3 ms·
"it's directly destroying their source of dignity." I understand that. Much of family is in that boat, and I understand their perspective. I grew up poor (home
by wahern 10y ago
"it's directly destroying their source of dignity."
I understand that. Much of family is in that boat, and I understand their perspective. I grew up poor (homeless on a couple of occasions). I started working 20 hours a week at the age 14 washing dishes and cooking, and have always held a steady job, often to my own detriment (should have spent more time studying).
I understand that people in immobile economic situations struggle to maintain a sense of dignity and autonomy. But life will destroy your sense of dignity when you put yourself out there. Ask anyone who completed law school, as I did. Success and humiliation often go hand-in-hand. Poor people don't understand that well enough.
So I understand and appreciate the argument about dignity. But if my treatment of that argument seems less than sympathetic, it's because I've learned that people _should_ learn to disentangle their sense of personal dignity from their economic circumstance and social status. Appealing to their culturally-informed sense of dignity is the same excuse Islamic terrorists use to excuse their heinous acts.
At the same time, I know that that sense is real (however "wrong" it may be), and that it substantially effects the viability of UBI, just like it does peace in the Middle East. And there are similar issues that go unaddressed by UBI, such as the necessity to channel people into constructive activities. Bare economic necessity already does that, and it's not clear how that could be replaced. We don't want armies of citizen sleuths spending their idle time shooting up imaginary pizza parlor child pornography fronts.