3 ms·
> actual AI Ex-game developer here. I was also surprised at what "AI" looked like when I entered the game industry. It's easy to dismiss what game devs do as n
by munificent 10y ago
> actual AI
Ex-game developer here. I was also surprised at what "AI" looked like when I entered the game industry. It's easy to dismiss what game devs do as not "actual" AI, when really it's just two definitions of the terms.
In the academic community today, "AI" implies learning, often unassisted. That's a fine definition, but it's also a recent one.
When "AI" was originally coined, it simply referred to software that did things people used to think required some intelligence. Stuff like OCR and playing chess.
As our expectations of what computers can do grew, we kept redefining "intelligence" to mean fewer and fewer things. There's a weird feedback loop here, because our informal definition of "intelligence" is often "whatever only people can do". As soon as computers could beat us at chess, "beating a human at chess" got kicked out of the "intelligence" set. That meant chess software no longer gets called AI.
In games, "AI" just means "the code that controls what likelife in-game entities do". In the fiction of the game world, these entities have real intelligence. The game's implementation of that an artificial simulation of that intelligence. Thus -- "artificial intelligence".
In practice, it often lines up with the historical definition of what kinds of code was called "artificial intelligence". Many early AI researchers were in fact using games as their testbed.
It also ends up being fairly simple. Humans are so eager to anthropomorphize that it doesn't take that much simulated intelligence to get us to see a simulated entity as acting "alive". Simpler AI is also easier to implement, easier to debug, faster to execute, and much simpler to tune.
Learning algorithms are rare in games because they more often than not implement an anti-goal. A game designer's job is to give the player a carefully balanced experience that rides the knife edge between too easy (boring) and too hard (frustrating).
It is not the game's goal to make the entities as smart as possible. They would just kick the player's ass and that's no fun.
An AI that learned on its own is very hard to tune and would likely make the game no fun.
I do think there's room in games for learning AIs. But what I think would make sense is:
1. The fitness function the AI should train for is fun, not beating the player. Instead of rewarding AIs that win, reward ones that the player says were fun to play against.
2. You let the developers train the AI, then you bake those parameters in and don't do learning on the end user's machine.