3 ms·
>> it became hard for Psychs to institutionalize people who need help. > The prospect of a society in which any psychologist can, You've mixed up psychologist
by DanBC 10y ago
>> it became hard for Psychs to institutionalize people who need help.
> The prospect of a society in which any psychologist can,
You've mixed up psychologist and psychiatrist.
It's easy to find ways that psychiatrists can detain people against their will, and force them to undergo medical treatment against their will, that don't rely on a single doctor and that have strong protections against abuse.
Something like two doctors - one of which knows the patient, plus an approved MH professional who's role is to protect the legal rights of the patient, plus free advocacy during all stages of detention to protect the legal rights, with powers of a close relative to ask for the detained person to be released; with a default position that people have capacity to make decisions about themselves, and that any limitations of capacity are limited to a single domain (I might not be able to say what happens to my money, but you should not use that to assume my capacity chose my medication is limited); with a recognition from all involved that this is a significant interference with my human rights and that we only tolerate this because it's in my best interests.
- tptacek 10y agoSame problem with psychiatrists. The psychiatrists associated with large-scale direct intake at hospitals are also extremely overworked and often not particularly sophisticated (psychiatrists who keep up with research and are effective practitioners can make more money outside the hospital system). In the very worst case, which is unfortunately common, you have chains like UHS operating mental health hospitals in numerous states with what appear to be quotas. You don't have to drive yourself to a UHS hospital to end up in one. Most hospitals, even the very good ones, don't do on-site psych; in many of them, if you show up for any psych reason, you'll be held and then transported to an affiliated mental health hospital. So, yes, there are very significant due process concerns with acute mental health care.