4 ms·
The issue is that very few people would be willing to be treated by an unlicensed doctor. The same is not true for software and will NEVER be true for software
by stale2002 10y ago
The issue is that very few people would be willing to be treated by an unlicensed doctor.
The same is not true for software and will NEVER be true for software.
Nobody is ever going to care if the guy fiddling around with CSS and HTML to make a marketing landing page is licensed or not. Hell, I know small startups that will pay a bright high school student to do stuff like that.
Vast swafts of software engineering can be reduced to basic crud web dev that a bootcamper college dropout is capable of doing.
There is no "high school intern" level equivalent of medical work that the world has a massive shortage of.
- tptacek 10y agoThe code of ethics doesn't even have to be enforced by employers. All it takes is for a sufficient number of senior developers to adopt it, and then companies that want reliable access to senior talent will be required to reckon with their code of ethics.
- stale2002 10y agoThats a fair point, for sure. But if that is the case, senior devs would have to have some reason to join this organization, as it only seems to put you at a disadvantage. Lawyers are only in their professional org because it is enforced against them. There'd have to be some negative effect to "defecting" by not joining the org. Self enforced maybe? Devs refusing to hire other devs that aren't in the org? Possibly.
- tptacek 10y agoI'd join a professional organization that committed me to the three ethical rules I proposed downthread. Why would I do that? By your logic, it would serve only to put me at a disadvantage. And yet: I'm pretty senior as engineers go, and still happy to sign up?
- morgante 10y ago> The issue is that very few people would be willing to be treated by an unlicensed doctor. That's true today, mainly due to centuries of work to professionalize medicine. There was a time in history where much of treatment was basically the equivalent of high school crud work. More importantly, I don't think we need to worry about the random fiddlers. They're not the ones building massive databases. It's the people working at places like Google and Facebook.
- flukus 10y ago> The issue is that very few people would be willing to be treated by an unlicensed doctor. The size of the "alternative medicine" industry begs to differ.