3 ms·
> Create a climate of "snitches get stitches" and maybe they will think twice before selling out the lives of a billion people. Committing crimes against peopl
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> Create a climate of "snitches get stitches" and maybe they will think twice before selling out the lives of a billion people.
Committing crimes against people who defect is obviously not going to work. They'll just arrest you for it.
But suppose we create a certification. To get certified all you have to do is promise not to work on a specific list of things: Mass surveillance, backdoors, etc. To lose certification forever all you have to do is work on one of those things.
Then we can have companies offer to put it in their contracts with their international customers that they'll only hire employees and contractors with that certification. Any companies that aren't actually working on mass surveillance etc. are happy to do this because it gives their customers more confidence that they aren't, and if it becomes popular then any companies that don't will become suspicious and lose business.
Then all employees at all companies will have to think twice before working on such things, because it would mean giving up any possibility to work at any of the companies who won't hire such people, which with success will constitute most of the industry.
- TuringTest 10y ago> To lose certification forever all you have to do is work on one of those things and get caught. There, fixed that for you. That small detail is why your attractive idea wouldn't work in real life. How many years it took for the car industry scandal about tampering with emission tests to be revealed? And it only got to ruin the the reputations of the few engineers involved in the forgery.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> There, fixed that for you. That small detail is why your attractive idea wouldn't work in real life. How many years it took for the car industry scandal about tampering with emission tests to be revealed? And it only got to ruin the the reputations of the few engineers involved in the forgery. The same goes for theft and graft and murder. You don't get punished if you don't get caught. But you could get caught, and you don't know ahead of time whether you will or not.
- couchand 10y agoCanaryCertified (TM).
- Kalium 10y ago> But suppose we create a certification. To get certified all you have to do is promise not to work on a specific list of things: Mass surveillance, backdoors, etc. To lose certification forever all you have to do is work on one of those things. I fear you may be making a potentially dangerous assumption about how engineering works in a compartmentalized environment. Engineers do not always know the purpose of the systems on which they work. Once upon a time in Texas I spent several years working on a system to run a binary sample through a series of plugins that produced analysis of the binary sample. I was told that this was to help detect malware - and it could certainly do that. Did I know that for certain? No. Were there other possible uses, such as to determine how detectable a given piece of experimental malware was? Yes. Did I have any way, shape, form, manner, or means of finding out what 100% of uses were? No. A lot of software has more than one possible use.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoYou don't prohibit making or having knives, you prohibit stabbing people.
- Kalium 10y agoThe problem with the certification model proposed is that it seeks to prohibit stabbings, but works on people who make knives.