6 ms·
I totally understand why Ann Arbor is on the list. But more than a little surprised not to see Detroit. Lots of my younger engineering friends from out state
by rmason 10y ago
I totally understand why Ann Arbor is on the list. But more than a little surprised not to see Detroit. Lots of my younger engineering friends from out state Michigan are finding jobs and settling into the downtown area. Just heard yesterday that Snapchat is opening an office downtown.
- pmiller2 10y agoI'm from Michigan, and there's no way you could pay me enough to live in Detroit. I could bear to live in Ann Arbor for the right amount of money, but forget Detroit.
- __derek__ 10y agoI'm also from Michigan, and living in Detroit is actually pretty cool.[1] It has great beer, good food, a low cost-of-living, great bikability, and a thriving scene of 20/30-somethings (both yuppies and not). Granted, it is a spiky place: you either love it (hit that peak) or hate it (land in those valleys). The phrase "to each their own" certainly applies. [1]: I don't live in Michigan any more, but I do visit Detroit regularly.
- headcanon 10y agoI think you need to take another visit to that city, friend. It's not even the same place that it was a few years ago.
- kevindong 10y agoI went to the University of Michigan hackathon (MHacks) back in October of this year which was, for some reason, hosted in Detroit (absolutely _terribly_ done hackathon, btw). I was shocked at how bad Detroit actually was. In my opinion, it's actually worse than what people say. A story I heard from one of the people that live in the area is that people leave their cars unlocked and devoid of valuable belongs so crackheads won't break their windows to search for money. They're still going to search, but they won't break the windows.
- ap22213 10y agoMaybe it's changed. But, I worked in Ann Arbor in software from the late 90s to the mid 2000s, and Detroit was way cooler than Ann Arbor. If you want to wear polo shirts, sweaters around the neck, eat pâté and cheese, drink wine, and look beautiful, then A^2 is your place. But, if you want anything interesting, you go into Detroit.
- pimlottc 10y agoHey now, I'll not hear anyone talking bad about cheese.
- tcbawo 10y agoAlso surprising that Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, and Pittsburgh aren't in the list.
- qntty 10y agoAlso surprised about Columbus and Pittsburgh. Not so surprised about Cincinnati and Cleveland.
- blackguardx 10y agoWhy Columbus over Cleveland?
- qntty 10y agoI've never been to Columbus, but I went to college in Ohio and it seems people tended to move to Columbus and Pittsburgh, but obviously anecdotes aren't really data.
- blackguardx 10y agoI went to college in Cleveland and have been all over PA and Ohio. Cleveland seemed much more dynamic that Columbus to me. And Pittsburgh was more dynamic than Cleveland.
- ap22213 10y agoPittsburgh is a strange place. I was thinking of buying a 2nd home in Shadyside about 4 years ago. I recently visited, and the homes that I was looking at have appreciated 3x! I spent some time talking to a lot of the locals, and they've not seen much change in the past 10 years. Pittsburgh has recently been ranked as one of the cities in the US with the highest inequality. I love Pittsburgh, but it's uneven.
- __derek__ 10y agoI suspect that the phenomenon you've noted is captured by the fact that Detroit is grey rather than pink.
- headcanon 10y agoI think a lot of it is class dynamics, as well as geography. Detroit is very spread out and most white collar workers who work in the city live in the suburbs - Royal Oak, Bloomfield, Clarkston, etc. The areas being gentrified by young professionals that would be considered "Detroit" are concentrated in the Downtown and Midtown districts. Hamtramck is in the gentrification process as well, but it's considered a separate city. Basically the fact that the newly-relocated white collar workers are all spread out and are offset by the mostly blue-collar old guard likely explains why it wouldn't make the top of the "Brain concentration" index. Ann Arbor, on the other hand, makes more sense because its geography is so much more centralized, and is only supported by a few bedroom communities (Dexter, Selene, and Chelsea)
- cylinder 10y agoEveryone eventually leaves their 20s and many will want to raise a family in safe place with good schools. This can definitely be done in urban areas but definitely not in Detroit (city proper). Not only that but people want to live in places with good, reliable governments and institutions. E.g., Minneapolis over Detroit for cold midwest cities that aren't Chicago.
- Nydhal 10y agoMany will want to raise a family, but that might be countered by the fact that more and more are unable to.
- afuchs 10y agoBloomberg measured the per capita concentration of people working in jobs or with degrees related to STEM; that is the number of people in STEM fields divided over each metro areas' entire population. Small metro areas that are dominated by a single employer, such as a college (e.g. Ann Arbor, MI; and Ithaca, NY), can be expected to score higher than larger, more diverse metros.
- rmason 10y agoOK, that explains it. The engineers are a tiny percentage of the population of the city. But compared to eight years ago the increase is sizeable. The area within a mile of the Madison building has gone from all abandoned buildings to a virtual tech city within the city. https://www.google.com/maps/place/M@dison+Building,+1555+Broadway+St,+Detroit,+MI+48226/@42.3360645,-83.0516592,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x883b2d322d10d517:0x217cfdf6d07948a8!8m2!3d42.3360645!4d-83.0494705 https://www.google.com/maps/place/M@dison+Building,+1555+Bro... The only negative is that apartment rents have gone sky high, not high by SF standards but high by Michigan standards.