4 ms·
There's a huge messaging problem here. We've baked in a considerable amount of future warming that we can't get out of, even with aggressive reduction of CO2.
by lamontcg 10y ago
There's a huge messaging problem here.
We've baked in a considerable amount of future warming that we can't get out of, even with aggressive reduction of CO2. That means that we're going to have to accept some of the costs of warming.
That doesn't mean that we should give up on reducing CO2. If we dig up all the carbon in the ground, burn all the gas, coal and oil then we wind up in a 4,000+ ppm CO2 world that the Earth hasn't seen since 40M years ago in the Eocene. In 200-300 years that would melt Antarctica. There were jungles in the Arctic back then. And it took on the order of 40M years to get here and we'll turn the clock back in a few hundred years.
Presumably I won't be around to see it, but I still would prefer that not be my generations legacy.
And we will be forced to deal with whatever the consequences no matter what so your question is a bit meaningless. The only choice we have is over how bad those consequences will ultimately be -- somewhat bad, really bad, or horrifically bad.
To be fair, its likely that horrifically bad is not on the menu since Tesla is selling cars and batteries, people are buying them, and the US military is even on board solar power since they don't like IEDs blowing up their fuel convoys -- so some mitigation will be happening no matter what the government does. But "drill baby, drill" is going to optimize for having the most costs to offset in the future.
- agumonkey 10y agoWhat I mean is when near a crash, you can spend some budget trying to brake, but you'll have to reflect on how you gonna brace and roll because it's gonna happen; not just stop at "hey we broke as hard as possible, sorry".
- antisthenes 10y ago> If we dig up all the carbon in the ground, burn all the gas, coal and oil then we wind up in a 4,000+ ppm CO2 world that the Earth hasn't seen since 40M years ago in the Eocene. In 200-300 years that would melt Antarctica The bigger problem here is that at 4,000+ ppm CO2, a good chunk of people will simply suffocate. Have you ever tried to do perform work that requires high cognitive load in a poorly ventilated room? Now multiply the effects of that x3, and realize that there's no escape from this, anywhere on the planet. You can't simply open a window and let in that fresh 400 ppm air anymore. Evolution might start selecting for individuals that are successful without higher cognitive function, aka selecting for physically fit imbeciles that can function in a 4,000 ppm CO2 world. That's a hypothetical scenario, of course. Western Civilization will be long gone before CO2 levels reach anywhere near 4k.
- agumonkey 10y agoWhat biological function would benefit from a "better" CO2 ratio ?
- antisthenes 10y agoI'm not sure I understand your question. What do you mean by "better" and why is it in quotes?
- agumonkey 10y agoIn the case CO2 density reach high levels, in an evolutionary way it may be "better" (more supply). So now I wonder, what traits could be developped it there was that much more C02 around.