3 ms·
The AMA or ABA is useful for censuring activities which are obviously noxious to broader society, which helps it manage its standing within society, but I think
by threatofrain 10y ago
The AMA or ABA is useful for censuring activities which are obviously noxious to broader society, which helps it manage its standing within society, but I think that is almost the entirety of the motivation, utility, and scope of professional ethics. Nevertheless I think there are advantages to organization and I hope for more of it. That being said,
You can't stop a metaphorical mass database of Muslims at a time when there's sufficient political support to do so -- and there's plenty at the moment. A lot of people see <it's just information, what do you have to hide if you're righteous> as a good enough reason, enough to generate broad acceptance.
There's also enough political support to build illegal mass surveillance machinery, and then lie to Congress about it. The aggregate of the US is okay with that, just like how the aggregate of the UK is okay with even more in-your-face surveillance. Likewise, you cannot stop the documented abuses of psychiatry when there's all too much political support for it.
There are useful reasons for a union, and I hope it so for the health of the technology community, but I don't think it can dent the issues which people mean by this "never again" political speech (big databases of people -> risk to vulnerable minorities).