4 ms·
The article you linked isn't as dire as you make it out to be. It doesn't say that anyone treated for mental health issues is ineligible to own firearms, just t
by smacktoward 10y ago
The article you linked isn't as dire as you make it out to be. It doesn't say that anyone treated for mental health issues is ineligible to own firearms, just the much narrower segment of "anyone involuntarily committed to a mental institution or found to be a danger to self or others." Which seems pretty reasonable to me.
If you're holding back from seeking treatment for mental health issues because you're worried about losing your guns, don't. I can't speak for every jurisdiction, but I live in Virginia, I've suffered from and received treatment for depression, and I've had zero problems purchasing and owning firearms.
- tptacek 10y agoIn a number of states, there's a short-term prohibition on firearms purchases by people who voluntarily admitted themselves to a mental health institution. On information and belief: pretty much anyone who goes to the hospital with a panic attack, a PTSD episode, or a concern about profound depression will end up "voluntarily admitted" to a mental health institution, so this is a lot of people. I believe one of the things that makes these prohibitions constitutional is that they expire pretty quickly.
- iamatworknow 10y agoI'm in New York, which probably has the toughest gun laws in the country outside of maybe California. I've had a pistol permit and a .380 for over 3 years. I also go to a psychologist monthly for CBT and a psychiatrist every 3 months for medication. I've never harmed myself or others and I don't intend to, but I do have depression and anxiety due to some traumatic events in my past. Nobody has come asking for my gun.
- virmundi 10y agoDepends on where you are in NY. A cop sued for his guns back after he was wrongfully attacked by the State [1]. When the government takes away a person's pen as well as their right to self-defense, it will be interesting. 1- http://www.foxnews.com/us/2015/01/04/retired-cop-sues-new-york-for-confiscating-guns-after-hospital-visit-for.html http://www.foxnews.com/us/2015/01/04/retired-cop-sues-new-yo...
- iamatworknow 10y agoSounds like the exception and not the rule. >He was discharged with a diagnosis of “depression, insomnia” and then returned a short time later for a 48-hour stay. The lawsuit says that during that visit, staff erroneously listed him as an “involuntary admission,” triggering the SAFE Act reporting provision. Yeah, since it was an error in this case he shouldn't have had his guns confiscated. If your mental state is at the point where you legitimately need to be committed, however, then I agree with some of the other comments here and taking away your guns is justified. But if you're not feeling well about your job or your sex life or exhibit any general depression symptoms, gun owner or not, a story like this shouldn't dissuade you from scheduling an office visit with a mental health professional. Apples to oranges.
- tptacek 10y agoHey: since you're still commenting, can I ask again for a pointer to the $300 background check I can buy as an employer that will tell me if someone is legally allowed to purchase a gun? I'm serious about replicating this.
- Bartweiss 10y ago> anyone involuntarily committed to a mental institution or found to be a danger to self or others That "or" is crucial, and it's what makes this hideously unjust. Involuntary admission can be completely unrelated to your mental state or actions. A close friend of mine was committed because she was talking to another friend about her depression, and her phone died. He panicked and called the police. They committed her on the strength of the friend's testimony. She never intended to kill herself, she never had a plan to do so, but she spent three days in a closed psych ward regardless. Less anecdotally, Buzzfeed just did a major investigation of people institutionalized improperly and against their will to collect insurance money. You can read it here: https://www.buzzfeed.com/rosalindadams/intake?utm_term=.tarGPxnxG#.eb8nlEjEn https://www.buzzfeed.com/rosalindadams/intake?utm_term=.tarG... Short of overt fraud, very little distinction is drawn between "I guess you're not a danger now" and "you were never a danger at all to anyone". As a result, commitment can mean lifelong restriction of rights without any health basis at all.