3 ms·
Signal explicitly states they do not try or can protect you from state actors. Sure, that's easy to miss in the entire "supported by snowden" marketing, but we
by kuschku 10y ago
Signal explicitly states they do not try or can protect you from state actors.
Sure, that's easy to miss in the entire "supported by snowden" marketing, but we've had actually a debate about that on HN before.
- colordrops 10y ago> Signal explicitly states they do not try or can protect you from state actors. Where do they state that?
- kuschku 10y agoIn every single debate I had on HN where I complained that Signal reduces the privacy of people at risk of state surveillance, such as journalists, political activists, etc, because they bothered to use GPG before, and now switch - due to the marketing - to Signal, it was always said (even from OWS members themselves) that Signal is not designed to protect against that, instead, it is designed to improve the safety of the average citizen.
- colordrops 10y agoCould you provide a link to the comments? I'm currently discussing Signal with some friends and this would be helpful.
- lima 10y agoOf all the messaging apps, Signal is probably the most secure. They're just being realistical about it. If a nation-state is targeting you, relying on a particular app, no matter how secure, isn't enough and they don't want to make false promises.
- kuschku 10y agoIs it? People at risk of state surveillance would usually switch to GPG or OTR with FLOSS apps before, and usually throw proprietary stuff from their devices. Now, they use Signal. I'm not sure if that's more secure. In fact, I'd argue Signal is less secure. Moxie himself has argued before that the intention of Signal is not to be more secure than these options, but to be a solution that everyone can use that's more secure than Telegram/The old WhatsApp protocol without Axolotl/etc.