3 ms·
> Wartime journalists typically don't need huge images That's pretty demeaning. Wartime photographers need quality as much as others. > Jamming every wifi cha
by toyg 10y ago
> Wartime journalists typically don't need huge images
That's pretty demeaning. Wartime photographers need quality as much as others.
> Jamming every wifi channel on both frequencies over an entire city is a crazy idea
They do blanket-block the internet though (recently Turkey, again), without which wifi loses a lot of functionality.
> You envisage a scenario where in the back of that toyota hilux
No, no. The scenario is of local state actors sitting in their aircon office, monitoring network traffic in a certain hotspot; if they identify a stream of compromising media, they censor it by corrupting the stream. Yes, TLS fixes that; but if you have that sort of crypto features, you can make sure the images are encrypted on storage media in the first place.
- jfindley 10y ago> That's pretty demeaning. Wartime photographers need quality as much as others. I'm not sure why you find this to be demeaning. The cameras used by journalists (canon 1dx ii/nikon d5) have dramatically lower resolution than cameras used by, for example, landscape photographers. This is for a number of very good reasons, but one of these is because there's no demand for anything else. 20Mp is more than enough - indeed many don't even shoot at this, but opt for smaller images for faster processing and upload. You don't need huge images for news (print or online) - in both cases the final image is small, and the DPI/resolution is low. The idea that huge image sizes somehow equate to image quality is much of the time a marketing idea - all you need is enough resolution for your output format. If that's a newspaper (online or offline), small JPEGs are fine. If your output format is a gallery image, or a building-sized advert, then yes, you want 50MP+ RAW images - but guess what? They aren't shooting for that.
- Joeboy 10y agoYou're talking about stills. The data requirements for video are massive. For me, in London, the most practical solution is still usually to hand the editor a USB drive in person. Yes, maybe heavily compressed 720p would be acceptable for some war journalism, but that's still going to be impossible to live stream reliably from almost anywhere in the world. And unless you're getting something spectacular, no mainstream TV station will want to use your crappy footage. Also remember that what you're replacing here is the transfer of pre-edited footage, of which there is likely to be a huge amount. You refer to files of "a few MB or less" elsewhere, which suggests you haven't really thought about what's required here. Edit: I don't mean to suggest this could never work, I mean satellite have been a thing for years. But at this point local storage is still vastly more practical for almost everybody. Edit2: Also I agree with brudgers that you came across as gratuitously uncivil.
- jfindley 10y ago> You're talking about stills. The data requirements for video are massive. The vast, vast, VAST majority of war photo journalism is stills. This may change in the future, but in general video journalism in war is handled very differently, has different operating parameters (for example tends to be conducted further back from the front lines, involves way more people, etc), and doesn't typically use SLRs at all. > Also remember that what you're replacing here is the transfer of pre-edited footage, of which there is likely to be a huge amount. You refer to files of "a few MB or less" elsewhere, which suggests you haven't really thought about what's required here. For some reason you appear to be shifting from photo journalism in warzones and other hostile and hazardous situations to videos taken in London... I'm not sure how this is related to the previous posts in the thread, and trying to completely shift the discussion then claiming that I haven't thought about what's required seems somewhat disingenuous at best.
- Joeboy 10y agoI accept that your argument is more reasonable if you're talking about stills, but the article is about video, and presumably that's what everybody else here is talking about. > For some reason you appear to be shifting from photo journalism in warzones and other hostile and hazardous situations to videos taken in London My point was that the measures you suggest for worst case scenarios do not even make sense in best case scenarios (London being a highly developed first world capital city).
- jfindley 10y ago> I accept that your argument is more reasonable if you're talking about stills, but the article is about video, and presumably that's what everybody else here is talking about. The article is not "about video". The article mentions both, and if you read the original letter[0], you'll find it does too. > My point was that the measures you suggest for worst case scenarios do not even make sense in best case scenarios (London being a highly developed first world capital city). Making sense for London is irrelevant. Read the actual letter[0] - it talks about, and only about "...the most dangerous parts of the world", and protecting against "authoritarian governments or criminals". Obviously, if that's not what you're doing, then different solutions might be better. 0: https://freedom.press/news/over-150-filmmakers-and-photojournalists-call-major-camera-manufacturers-build-encryption-their-cameras/ https://freedom.press/news/over-150-filmmakers-and-photojour...
- gaius 10y agoI am a former employee of a news agency you have all heard of. 2.7MP is plenty for a news image, tho' more is better - this is what our people were shooting with Nikon D1/D1h. A satellite phone at even modem-speed will blow your budget faster than you can blink if you use it to send full resolution photos...