5 ms·
Doesn't this just make the smog somebody else's problem? Unless I'm missing something - which is quite possible - it appears to be perhaps the purest expression
by throwanem 10y ago
Doesn't this just make the smog somebody else's problem? Unless I'm missing something - which is quite possible - it appears to be perhaps the purest expression yet of the "not in my backyard" concept.
- gambiting 10y agoIt does. What's worse, people who pollute in Delphi won't have any incentive to stop doing it now, the air will be clean no matter what they do, so might as well continue burning rubbish.
- Retric 10y agoSmog is made of up several things, but some of it is only stable over relatively short time frames. Move that to the upper atmosphere and it does not nessisarily end up in anyone's back yard. EX: Ozone is not heathy, but it's useful in the upper atmosphere. It's formed in part from Nox compounds, but they both end up as N2 and O2 the two main components of the atmosphere. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrogen_oxide https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrogen_oxide PS: This seems unlikely to work well. However, one option to break up the heat inversion might be to change surface coloration over a relatively large area to create large updrafts / downdrafts.
- astrodust 10y agoThe jet engine idea is absurd. Why not build a taller stack that pokes through the inversion layer? Non-trivial to engineer, but guaranteed to work if constructed. In the end using coal is probably a super bad idea. Hopefully other methods come online soon.
- baldfat 10y ago> In the end using coal is probably a super bad idea. Hopefully other methods come online soon. The only use of coal is for electricity in the power plants already there. Coal makes the majority of the fuels used to power India.
- gambiting 10y agoI'm from Poland and I would bet that majority of homes are still heated with coal every winter.
- sathackr 10y agoMy guess is the inversion layer is thicker than a taller smokestack could be practically constructed. Yes, we can build buildings almost 1km high, but that's not practical for every smoke stack in the city. A jet engine is a much cheaper and quicker to deploy option, assuming it actually works.
- gurneyHaleck 10y agoLast time I checked, a jet engine doesn't quite blow smoke entirely across a tarmac. Maybe hot air just rises anyway. Maybe kinetic influence matters less than boosting the thermal energy? But inversion layers change with the weather, so even if this works once, it may not work every time. And a band-aid that fixes this now, may only encourage more runaway growth covered up by more band-aids. Wouldn't want to actually change technologies though. Just blunder along and cobble together dust busters and blow torches and continue with business as usual. I suppose I'd only expect roughly the same from my own town supervisor...
- sathackr 10y agoI have my doubts as well as to its effectiveness, and of course, it's just a band-aid, but if the band-aid stops the pain long enough to fix the underlying issue, then go for it. Unfortunately, like many tech band-aids, once the pain goes away the problem is ignored until it flares up again.
- walshemj 10y agoIn the UK 30+ years ago we had a scool trip to Cranfield university and they had been experimenting with using tall chimneys to fire giant smoke rings into the upper atmosphere to do something similar,
- jessriedel 10y agoIn addition to the quick decay of much of the smog described by Retric, you also have a huge benefit purely from dilution. The world is really big, and most humans live clustered in <1% of its area. So even if every coal-burning plant on the planet were to implement this tech fully, it would decrease the worldwide human exposure by a couple orders of magnitude. The effect is even more extreme when you consider the vertical dimension; probably at least another order of magnitude, but hard as a layman to estimate.
- jdavis703 10y agoI don't know what it's like in India, but in the US people seem to only care about pollution that looks or smells bad. If rivers are catching fire or the sky is hazy from emissions, people seem to become more environmentally friendly. Which makes sense, you're not relying on some elite expert, but your own gut reaction. However if we start hiding pollution will that have the effect of making people care less about the effects of pollution that aren't easily detectable anymore, such as climate change?
- jessriedel 10y agoYou're making a general argument that we should impose injuries to people in order to incentivize them to not produce a negative externality. Not a transfer from them to someone else (like the government) in order to align their incentives, but literally a dead-weight loss, as if the government smashed your windshield in every 10k miles you drove in order to incentivize you to drive less. Actually, it would be more like the government randomly picked a thousand motorist on the road each day and executed them in order to disincentivize driving. Literally half a million people per year die of smog in India. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2016/05/11/air-pollution-in-india-is-so-bad-that-it-kills-half-a-million-people-every-year/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/20...
- vertex-four 10y agoExcept that this isn't the Government doing anything - it's an externality of industry operating in the area. The Government would have to do something to prevent people from seeing the issue, which is the moral opposite of what you're suggesting - it's the Government tricking people into failing to see the results of industry.
- mirekrusin 10y agoWhen Germany had problems with acid rains they did something similar (exhaust higher up) and had to stop because the only thing that happened was that acid rains spread to larger radius. Is this different because it's going to hit higher altitude?
- qbrass 10y agoIt's still a problem, but the threat level goes from the scale of a running car in a closed garage to a running car out on the road.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoResponses to pollution depend, in part, on concentration. Pour a bag of fertilizer in a little garden pond and you'll kill any fish that may have lived there, and the water will turn to an algae muck quickly. That little pond may never heal. Sprinkle the same bag widely over the surface of a large lake, and the algae, plankton, and seaweed will take up the fertilizer, grow a bit, get eaten by fish, and the whole system will return to equilibrium. Similarly, smog will eventually nucleate rain clouds and fall to earth, noxious ozone will disperse to the upper atmosphere, and volatiles will degrade. True, some effects remain (like the total amount of CO2 in the atmosphere), but there's some benefit to changing "deadly concentrations for millions of people in this small area right this moment" to "long-term effects for a large geographic area in the future". Unfortunately, many kinds of pollution would also be mitigated by being spread out temporally as well as spatially. If we could spread out our CO2 emissions over many millenia, they'd be no problem for the environment to take care of.
- sliverstorm 10y agoThe finest tradition of all humans, shared across the globe.
- barkingcat 10y agoCanada and the US have both been doing this for decades. In Canada, the Sudbury SuperStack is the cause for acid rain across the eastern seaboard of the North American Continent. And where does the garbage from large dense cities go? Into land fills, externalized, definitely not within the city limits :) There is no other place for the pollution to go other than somewhere else "not in my backyard." Unless we throw it up into space, basically every single waste management system is "not in my back yard". All this jet engine idea reveals is not covering it up. At least it's in the news.