave of support started on social media somehow, but it looks bleak if we're talking organized rebellion inside likes of Facebook or Google.
- tptacek 10y agoWhat other similar things have you tried to organize? How many people got involved? What were the outcomes?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI have to keep the details private. All involved under 30 people who had some fight in them and motivation to resist in direction I pushed. First one all but me backed out on key moment with one selling me out. Others had similar pattern with lots of support in those that talk, too few actually acting, some ratting, and it fizzling out as actors get scared or removed from a situation with too many talkers. All went that way. Im actually doing another right now but directly and in open since I anticipate others will bitch out. In any case, the pattern I describe seems very similar to large-scale activism work or just how people in this country talk vs respond on big issues. It's either human nature itself or a weakness of American culture.
- tptacek 10y agoOk, but right now we're closing on on 1300 signatures for the NeverAgain.tech pledge. I'm not so worried about the kinds of things that happen in 30 person groups, though I recognize those things are real.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThey have 1300 supporting their position. Which large, tech companies or VC-funded companies have agreed to their terms with operational implementations on the way? Or is it a tiny fraction of the tech community talking with little delivered while most support status quo? That's the pattern from the 30 person groups and national level things in politics. If it's not happening & they're succeeding, they're an example of something going well that doesnt fit what Im describing. Are they succeeding?
- tptacek 10y agoI don't understand your question. It's not a petition, it's a pledge. There's nothing their employers can do about it; it's not up to them. That's the point of a pledge.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI may be misunderstanding the reason for the example. You were talking about revolt and what threshold of support was required originally. My trend was personal experiences involving revolt where most talk more than they act when huge sacrifice is necessary. A common problem in politics in general. So, this is a pledge to not put together data that can be used for (basically) targeting minorities, destroying such data, the backups, etc. Also boycotting work for them and legal resistance. It follows they must be refusing to work at such places (eg Facebook, Google), not using their products/services, pushing for changes at them if they do work there before quiting if there's No's, preventing it in other companies via business model, and so on. They would expect change in tech company practices to result due to this pledge/revolt. We'll be able to judge their current commitment based on their employment and if they boycott all such surveillance services with forms of PII that can be used for targeting. The latter due to Vote With Wallet concept of not financially supporting evil companies. We'll see if it fits my pattern by looking for whether a huge percentage of developers are committed to this over maybe next year or so. Also what changes happen in these companies' data collection and retention practices due to pressure from the pledge/revolt causing enough high-talent turnover. My pattern, if they fall victim to it, says they'll remain a tiny percentage of tech employees, probably use surveillance-powered goods, and likes of Google or Facebook continue collecting a trove of data that benefits such targeting since pressure didnt work. I hope it does work, though, as I support the goals of the pledge. I'll leave this tangent at that.