6 ms·
Why doesn't Windows include native PDF reader support?
- p858snake 17y agoDidn't adobe have the rights for PDF till recently when they made it open source?
- jws 17y agoPDF became an open standard in 2008, but before that the format was still well specified and openly published.
- p858snake 17y agoIt may of been well known, but anyone that tried to use it would of had to abibe by the license owner's wishes. Which according to other comments was Adobe not wanting it included which meant they couldn't without a lawsuit being introduced.
- nitrogen 17y agoIn most cases, unless a patent applies, if you don't get your information from the licensor (i.e. you create a "clean room" implementation) the official licensor of a format has no say in how you distribute your product. But, with the number of software patents granted accelerating, this approach appears to be less and less viable.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoFoxit Reader?
- bmj 17y agoThat's not the point--Mac _natively_ can render a PDF. You have to download a separate reader on a Windows machine.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoConsider: "Heck, you don't even need to build it into the OS. Just make it an optional download such as your Save As PDF add-in for Office." And: "Your customers are tired of the exploits and the complications that so many of today's PDF readers include." The authors are asking Microsoft to write an application that reads PDFs and isn't Adobe Reader. My point is that such an application already exists, is free to download and use, and is both faster and more secure than Adobe's reader.
- blasdel 17y agoFoxit has had some pretty blatant security vulnerabilities -- straight up unprompted local code execution: http://blog.didierstevens.com/2010/03/29/escape-from-pdf/ http://blog.didierstevens.com/2010/03/29/escape-from-pdf/ It does a mediocre job of rendering, and isn't faster than Acrobat if you strip out all of Adobe's lame plugins (we put plugins in your plugins so you can extend while you embrace!)
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoI didn't know that about Foxit Reader; thanks for sharing. Still, there's no reason, given the author's own requirements, why a PDF reader has to come from Microsoft rather than a competent third party. Granted, Microsoft has gotten better at security in recent years, but they're hardly exemplary at it.
- a2tech 17y agoBecause Adobe pitches a fit about anything MS does to make working with PDF's free. You may not be aware of this but MS Office 2003 was supposed to have the ability to save to PDF builtin-but Adobe threw a huge hissy fit about MS cutting into their markets so MS took it out (there has been an add-on available as a download since it was released-but Adobe insisted the functionality not be included by default)
- blasdel 17y agoThey make an insane amount of money from the way that enterprises spend hundreds of dollars on Acrobat Professional licenses for every single computer. Sometimes they wise up and implement a baroque license management server where they only have to pay for a fraction of the licenses, but it still costs an insane amount of money. When it gets used, it's almost exclusively for "Print to PDF". Power Users will use it to combine PDFs, and maybe do some shitty doodling. Occasionally the awful PDF forms functionality gets used, but they usually learn their lesson (easy to make one worse than an MS Access app!) It's the calf to Microsoft's Office cash cow.
- alanh 17y agoWow. I’m not saying anything here, but it's interesting Print to PDF is such a big draw, when OS X's print dialog has included an option to save to PDF (or preview as PDF, or email as PDF, or import to X where X is Evernote, Yojimbo, etc.) for years
- dagw 17y agoMicrosoft has had print to Postscript since at least NT4, and would love to include print to PDF. However they know Adobe would kick up a massive legal fuss if they tried (like they did when MS tried to include save as PDF in office 2007). That being said you can easily download save as pdf for Office 2007 from Microsoft's homepage, and there are lots of very nice free print to pdf option available.
- omaranto 17y agoI've been using GNU/Linux for so long, I didn't realize until recently that Windows doesn't come with a virtual PDF printer. After a little searching I told some Windows using friends to install doPDF and they seem happy with it.
- bmalicoat 17y agoThis is the main thing I dislike about Windows. In OS X I constantly use PDFs: print to PDF, export as PDF, quickly preview PDFs. In Windows those things either require 3rd party software and/or way more time to launch programs.
- rbranson 17y agoNot to mention Preview is super fast and light compared to bloatware Acrobat Reader.
- DenisM 17y agoYou make "third party software" sound complicated. Here, free PDF reader with annotations, blazingly fast: http://www.foxitsoftware.com/pdf/reader/ http://www.foxitsoftware.com/pdf/reader/
- weaksauce 17y agoIn osx you get print to pdf, reorder pdf's, remove pages from pdf's, add pages to pdf's, etc... for free out of the box. In addition using skim (3rd party) you get an excellent, fast, opensource, notetaking pdf reader. Not saying that foxit is not good, I use it all the time in windows, but it is not a full featured free pdf utility.
- JadeNB 17y ago> In osx you get print to pdf, reorder pdf's, remove pages from pdf's, add pages to pdf's, etc... for free out of the box. Wow, I've been missing out! I use PDFLab to do all but the first of these tasks; I didn't realise OS X had a built-in solution. How do I do it?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- weaksauce 17y agoUse preview.app with the sidebar pulled out and you can just drag and drop pages around. Also you can delete pages from there and add in pages from other preview.app instances. You can also rotate pages from there too.
- larsberg 17y agoIsn't this the same industry that screamed bloody murder when MSFT decided to produce a free anti-virus for Windows 7?
- caf 17y agoMicrosoft produced a free antivirus for MSDOS 6.2, if memory serves.
- chaosmachine 17y agoI'd say they're probably trying to avoid another massive fine from the EU. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Microsoft_competition_case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Microsoft_compet...
- dwwoelfel 17y agoTwelve years ago, Microsoft found itself in a courtroom opposite the US Department of Justice for including native internet browsing support. The conclusion of that case was that Microsoft is not allowed to add "products" to their operating system. I think a PDF reader constitutes a product. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft
- jrockway 17y agoAnd since then, they've included anti-virus software, a firewall, video players and codecs, and so on. I don't see how a PDF reader would be any different than Windows Media Player.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sliverstorm 17y agoanti virus and firewalls are much closer to basic OS functionality- it's like self defense, but for software. That is much less objectionable than competing with Netscape was, which was the biggest software war of the time (that I know of) Or, you can look at it from the POV of firewalls and AV is needed to fight flaws in their product. Should they be prohibited from defending their own product, even if it isn't a direct patch => resolution but a prevention?
- caf 17y agoOr Zip files. Or backup/restore. Or picture viewers. Or...
- dsspence 17y agoPdf technology is a native part of Apple's drawing system Quartz in OS X: http://www.prepressure.com/pdf/basics/osx_quartz http://www.prepressure.com/pdf/basics/osx_quartz . That might explain its relative ubiquity.
- pasbesoin 17y agoThe Skim PDF reader/annotator takes advantage of this (as I understand it). Not having a Mac, I haven't tried it, but when I read about it a year or two ago, I became quite envious. http://skim-app.sourceforge.net/ http://skim-app.sourceforge.net/
- joubert 17y agoMicrosoft has a competing format: XPS
- white_eskimo 17y agoExport to PDF functionality is native in Word 2010 Beta
- jonsen 17y agoWould it reduce the amount of .docs floating around the Word Wild Web?
- barnaby 17y agoInteresting that after all this time MS still haven't fixed this bug. I mean, I realize the patch is probably a business agreement rather than some code, but still.